Erin Patterson: Mushroom Killer — appeal verdicts
Summary: The discussion focuses on Erin Patterson's failed appeal against her conviction and increased sentence to life without parole. countessalmirena details the court's decision and highlights Justice McLeish's remarks on Patterson's deceptive conduct. springyzone expresses approval of the sentence but criticizes inconsistencies in the justice system, comparing it with other cases involving youth crime and a young driver. Both participants agree that the justice system is unbalanced, with leniency in handling youth offenses and tougher penalties in other cases. They express concern about the likelihood of reoffending in both youth crimes and Patterson's case, noting the latter's lack of remorse.
Today Erin Patterson’s appeal has been denied.
Seven grounds for an appeal against her conviction were brought by her legal team. Five were rejected, but leave to appeal was granted on the two remaining grounds: the jury accommodation issue, and the admissibility of mobile phone data.
However, both grounds were then unsuccessful. Erin Patterson’s appeal has failed.
The Court of Appeal judges, Justice Stephen McLeish, Justice Lesley Taylor and Justice Peter Kidd were unambiguous in their judgement.
The DPP has also appealed to have the sentence increased as it was “manifestly inadequate”. The sentence was life with non-parole period of 33 years. The Crown were successful, and the sentence has been increased to life without parole.
Justice McLeish says Erin Patterson's conduct was characterised by "an elaborate series of deceptions".
He raises the false cancer claim, the destruction of evidence, the planning of the lunch and the "cruel breach of trust" of her relatives.
Justice McLeish says the non-parole period will be set aside, and that the prosecution's appeal for a harsher sentence is successful.
He says Patterson's conduct deserves to be "denounced in the strongest terms", and it is inappropriate for parole to be an option.
So that’s that.
countessalmirena
OP@springyzone It’s certainly not balanced.
Youth offences are obviously problematic. In Victoria criminal behaviour by teenagers seems to be handled with an eye to minimising its severity on the basis that the offenders are kids and we must not throw their future away. That - in my view - is missing the point, and it’s resulting in teaching such offenders that they can get away with violence and dishonesty and antisocial behaviour. Over and over again.
The driver case you mentioned… problematic. I’d say the judge probably thought the young man did know what had happened, and in failing to come forward he made things worse for himself. Who knows? I suppose he would try to seek an early restoration of his licence after a while … and it’s possible he would get it if he keeps his nose clean.
Re E.P. … I don’t know that she’d be at zero risk of acting criminally again. The lack of remorse is worrying.
springyzone
I don't think anyone is zero risk.
EP I think generally would not be a risk for the general public or strangers, though I wouldn't rush to accept a dinner invitation.
The young man I think probably didn't know exactly what he hit and apparently had very little damage to his car. He should have come forward once he heard the news. But I don't believe for a second he intentionally hurt anyone & the risk of reoffending as in deliberately running anyone over I'd say is very low.
I believe the woman was probably committing suicide by car.
The risk of youths reoffending with machetes once they have deliberately done it is about 95% in my opinion. That should count for something.
How about we give them home detention for 10 years, can we imagine the outcry.
countessalmirena
OPThat sounds likely ftom what you’ve described, @springyzone Poor woman… but it isn’t fair to involve a third party in the manner of death, if that’s the case.
Ha, yes. They’re not going to stop their violent behaviour if they see it isn’t dealt with in a way that makes them ashamed of what they’ve done. (In my opinion.) Instead it seems to be glorified among their peers, encouraged by overseas interests using and grooming youths to behave criminally on command, and gets them likes and views on social media. That’s a whole separate topic, isn’t it?!!! How to stop youth crime? 🤷❓⁉️🤨
And… yes. obviously none of us would want a meal prepared by Ms Patterson. I’d bet that she’s done something before, something underhanded designed to cause pain or harm to someone she deemed to be an enemy. Not murder, but I suspect she had previously already broken the moral boundary that keeps most of us from physically harming others when we’re angry or upset or feeling hurt by them. (Planning those murders didn’t come out of nowhere.)
That’s what most disturbs me. She wanted her husband dead and didn’t mind one little bit if there was collateral damage. In fact, she was counting on it. If he thwarted her by turning down the lunch invitation, no matter - he could just suffer the death of his family members, and possibly be killed in another manner later. Cold, cold attitude. I feel - still - that she’s only sorry she was caught, and if released she would inevitably be hurt by or take umbrage at other people, and would want to be avenged, even if the hurt was over spilt milk. And then … and then … a better poison plan… 🤢☠️
springyzone
I suspect Erin has something in common with the machete youths.
I think she probably had tried it before. Her husband had an unexplained illness previously, if I recall.
So she tried something, it worked & she faced no consequences.
Why wouldn't she try again, she thought she was on a winner.
Same with the machete lot. They try a little theft, a little violence & it is highly successful. Even if they get caught, they get released-hundreds of times if need be.
I think their attitude is probably every bit as cold as Erin's and maybe more dangerous in a way as their attacks could target anyone. They don't care.
Whereas I think Erin would probably just target people who are related in some way to her.
springyzone
I'm fine with her sentence.
However, I am amazed at just how severe our justice system can be when it wants to be.
Here is a woman who committed some murders and now has life in prison, which is how it should be.
There is often debate about the purpose of prison; punishment or rehabilitation. I think it probably should be a bit of both.
In Erin's case, I very much doubt she would reoffend if released. I don't see her as a threat to the general public as such.
That doesn't mean I think she should be released as there need to be consequences.
There was also recently the case of a young man who was driving at night-sober, under the speed limit, who hit something on the road. It turned out to be a woman who was kneeling or bent down on the road and had been there for 4 minutes,so she wasn't moving & I think that is relevant as movement makes things more visible.
At the time he wasn't sure what he hit, thought it was an animal and kept going. Found out later, probably from news, it was a woman and didn't go in to police.
Now I am not saying he should get off scot free either, but I think the accident was clearly not his fault. It can be very hard to see anything dark at night, especially if it is on a dark surface such as roadway and low to the ground.
But his sentence originally had a non parole period of 8 months plus his driver's licence has been cancelled for 10 years. He is now on a good behaviour bond but personally I don't believe he was driving carelessly as such. I think 10 years & no licence is excessive myself.
Then jump to this week in Melbourne when machete wielding youth fought a family for 20 minutes as he tried to break into their home. Turns out he had only been free for a week after being on similar rampages through quite a few other homes in the area before that. Well known to police.
So he can attack and threaten people with a machete, he can steal cars, he can do what he likes and he gets 48 days in remand and that's it?
All I am saying is the justice system isn't balanced.