LEAVING NEGATIVE FEEDBACK FOR A SELLER THAT CANCELS DUE TO SELLERS REGRET, ONLY FOR IT TO BE REMOVED BY EBAY.
Summary: specklehead1 expressed frustration about an eBay transaction where a seller canceled a sale post-payment, admitting it was due to 'seller's regret.' specklehead1 was unable to contact eBay support effectively and faced disappointment when their negative feedback was removed, allegedly without valid cause. lezned-toycollector explained feedback removal policies and suggested ways to engage eBay agents effectively. springyzone confirmed similar issues with eBay's handling of cancellations and feedback removal, suggesting the system often fails buyers. Other participants agreed, discussing the challenges of maintaining faith in eBay's feedback system. Despite eventual contact with an eBay agent who admitted a mistake, specklehead1 remains skeptical about the platform's transparency.
I recently reported a Seller to Ebay for cancelling a sale after I had paid for the item, then refunded.
I contacted the seller requesting why had the sale been cancelled ?.
The seller replied " sorry mate but I can't let it go for that price."
I replied to the seller informing that I had paid in good faith and that it is a breach of Ebay policy to cancel a sale due to Sellers regret.
I then reported the issue to Ebay and left appropriate negative feedback as warning to other buyers. The seller replied "get a life ".
Now after 4 days I have received no contact from Ebay and to add insult to injury the negative feedback has been removed, even though the feedback was accurate.
At all times in the negotiating process I remained professional and polite.
How can you have faith in a system that operates like this ?.
I understand Ebay may well wish to protect a Seller due to "it potentially affecting their sales ", but how does this help keeping an honest and open feedback channel ?.
My reason for posting here is the principal of the matter and protecting the buyer, because if all sellers became aware there are no consequences for cancelling a sale where does that leave us ?.
Sure at the end of the day it is just a sale and we move on, but this cannot be encouraged via no consequences.
I rarely leave negative feedback and as a seller avoid negative feedback by leaving a good service for my customers.
Am I missing something here?,
Please share your thoughts.
springyzone
@fil-5665
@theinkcentre
I agree ebay makes a lot of mistakes.
I think that in the majority of cases, feedback should stand.
But I also think there has to be the ability to remove it in some instances.
I once saw feedback that was full of terrible abuse & I have seen a lot of negative feedback that was clearly not warranted or else was a mistake. For example, if a buyer gives a negative but makes a comment such as 'Fantastic item, great seller', then I'd assume they ticked the wrong box.
sandypebbles
Totally agree @springyzone
Back when I was selling, I got a neg and had it removed, the neg feedback?
sticky tape on packaing was upside down
Seriously
springyzone
I've seen a lot of feedback that I think should have been removed.
One reasonably common one would be that the item wasn't as as big as expected. On clothing you might understand, but I've seen it applied to all sorts of other objects-ribbon, decorations, paper products etc, where the dimensions were clearly listed in the ad.
As for sticky tape upside down, I am struggling to know whay they meant. Sticky side up? Sometimes tape can get a bit twisted but if the item arrived as described and intact, it is ridiculous they would even care.
countessalmirena
I could imagine being concerned if the sticky tape were applied sticky side up instead of properly adhering to the parcel to secure it… but upside down? Did they not like the pattern…? Weird!
sandypebbles
No, just ordinary, clear sticky tape
Just an individual with too much time on their hands and a generic trouble maker
specklehead1
OPSpot on, that is using common sense, some people just dont think some times either, e.g give wonderful glowing reviews ,then leave neutral feedback, this sometimes just defies logic.
In my instance Ebay its self stated they Ebay made made the mistake by removing the feedback, citing "human error ", so there is no excuses for not reinstating the original negative feedback. The fact is Ebays number one priority is volumes of sales, so if the accurate negative feedback even if valid is going to affect sales, we cant have this.
Thankyou for your imput.
springyzone
@specklehead1
If ebay really wanted to, they could reinstate feedback if they felt there was a mistake.
And if feedback broke some guideline or rule, they could even automatically notify the buyer, let them know why it was rejected and allow them to resubmit it once modified.
But they don't seem to and I am guessing the reason is that disputes would normally be about negative feedback & ebay would much prefer to have no negative feedback from buyers if they can manage it as it might turn off other buyers. So you're right. They don't like anything to impact sales.
theinkcentre
This is becoming all to common for eBay. They do not seem to abide by their own rules.
fil-5665
Always thought removal of feedback was wrong
springyzone
@specklehead1
You are correct in that sellers can lie about the reasons for cancellation.
In fact, I am surprised the seller even replied to you and put the real reason in writing.
From what lezned wrote, I am assuming that the seller must have claimed you requested a cancellation or that there was a problem with your address.
In my opinion, ebay should have some automatic type system, easy to use & easy for ebay to monitor, where a buyer interaction with that and only that counts as a cancellation request. And if that has not been ticked, it should be impossible for sellers to mark it as such.
It would not be too hard to do.
It seems that some buyers do request cancellations in private messages so maybe when someone goes to send a PM, there could be an automatic drop down menu with 'I wish to request a cancellation' there as well.
