I just spent the last half an hour reading over this thread.  And by golly I think I actually learnt something  It's great to see the community here are prepared to help and give their time and offer such insightful advice. And it's so awesome that Paypal ruled in your favour. Well done OP, well done Paypal and most of all KUDOS to all who contributed to OP's dilemma. And believe me I lost sleep over a $7.50 sale that went wrong recently so it must've been an awesome feeling getting that email from paypal.