on 25-09-2018 07:09 PM
Australians:
OK to grumble about it costing you more if GST is applied to overseas purchases, but what to do if the GST legislation SHUTS DOWN your business in Australia?
I am an Australian author and publisher, and have 4 books up on Amazon's POD (Print-On-Demand) site in California. As from July 1, Amazon have declared that it is not workable for them to comply with the new low-value GST regulations, and so they will not ship anything to an Australian address.
I estimate that Amazon have spent tens of millions of dollars on setting up the POD service, and there is no real alternative for POD. The new legislation is largely unworkable, unenforcible, and uncheckable as far as overseas suppliers are concerned. It's getting Australia a reputation as a bad place to do business with.
A new example of this -- ABEBooks are the main source of buying second-hand books, worldwide. In the face of the new legislation, US bookshops have not declined to supply to Australia, they have just added $40 to the cost of postage to Australian customers. Cost of book, $3.50. Cost of postage, $44.00. Message to Australians: we DON'T WANT your business. it's just too hard.
The new legislation came out of an Australian Government Productivity Commission report, which you can see at https://www.pc.gov.au/inquiries/completed/collection-models/report/collection-models.pdf. In it they say:
The legislated model and the suitability of alternatives should be reviewed five years from commencement, or sooner if triggered by evidence of unduly low compliance, unintended impacts on consumers or adverse trade policy responses.
===
I've clearly suffered an unintended impact and seen the adverse trade policy responses. What can be done to get an immediate review of the legislation? I've tried contacting my member of parliament (Julie Bishop), the media, and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, all of whom have not responded or have said it's nothing to do with them. ??????
on 25-09-2018 09:11 PM
It would seem you have tried all of the available avenues. If those parties won't look at your case, nobody else has the power to.
Have you considered publishing in Australia? If your book is selling, a publisher could be interested.
on 27-09-2018 06:09 PM
I have used POD book printing and have had a book with reasonable sales through mine (Lulu). Therea re so many other options so I am not sure why you think it is the end of the world for you.
There are POD and short run printers in Aus, even if you use them for Australian sales and Amazon for rest of the world. If you really wanted to stick with Amazon or another overseas priner you could post a heap to yourself and do your own promotion and selling. Or you could just sell Ebooks.
The GST on overseas sales is not going to stop, and I don't know why you think your case would make any difference and earn a reconsideration of the legislation - a bit self important aren't we?