Kopenhagen, I would be pretty sure the CDs are fine. My brother was a music buff and looked after his things & they were his.

So they have been used but we haven't inspected them or played them. They were advertised 'as is', part of a deceased estate. The ad was as honest and straightforward as we could make it.

You're right, we are not willing to leave ourselves open to any dispute. We're not trying to hide anything, quite the opposite. We feel he is a bit of a scammer, trying to imply paypal means obligatory postage. He has not said he would pay extra for postage, he has just said he has paid via paypal and now we 'have to' post them to him.

He's picked the wrong people to scam.