Does it bother you if threads go off topic?

[donnashuggy]

Or if people make off topic posts in threads?

[cherry*135]

The rule says discussion boards, not threads.

[buzzlightyearsgirlfriend]

---

@donnashuggy wrote:

My understanding is that it relates to the topic started as well, I would be happy if you guys could check with the moderators for clarification but I think you will find that quite a few posters have had posts removed for being off topic within a thread:

http://pages.ebay.com.au/help/policies/everyone-boards.html

---

Posts being removed for being off topic within a thread is not mentioned AT ALL in the board usage policy.

If members are having posts removed or being sanctioned or suspended for this, then it is being done outside the board usage policy that we agreed to when we signed up.

It appears that the board usage policy as it applies here is being rather loosely interpreted and applied.

[azureline**]

I think Buzz, AM 3, and Freddie are correct and I gave them Kudos

[donnashuggy]

I know what you are all saying, would appreciate you getting clarification from the mods as I have.

It's a ridiculous rule as it causes a disturbance to otherwise friendly banter. Unless the topic has been changed to cause problems.

[debra9275]

But Az & Buzz, that doesn't explain why some posters are having posts removed for being off topic on here. jMHO but it should only apply to the help boards

[cherry*135]

That is how it was under the previous system.  It was the reason given to move a thread that is on the wrong board to the correct one.

[azureline**]

---

@debra9275 wrote:
But Az & Buzz, that doesn't explain why some posters are having posts removed for being off topic on here. jMHO but it should only apply to the help boards

---

but are they? and have they queried it, if so?

[cherry*135]

Wouldn't it be up to individual posters who get that sort of mail to individually query it with the moderators?

[debra9275]

I can't answer that Az

[freddie*rooster · Accepted solution]

Take for instance Catty's thread, now that thread is a thread which has always been anything goes, from broken hearts, to illness, to sick kitties, to holidays, to gardening, to kidlets, to cooking and back again. How would that thread survive it it was a requirements to stay on topic?