Ebay might be the most incompetent organisation I've ever dealt with.
Summary: A participant initiated a discussion expressing frustration with eBay, describing it as the most incompetent organization they have dealt with. Multiple participants joined in, sharing their own negative experiences and challenges they faced while dealing with eBay. The conversation took turns exploring the inefficiencies and difficulties in eBay's customer service and other operational aspects. Participants empathized with each other, providing a platform to voice their dissatisfaction and concerns with the organization.
I received a neutral feedback from a buyer saying their item didn't work. It was an HDMI cable which I've sold over 100 of. Even though I knew it was almost certainly not a problem with the cable, I apologised to the buyer and issued a full refund. Several days later I noticed I had a defect for the sale for cancelling the order for being 'out of stock'. I appealed the defect informing Ebay that this was not the case and providing details of the situation. I received reply saying that the defect was not eligible for removal. In over 20 years of business I have never encountered an organisation as incompetent was Ebay. It's baffling that they are still in business.
springyzone
It does sound unfair.
I don't think they always listen properly or else don't take any notice, just keep to their own script.
You were punished for being too kind and accommodating.
But your problem could stem from the way you 'cancelled' the sale to ebay, saying you were out of stock. From what I have read, that often leads to a defect.
I'm wondering if you would almost be better off saying to buyers like this that you will issue a postage label and full refund on return of the item. Have to admit that as a buyer, I would want to do that though through an ebay claim. I know you'd probably still get a defect but at least you'd have your item back.
sawil4629
OPYeah I hear you, however I didn't 'cancel' the order. I simply provided a refund. It's almost unbelievable that Ebay get these things wrong so often.
twyngwyn
I don’t know how it works now, but years ago, the advice on this forum was ‘never refund the full amount’……keep 30c for instance.
Does anyone know if that still works?
lezned-toycollector
Yep. I learnt this the hard way. Full refund = Out of stock. The eBay agent actually had the audacity to tell me that I was providing a poor buyer experience by gifting items. Apparently it makes a buyer feel awful if they receive anything for free.
The way things are set up now, any seller initiated refund for the full amount will always encounter a defect for "Out of stock", and eBay won't remove the defect.
Just use the reason "Postage discount" and refund all but 3¢. That way eBay still get their 30¢ for the transaction, so you won't get a defect.
If you want to issue a full refund, to avoid a defect it has to be done through a request - or - you can cancel the transaction and use the reason "Issue with buyer's delivery address".
gutterpunkz05
I must be doing something wrong, recently had a buyer advise me that contents of a purchase was well short of that listed and indicated by the packaging. After verifying that there was in fact a problem with the item contents, I issued the buyer a full refund immediately, The sale was not cancelled, reason for refund was other adjustment and ebay included there fees as part of the refund, including the non refundable 33c, and no defect recorded.
What your buyer paid
What you earned
lezned-toycollector
In my experience, the reason "Other adjustment" defaults to "Out of stock" if a full refund is given. That is the exact process which caused my initial problem.
davewil1964
any seller initiated refund for the full amount will always encounter a defect for "Out of stock",
Absolute garbage.
I've refunded in full using 'buyer requested' and 'Problem with buyer's address'.
No issues at all. They get refunded, I get my fees back. Simple.
The key is the reason for the refund, and damaged qualifies for a defect.
lezned-toycollector
No you haven't. Neither of those reasons are available for a refund.
They are, however, available options when you cancel a transaction... which, had you read my previous post, you would know I already stated as much.
You can call it garbage all you like, but what I posted is 100% fact. If you provide a full refund using any of the available reasons at all, it WILL default to "Out of stock". However, the postage adjustment option will not default to "Out of stock" if the order is not completely refunded.
You do understand the difference between a refund and a cancellation, don't you.
lezned-toycollector
The screenshot disappeared from my previous post...
Even the reason "Buyer cancelled" defaults to "Out of stock" for a full refund. Yes, I've tried that one too.
3 of the 7 reasons shouldn't create a defect - but they do if you refund the total amount, and the defect will show as "Out of stock".
gutterpunkz05
I refunded the full amount, ebay refunded there component in full, and no defect has been applied. If the reason for refund had defaulted to out of stock, then ebay would have kept there 33c fixed order fee and only refunded the FVF (variable component) and a defect would apply.
If you only make a partial refund, then ebay will reduce the refund of FVF accordingly, and the fixed fee still applies.