I hope ACCC, one day, fines eBay for fake FREE SELLING campaign
Summary: dan_buys_sells_things expressed frustration over eBay's 'free selling' campaign, arguing that fees are still present but obfuscated through a 'Buyer Protection fee,' making it misleading. gutterpunkz05 and sandypebbles offered counterpoints, clarifying that sellers aren't directly charged a selling fee, though costs might be visible in terms of buyer pricing. lezned-toycollector and *casey* added sarcasm and criticism towards the effectiveness of buyer protection. The discussion highlighted a divide in perspectives on what 'free selling' entails, with some seeing fees as cleverly disguised and others viewing them as separate buyer responsibilities.
“Sell for free.” Sure.
And this isn’t a post you’re reading. It’s just pixels beaming photons into your eyes, so legally, I never wrote it. 😉
eBay still takes a fee.
Call it a “fluffy kittens support donation” if you like. They still keep it, and it still comes off the sale price.
The wording is clever enough to be technically true and misleading enough to work through the loophole.
Used-car sales tactics on steroids.
We all see it. We all roll with it. Including the ACCC .
I hope the ACCC finds the balls to put eBay’s photons back together into three simple words:
IT’S A LIE.
And that the fine has plenty of zeros.
e_purchasing
You have an widget you want to sell for $100, you list it on eBay for $100. You did not pay anything to list it, you did not pay any store fees, you did not pay for the postage label. when it sells you get $100. That is free Selling . The buyer pays the protection fee and the postage . It is not advertised as free buying.
Unlike a pro subscription where ebay takes a fee on sale and charges a subscription fee and it is NOT free selling.
Buyer protection fee does NOT come off your sales price, it comes off Ebays because you advertise for $100 but eBay applies and advertises it for $108. If you want $108, list it for that, then eBays advertised price will be $116 so the buyer(again) and not YOU who pays the BPF and it remains free selling to you but not free buying to the buyer of your widget.
There are no "LIES" only ill thought out ideas.
*casey*
"Call it a “fluffy kittens support donation” if you like"
eBay may as well call it that because one actual LIE is :
"What does Buyer Protection Include ?
With buyer protection you benefit from:
Risk monitoring and fraud detection: We actively monitor marketplace activity to identify risk and potential fraud and take action to keep you protected"
which is absolute rubbish!
dan_buys_sells_things
OPThanks all for the feedback. To be clear, I’m not arguing about whether eBay should charge fees, or how big they should be. That’s beside the point. Fees are fine. My point is about calling it “free”.
Think of the card surcharge ban that started on 1 October. Say your coffee was advertised at $5, but you paid $5.25 with the card fee.
The rule now is simple: absorb the cost or advertise $5.25. Show the real number. Nobody cares how it’s packaged. And no café owner would ever say card payments are “free for merchants” just because the customer paid the 25c. It’s still a cost of selling, just collected from the other side of the counter, and it’s money that could have been part of the business’s revenue.
eBay does show buyers the real number. It just doesn’t show sellers theirs. The buyer pays the winning price plus the “Buyer Protection fee”, and the seller never sees that portion.
Buyers bid to their total, so the fee comes off what they’d otherwise pay for the item. In the factual world, money a platform keeps out of a sale is called a fee.
Same principle as the coffee: absorb it, or show it honestly. Don’t call it free ;o)
It’s the same laughable “free lunch” with a $100 entrance fee.
..Or listing your house for sale “for free”, except your buyer pays a $25,000 'finding' fee on top of the price. See how that sits with the public, rather than with us poor schmucks selling crap we don’t need.
dan_buys_sells_things
OPHey all, thanks for the input. I think the point I’m making may have been missed, so here’s a simple test.
If the amount the buyer pays isn’t equal to the amount the seller receives (leave postage aside for now), that isn’t free selling. It doesn’t matter how the platform wraps the cost: insurance, an initiation fee, a friendly hug fee, whatever it chooses to call it. If the platform keeps a portion of what the buyer pays, selling isn’t free.
And yes, the seller wears it. Buyers budget for the total they pay, not the item price. Add a fee on their side and they offer less for the item. Same bite, just taken from the other end of the transaction so it looks free. eBay’s own seller guidance even suggests sellers may want to revise their prices because of the Buyer Protection fee. Why would that be, if it’s not the seller’s cost?
Rebranding a selling fee as a “Buyer Protection fee” for marketing doesn’t change what it is. That’s a hidden fee and a marketing trick, exactly the kind of thing the ACCC looks at. I get that a well-crafted loophole and clever wording make it hard to challenge legally. Like defining “free” on page 145 of the T&Cs as “for the purpose of this advertisement, you are FREE to click the Sell button” ;o)
What IS true: it’s cheaper to sell this way. Roughly 4-8% versus the old 13% or so. That’s correct and factual and a genuine improvement... just with a flavour of shady misrepresentation eBay is famous for.
twyngwyn
It’s only free for the seller is you don’t accept ‘make an offer’…..if you do, then that’s taken out of the ‘offer accepted’
sandypebbles
No, it has not been missed
What has been pointed out is that what one's personal opinion of what free to sell should mean or include , is not what it actually does mean as per eBay t&c's
Ergo the ACCC will not be fining eBay based on personal opinion
sandypebbles
Selling is free
So long as people do not expect selling to include anything other than selling (aka not paying a selling fee when an item sells)
And every reasonable person over the age of about ten knows that free shipping does not exist
dan_buys_sells_things
OPSo selling isn’t free. It’s cheaper.
The fee didn’t disappear, it moved to the other side of the price tag. eBay introduced the “Buyer Protection fee” to cover the cost of running the platform, keeps all of it, and gives no transparency on how much actually funds protection versus the bottom line.
That’s a fee with a nicer name.
And no, technically true but misleading isn’t an oxymoron. It’s a whole marketing genre. 😉
It’s like “free shipping” with the postage baked into the price. Nobody believes the courier works for free. It’s just too painful for the platform to say it openly: the seller pays. So it has to throw a little “FREE” tantrum instead. When the cost is hidden in someone else’s price, everything looks free. Key word: looks.
Not free. Cheaper. Just say that. ( specsavers ad approved ;o)))))
gutterpunkz05
Free to sell (T&C's Apply) and that is exactly what it is.
No cost to seller = Free to sell.
sandypebbles
Gutter, I hope eBay pay you for whatever snacks or drinks you might consume while you are listing, they are part of your selling, no?
gutterpunkz05
Somethings you just have to incorporate or absorb, still happy to pay ebay seller fees.
I would love to sell something for $100 and have have ebay pay me
$106.70, but that is not how free selling works.
sandypebbles
ACCC don’t fine companies for people failing to read the t&c and/or not thinking they will really apply to them
Nor do they due to someone not understanding the difference between selling and anything else
Next you will complain that eBay didn’t pay the portion of your power bill/phone bill during the time you were using eBay to sell something
Considering you agree to the terms of selling and user agreement prior to selling
lezned-toycollector
Yep... because ACCC hands out fines every other day for fictitious twaddle. Everyone knows that's the whole purpose of their existence 😂 😂 😂 😂
Sarcasm aside, you do understand that no entity (ACCC or otherwise) will ever take any action based on your personal misinterpretation of events, or poor comprehension ability, right??
gutterpunkz05
Could it be that the account you are using here, is not a free seller account. I wonder if we can get a specsavers ad out of this.
gutterpunkz05
If you are referring to the buyer protection fee, it is not a selling fee nor is it paid by the seller.
The requirement for free sellers to mostly use ebay labels, is also not a selling fee.
Don't know how it can be technically true but also a lie, does that equate to an oxymoron