Seller failed to send item after auction.
Auction completed , payment made & seller declined to post item but refunded money. Seller then asked for more money to complete sale in an email message. Reported seller's conduct to eBay but eBay is blind at the wheel & taking no action. Seller provided false reasons for the cancellation and then readvertised the item for sale.
anastasios41
9 comments
*casey*
While we can all sympathise with a new seller who started with a 0.99 cent auction, I think what also needs to be mentioned is that, apart from the seller not being new to eBay, a member for 7 years with plenty of time to read up on the rules and / or have a look at how auctions were going these days:
1) The seller knew how to refund
2) The seller knew how to cancel a transaction using a false reason
and more importantly, the seller asked for more money outside of eBay.
If an inexperienced buyer had actually paid outside of eBay, they would have lost all protection against an item not received or not as described.
And if the buyer had then come to the boards upset because they'd lost their money, they would have been told how silly they were, it was their own fault, and they should have known the rules.
Knowing the rules works both ways.
springyzone
I agree with all you say there.
This thread actually got me musing about how people perceive feedback as I was surprised to see the feedback would be taken as a hostile buyer. I would have taken it as an upset or angry buyer, but with a valid reason.
For me (and I am a buyer only on ebay these days), the feedback that frustrates me most is the sort that says "Terrible seller, avoid". It begs the question-why? What did they do wrong?
The most useful type of feedback, for me, is one that gives some detail. Anastasios, from what I can see, does generally try to give detailed & accurate feedback. Enough anyway so that a potential buyer could make their mind up as to what the problem was and who was at fault.
I noticed that he/she generally comments on product, communication, packaging plus delivery times. These are all of buyer interest. He is also fair in that if the problem was delivery time , at least he still gives a positive, he doesn't mark down the seller for it. So all in all, I'd be inclined, as a customer, to take notice of his feedback. Maybe it would not stop me buying from that seller but what it would do is alert me to the fact that if the auction was running at 99c, I'd be likely to suffer a cancellation.
It is also a record of the seller's behaviour. You'd expect that after having an auction bomb out at 99c and having to cancel, and getting neg feedback to say start at a price you are willing to sell at, a seller would learn a lesson but nope, this seller seems to have listed the item at 99c a second time.
springyzone
Although a seller cannot set a reserve on most item categories, there is no reason sellers can't start their auction at a price they would be willing to sell at. No one is twisting their arm to start at 99c & it is a stupid move to do so, in my opinion.
I know ebay hints to sellers to start low to get excitement building but I don't think that necessarily works.
Ebay cannot make the seller send you the item but yes, once you complained, if they could see the message you were sent, the seller should have been sent a warning that it is against the rules to privately ask for further payments. Then maybe ebay could also send a link to the selling instructions pages.
They send warnings for lots of other issues so I think this would warrant a stock warning too.
If the seller knows enough about ebay to know how to make a refund and how to provide a false reason for a cancellation, then they should know enough to realise lots of auctions don't go much past 99c so it is a risk they would be taking. It is not that I don't have some sympathy for new sellers but I think if people don't read up the rules, they need to cop some of the consequences. It's a learning experience.
You've done what you can, so move on I guess.
You've caused that seller's feedback to fall to 91.7% and in my view, that is fair enough. Unlike others, I see no problem with your feedback in that it makes it totally clear exactly what happened. The word reserve is not accurate but most other buyers will know what you meant-that the seller should have started higher.
sandypebbles
What is your question for other members?
Did it feel good to neg a brand new seller on their first ever sale?
There is no reserve on eBay so why suggest something that is not possible in your feedback?
Anyone reading the feedback you left is likely to see you as a hostile and unreasonable buyer
You also could have communicated with the seller and explained to them how selling works
anastasios41
OPMate, the seller clearly failed to act ethically and follow eBay auction rules.
The seller deserved my negative feedback 100%, especially when making false claims in regards to the sale cancellation and then seeking more money in a separate email sent via eBay, which there is a record of it.
I'm not going to communicate with a seller any further who acted in such as stupid manner.
As for me being a hostile & unreasonable buyer, I will let my record speak for itself.
If the buyer wanted more money, he should have started the auction at a minimum sale price ( I assume that is possible).
How you can possibly support this seller's conduct defies any logic.
sandypebbles
I am not your mate
I pointed out how your comment on your neg for a brand new looks to anyone reading it as a buyer which is what it is
Your telling the seller in the feedback you left that they should have set a reserve for example, there is no such thing
You have no idea if eBay turned a blind eye since they are not about to tell you if they did anything, they are not going to disclose to you if they pinged the seller's account or if they gave the seller a defect or longer holds on their funds
You could have contacted them and pointed out their seller obligations, would have taken a couple of seconds had you copy and pasted the spiel
And I did not 'defend' the seller's actions , simply pointed out your response to what happened
Not the sort of reaction record I would want the public seeing. Especially the 'advice' about setting a reserve price
Plus, the fact that buyers can only be given positive feedback and positive comments, it does not mean a thing
springyzone
*casey*
A new clueless seller who started with a 0.99 cent auction.
I doubt eBay will do anything at all.
You have your refund and left feedback, and although annoying, there's not much else you can do.
*casey*
And just to add after looking at your feedback left for the seller, there's no option to add a reserve price in that category