No, the buyer hasn’t seen the bag.  This whole process is incredibly subjective. Obviously, the person who authenticated the bag in November had no issue with the condition of the bag and nor did I. In fact I was thrilled!  It’s in excellent condition and is a beautiful bag.  Then 6 months later someone else looks at it and based on THEIR  opinion decides to fail the bag.  So they have denied the buyer a beautiful bag at a fraction of the price of a new LV bag and me a $600 sale!  Like I said, a very dodgy authentication process!!