Seller cancelled order for Best Offer citing item not working
Summary: The discussion revolves around a seller canceling an order for an item sold under a 'Best Offer' claiming it was not working. ryz05 is likely the buyer affected by the cancellation and engages in multiple exchanges with other participants including twyngwyn, davewil1964, and springyzone, seeking advice or sharing opinions about the cancellation. The interactions include expressions of dissatisfaction and queries about the seller's obligation in terms of item functionality and transaction cancellation terms. Other participants such as gutterpunkz05 and countessalmirena contribute to understanding the situation, providing insights or similar experiences.
Hi
I recently won a best offer an item where the item was advertised as working (and ironically had a video of the item working).
A few days later I got a message from the seller saying
"I have some bad news, I got the remote out of storage to ship it to you, but unfortunately, when I tested it, it did not work!I have put new batteries and cleaned it (no corrosion), but it still did not work!so I am going to cancel your order."
I mentioned that the item wasn't cancelled yet so please action now (which i now regret)
I later offered to purchase the item (under the idea reversal of the cancelation with a partial refund was possible) and was told;
"Hello, no I will try to fix it and relest it as working.thanks"
My first thought is that the seller had second thoughts on the price they accepted the offer for and wanted to resell for a higher price.
Is this suspiscious activity from the seller? Why not give the buyer the option of waiting for the item to be fixed, rather than re-selling.
countessalmirena
The “clock ticking” aspect is to go with the fact that eBay can and do take action against sellers who don’t send an item within the required timeframe. Action can include seller having their account limited, fees increased, etc.
If the seller has been honest with you about the item having a problem, they probably did the best thing in cancelling.
If the seller hasn’t been honest, they’ve gone about it in an ineffective way; they could have cancelled with a reason that wouldn’t have cost them anything… but they didn’t. This is counter effective if they were unhappy about the offered price.
My own perspective is that I’d accept the seller’s explanation in good faith.
ryz05
OPI've accepted that point, but not sure why my counterpoint to the 'clock ticking' is getting overlooked here. Takes all of 2 seconds to give buyer an option, that suggestion isn't unreasonable and pretty common when an item isn't available.
Considering I've sent 4 follow-up messages in the last few days without reply, inclined to believe the seller has made a one-off action that is potentially disingenuous and is usually reasonable.
Happy to disagree with the regular posters here, I understand this ultimately isn't the place to get potential issue resolved and is more about generic advice for those who aren't familar with eBay.
Happy to leave it there. No-need for further replies. Thanks for your time everyone.
sandypebbles
It is a place to get factual advice, rather than you contacting eBay and getting a scripted response which makes false promises just to get rid of you
Far from generic advice, thank you, hundreds upon hundreds upon hundreds of issues have been resolved though the information/links/advice provided by other members
If you do not want other members to reply, you need to self report and ask a mod to lock the thread
Someone with a similar issue may find factual information helpful, even if it is not what you wanted to hear
ryz05
OPRespectfully disagree. Like I said, happy to leave it there.
gutterpunkz05
The joys of dealing with electronics, one minute they work fine, the next they don't, and then you get into smart electronics that fail to recognize/diagnose any faults, followed by a catastrophic failure.
countessalmirena
I’ll respond re this point as it seems I wasn’t clear in explaining.
Irrespective of how nice or reasonable a buyer may be, and what they may say in a message, the seller would still be open to a punitive outcome. If a listing states the item is in working order, and the buyer receives it in non-working order, the listing description trumps buyer messages automatically. eBay’s processes are bot-driven. A claim of not as described is going to go badly for the seller in this scenario.
Ditto for the question of delayed shipping.
An offer to parley post-sale isn’t a good idea in most circumstances. eBay is set up to follow the usual pattern of a transaction.
There is every incentive for a seller to cancel the sale in that case. Seller cannot provide you with the item as agreed prior to the sale. Proceeding would simply be fraught with pitfalls.
ryz05
OPThat's actually a reasonable explanation, I guess it's the flip side of buyers potentially taking advantage of decent sellers. Shows the system isn't perfect and doesn't cover every scenario. It's a shame that the considering the fees paid by selling don't go towards better support and systems for both sellers and buyers.
That being said, would have preferred the seller try and say their concerns rather than completely ghosting me though after the cancellation. I've had a lot of good experiences over messages the last couple of weeks so it was a shame to go through this, especially with someone with a 100% feedback rating.
imastawka
Considering I've sent 4 follow-up messages in the last few days ....
The seller may now look at you as a problem buyer.
If they didn't reply after the first message - leave it alone.
4 messages would be annoying to me.
You are obviously desperate to get this item because you got it for a bargain price from what I can see.
Don't be surprised if/when the seller re-lists and you are blocked from buying.
Just sayin'
ryz05
OPBought it from elsewhere today and happily paid more without fuss. Actually had some fun interaction with the seller over messages as well.
Would have thought this experience would demonstrate id have no interest in purchasing from the seller I had the issue with.
springyzone
Glad you were able to find what you wanted elsewhere and that the transaction went well this time.
I had another thought about that first seller.
Although he told you he intended to try to fix the item and relist later, he may not have been 100% sure he would succeed.
From your description, he had already had a go at that, trying the more straightforward stuff-new batteries, a clean. But there was something else wrong, something he had not got to the bottom of yet.
So it wouldn't be a good idea for him to keep you waiting around.
I would imagine that once he had cancelled and refunded, he didn't want to get into any private message discussion where it might look as if he was in any sort of negotiation to reinstate a sale off ebay.
