Re: What Would You Do ?

opmania · ‎31-03-2015

ok for everyone's benefit I would put this note in another senario

I go to the races and win $500

The bookie hands me over the money and unbeknowns to me I have actually got $600 because 2 notes are perfectly stuck together

I celebrate my good luck by taking my family out to dinner

The bill comes to $200 and I hand over the money one of which is the stuck notes + $100

Chef from the restaurant takes this note and pays for fruit and veg for the restaurant

fruit and veg guy goes to supermarket to buy dog food and pays with the stuck $100 note

cashier takes note gives change and puts money in register

stuck note is given to another staff menber as wages and they go and cash it for $100 worth of pokie chips

It is probable that this money could have been stuck together for many changes of hands so who is the rightful owner

and how would anyone even be able to know this

anyone in the line of that senario could have discovered that there were two notes and not one and obviously the old guy did not know

so how can ownership of the hidden note only be claimable by one person

azureline** · ‎31-03-2015

Anything could have happened............... however, you knew the notes were adhered together, you knew who handed them to you. You did the correct thing and returned the excess note to the owner.

Doesn't matter how many times you find another scenario..................you didn't ask the man where he got it, as far as you are aware, the money was his, came from his wallet. The look on his face could easily have been amazement that he was careless or that you were honest.

i-need-a-martini · ‎01-04-2015

That scenario is illogical.

The only fact that you know is that the person handing you the stuck together notes is the rightful owner of both notes. I doubt if if you would sit there and think "Oh he may not be the rightful owner so I don't have to return $100 to him."

the*scarlet*pimpernel · ‎01-04-2015

What makes you think the librarian is as honest as you. You give him/her the 10 bucks, they put it in their back pocket and next time you'rein they tell you someone claimed it.

I think I would probably have kept it, and then I would have felt guilty and bad for ages afterwards.

opmania · ‎01-04-2015

just like i am doing now lol

one things for sure if I ever find another $10 I won't be telling this lot about it

azureline** · ‎01-04-2015

I haven't commented on the $10. It was found, no owner in sight, up to you and your conscience what you do, to deal with that.

Any time I have found money I have been able to return to it's owner.

If I am overpaid I return it to the person who overpaid me.

happyroo_bunji · ‎01-04-2015

I agree azureline, the ten dollars isn't the issue here.

For me the issue has always been that the OP would question keeping a large overpayment of money when they know who the owner is. Not only that but that the business they work for encourages it. Then to bring up the all codswallop trying to justify their thinking. There are no if's or but's. It is stealing.

opmania · ‎01-04-2015

I'm over it

polksaladallie · ‎01-04-2015