But this is ebay, full of holes. I think the salt in the wound though is when the neg feedback is removed (been there, had that happen to me too) when you know it is fully justified.
You ask how you can have faith in the feedback system. Basically, you can't. You now ned to check ebay automated positive feedback as bad sellers can get a heap of that.
e_purchasing
What was the item? item number?
specklehead1
OPJAPANESE TYPE 90 HELMET 158336227825
lezned-toycollector
What reason did the seller use for cancellation? They only get three reasons to choose from... two of which result in neutral/negative feedback removal (usually picked up by the bots), and the third (out of stock) results in a seller defect.
If they didn't use the "out of stock" reason (which is quite common as sellers try to avoid defects), and you don't want your feedback to be removed, you would have to contact an eBay agent and have them manually change the reason for cancellation prior to leaving neutral/negative feedback.
I know it's probably not what you want to hear, but it sounds as though you didn't do this, so as you were already aware, this resulted in your negative feedback breaching the feedback policy and subsequently being removed.
specklehead1
OPThankyou for your feedback,comments. For me the chain of events was rock solid. The seller used the excuse item mislaid or damaged, BUT then cheeky enough to add a bit of dumb honesty or just plain cocky and fessed up. This was the point. As for Ebay I have lost total respect for them as an agency, why ?. You LITERALLY CANNOT contact them and speak with a real person, Any of the listed phone numbers are not connected. I had all the proof for them to see, all the messages and the fact there had been 7 bidders and 9 bids laid tells you there was some interest. At the end of the day the system is a mockery, especially if you cant leave negative feedback in this instance. A big wake call about AI, it follows its little Algorithms and that's it, in this instance it appears to have deemed "refunded, therefore not entitled to leave negative feedback", no looking at rest of evidence, I will lay money no human imput.
lezned-toycollector
You LITERALLY CANNOT contact them and speak with a real person,
Unless, of course, you try to contact them. All it takes is to click on the "Help" hyperlink found at the top and/or of every page, then click on the big blue "Contact us" button. Typing "speak with agent" into the chat helps to minimise operator input and speed up the process.
The seller used the excuse item mislaid or damaged
This is NOT a cancellation reason, but rather, a refund reason. This does not result in automated feedback removal, so your negative feedback must have breached the feedback policy in some other way.
If you have a read through the feedback policy on the help pages, and take note of the reasons for removal, you should be able to identify why yours was removed.
specklehead1
OPI have tried engaging Ebay, but due to the BOT styled system every time I ask it put me through to speak with agent it just runs me around in circles, very frustrating. Given they say once negative feedback has been removed it cant be reinstated policy, whats the point.
From what I have read , the only possible reason for negative feedback removed was because the seller gave a valid reason for cancelling the sle and gave a full refund, even though they didn't have a valid reason for cancelling the sale and by their own admission in message real reason for not honouring the sale was due to "sellers regret".
lezned-toycollector
I have tried engaging Ebay, but due to the BOT styled system every time I ask it put me through to speak with agent it just runs me around in circles
The bot generates its responses based on operator input. The only reason it would ever be able to run anyone in circles is if they choose to allow it to do so. If you don't like the results being generated by your input, the remedy is extremely simple - change your input. It's not rocket surgery. I can honestly say that every last time I have typed "speak with agent" in chat, I have been connected with an agent within the next 1-3 steps. Typing "speak to agent" takes a little longer, as it is akin to typing "speak at agent" and deemed to be impolite.
From what I have read , the only possible reason for negative feedback removed was because the seller gave a valid reason for cancelling the sle and gave a full refund
Well you clearly haven't read anywhere near enough on the subject of feedback removal. There are 31 different reasons itemised on the feedback policy page - yes, 31... and again, the seller DIDN'T cancel the sale at all, but rather, provided a refund.
Please follow my previous advice, and read up on the feedback policy. I'm certain you'll find your reason for removal somewhere within.
specklehead1
OPI have just finally managed to speak with an agent via chat line and basically the outcome was this. The agent informs me this "if I had reviewed this case, I wouldn't have removed it, it was factual and correct, in this instance Ebay has made a human error ". The original reason for removing negative negative feedback was I quote "to try and maintain good working relationships between buyer and seller ", what a cop out !!!. Let me tell you reading between the lines this operator was not happy with how this has been handled. Anyhow we move on, i for one have no faith in the transparency of how this matter has been conducted.
springyzone
Glad you managed to get through. It can be a bit of a rigmarole as I don't think most casual buyers would know to type in 'speak with agent'. Even without doing that though, you can eventually get through to a human if you tick no, this has not solved my problem or something similar that comes up (been a long while since I needed to use it).
The system will try like crazy to solve things with AI but if it doesn't work, will eventually hand you over to a real person.
I had to laugh at their reason for removing feedback-to maintain good relationships? More likely to make a buyer even more annoyed than they were, but the thing is, I don't know that all buyers necessarily find out their feedback has been taken down. I never realised it had happened to my feedback for a while till I checked to see how my bad seller was doing. And I had even provided photos. It was all factual.
It would be interesting to see if your seller ever does get the price he is after. If he had 7 bidders, he had a lot more than some other auctions get.
specklehead1
OPThanks for all your constructive advice.