Sometimes some sales just don't turn out so well on ebay, it can be disappointing, but at least look on the bright side, you got your money back fairly quickly and could move on.
ryz05
OPExactly. Much worse things in the world to be worried and concerned about.
ryz05
OPWow. Like to think I've been respectful to everyone's here and haven't outwardly bashed the seller. I'm trying to figure out the logic and just met with passive aggressive answers with little substance.
Take care guys be happy.
imastawka
I have another scenario in this case.
It's been known that ebay has accepted an offer automatically on behalf of a seller before now.
We have had sellers coming here and complaining about this happening to them.
I'm not saying that this is what happened, but it's a possibility, and a $25 discount may have been too much for this particular seller.
ryz05
OPThat would make sense, but if that was the case, the seller would have messaged prior. There was a few back and forths with the offers to.
springyzone
We can't know exactly what happened but let's consider the option that the seller was telling the truth.
If that happened to me (as a seller) I would not be prepared to post the item off & then give a partial refund.
I'd be worried the buyer would later open a claim, stating the item was unrepairable and the ad said it was working etc etc etc
The seller could argue the buyer had been given a partial refund as compensation but the buyer could counter it with the fact they were told it was all fixable.
You as seller may be competent at fixing things but you can't assume all buyers will know what to do.
If it has a fault, the seller would be better off to fix it and advertise it then, or relist, describing the fault in detail and leaving it to a buyer to decide if they can fix it or not.
You ask why the seller could not give you the option of waiting for it to be fixed, but the clock was ticking. They only had a limited time in which to post it off to you so that you would get it before the expected delivery date & maybe they weren't keen to put themselves under pressure to do it that day or the next, maybe they thought they might need a bit of time or prefer to tackle it the following weekend or whatever. Maybe they wanted to fix, leave it a few days and re check it was still working. We don't know.
I had a look at the item number. Your seller is a steady seller, not big volume but has been on ebay long term and has a 100% rating with some great feedback.
I don't get the feel this seller would advertise as best offer and then later decide not to accept the offer, he seems more experienced than that. I'd actually be inclined to believe him, I think he has probably been honest with you.
ryz05
OPMost of what you say makes sense, but I don't understand the "clock ticking" point.
You simply ask the buyer "I can fix it but it make take some time, or if you're not happy with that I can refund you now" that would have been the most sensible option. Takes all of two seconds to send that message.
Just to re-clarify this was an item where the offer was ACCEPTED and PAID and then the order was cancelled after the fact. I think because the item was accepted $25 cheaper that the initial buy it now price is why the seller has second thoughts.
I can't leave feedback for this seller (I don't have a massive issue with this as it's open for buyers too that can be idiots) but really it's a loophole for people for sellers to change their mind without consequence.
Again, if you feel under pressure about time constraints, put better energy into maintaining your inventory better. Saves everyone time and hassle.
ryz05
OPeBay will always favor the sellers who run as a business, it is what it is.
After some thought, going to take the high road and let it go. Left a polite and respectful message to the seller advising to take better care of inventory for the future.
sandypebbles
eBay are all about the buyer
Just because eBay are not going to make the seller send an item does not mean they are looking out for sellers, and this seller in question has less feedback than you do
And as you have been told, there will be consequences for the seller for cancelling with the reason they did
You say you are tsking the high road but your comments here do not reflect that at all
ryz05
OPI've had an instance where I requested to cancel an order to a seller via m message, I I didn't initiate that on my end, so I'm assuming that seller copped fees? Seems odd doesn't it that they didn't complain doesn't it?
Not trying to vent here but I really don't understand the point of this forum. eBay staff don't obviously view it.
I have one seller telling me to leave feedback on a cancelled item, and another exposing a loophole if I'm unsatisfied about a sale I decide to make. Because I can simply make it up and there is no way to verify it.
davewil1964
The point of this forum, like most member fora, is to get advice from people with more experience than you. There are plenty here who know all the ins and outs of eBay. Far more knowledge than call centre staff reading from scripts.
ryz05
OPTotally agree which is why I get brand new stuff from Amazon and split my second hand niche stuff from Facebook Marketplace/Gumtree/eBay.
davewil1964
Your point?
Your complaint is as a buyer. I think.
But you were expecting, before you agreed to my point, eBay to respond.
ryz05
OPThat at least for brand new items, better to go through Amazon, because as you said, the community have more knowledge than eBay staff. Whereas you get a direct line to Amazon straight away via call or chat.
I double checked my messages and can't see where I was expecting an eBay staff member to respond.
davewil1964
Not trying to vent here but I really don't understand the point of this forum. eBay staff don't obviously view it.
You inferred you were wanting an eBay response
ryz05
OPI still don't, and if I were going to be honest it would come off as combatitive or unappreciative (as noted by the accepted solution and response to that post to the user who took the time to give a well written response whom I very much appreciate) I don't really want to waste mine or anyone elses negative energy, so again will leave it there.
twyngwyn
what is the item number?
ryz05
OP226244181966
twyngwyn
They could be old pics & video or they have sold off eBay or they want a higher price....you will never know unless they attempt to sell again
ryz05
OPThey've openly stated they are going to relist the item.
twyngwyn
leave them appropriate feedback , watch their listings & move on
gutterpunkz05
They have given you a reason for cancelling, and they are entitled to relist, repaired or not.
They are about $12 out of pocket for ebays FVF, which will not be refunded to them. As such one would expect any relist price to be higher to recoup fees and any repair costs.
You have no future entitlements, first offer, discount etc, in relation to the item.