topic Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id in Buying

reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

loungefly — Tue, 05 Aug 2014 12:40:56 GMT

Hi all,

Just wanting some feedback on something I came across and wasn't sure how to go about reporting something that looks dodgy.

I've found two separate listings for a camera. It appears to be the same exact camera. One of the pics is identical in both listings except zoomed in a bit in one). Description is exactly the same. The only thing is that the listings are using two separate seller IDs and one is a BIN/best offer and one is an auction.

These are the two listings:

http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/Panasonic-Lumix-DMC-GH2-16-0-MP-Digital-Camera-Black-Body-Only-/161384757674?pt=AU_Digital_Cameras&hash=item259347f9aa

and

http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/Panasonic-Lumix-DMC-GH2-16-0-MP-Digital-Camera-Black-Body-Only-/221515021192?pt=AU_Digital_Cameras&hash=item339352fb88

I clicked to report listing on the BIN/Best offer one. When I selected the auction format, it now says "This listing is a duplicate of another fixed price (or Buy It Now) listing from the same seller." The problem is, the second listing is listed as an auction.

Is there any way to report this accurately? Or am I just wasting my time? I've never reported an auction before btw (in case that wasn't already obvious :P)

Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

tstore — Tue, 05 Aug 2014 13:14:53 GMT

Sellers are allowed to list a duplicate listing when they are different formats e.g 1 BIN and one auction.

Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

davewil1964 — Tue, 05 Aug 2014 14:10:49 GMT

Ergo - there are probably other things you should concern yourself about.

If you want to get it (possibly) cheap, bid on the auction. If you want to get it, BIN. Simple. No need to worry about perceived violations, especially when there probably aren't.

Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

broncosfan182 — Tue, 05 Aug 2014 17:05:19 GMT

Thanks for the replies. I guess I assumed it was against the rules because it seems too risky to be legit (not to mention using two seller ids for the same item, which in itself seems kinda dodgy). Unless I've got it wrong, if someone bids on the auction listing with less than 12 hours to go, and during that time someone else uses the BIN on the other listing, the seller is running the risk of getting negged since they would have to back out of one of the sales. I wouldn't want to take that chance, even if the chances of it happeneing would be relatively slim. Anyhoo, thatnks for the input 🙂

Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

2011.narelle — Tue, 05 Aug 2014 17:15:55 GMT

So broncosfan182 is loungefly?

Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

2011.narelle — Tue, 05 Aug 2014 17:27:24 GMT

Just as i thought.

Broncosfan182 bought something from loungefly who are the same person.

I asked the question & he changed both fb to private 2min later.

Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

mykittenkat — Tue, 05 Aug 2014 22:19:45 GMT

Oh my, what a bit of a mess.

Check out loungefly71 completed listings ( bid history).

The user broncosfan182 has shill bid almost every auction.

Item number:141285275161

Item number:141329428479

Item number:141333739490

Item number:141354639056

How funny that loungefly come here wondering about a seller backing out of a sale. l'd be more miffed about the shill bidding if l were any of those buyers of the listings mentioned.

tut tut.

Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

2011.narelle — Wed, 06 Aug 2014 02:11:02 GMT

yes i wonder if he knows that he can't sell with private feedback but then again he's probably got another account.

So when you report an ended item for shill bidding does eBay still look into it?

Re: reporting a duplicate listing, with different auction format & seller id

thingsmostneeded — Wed, 06 Aug 2014 23:56:45 GMT

I think that if reported, eBay will check out the user names to see if there is a link. They see things that we can't and if there are other user names held by the user, they will see them too.

Shill bidding is frowned upon so if ended item numbers are included in report, something may happen as the proof is there to see.