Yes, I have tried to call them, and have left a message on their voicemail.  But in the meantime I was just wondering what others would do in this situation.  As you say, I can imagine it could get unpleasant if I claim what is correct.  I was thinking to just cut my losses, but my husband was quite adamant that I should stand my ground.  I will see if they call back and say that it is not my item, and see what they say and begrudgingly give a credit to keep the peace if I have to.  Thanks for your feedback, I really appreciate it.

🙂