cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.

I volunteer at a regional gallery and get to meet some wonderful, weird and wacky people.

 

But the ones that get up my goat are the ones who say "That looks like something a 5 year old would do." and expect me to agree with them.

 

And whilst we have a lot of community exhibitions that are amateurish enough (so perhaps the comment may be fair enough), the comment is usually reserved for iconic artists in major travelling exhibitions who are extremely well known.

 

Does anyone here like abstract art? And if you really hate it, why?

Message 1 of 368
Latest reply
367 REPLIES 367

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.

I cater for those who are less astute than you ๐Ÿ™‚

 

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 41 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.


@rabbitearbandicoot wrote:

we went to a gallery once - Canberra I think - one particular piece of ART - a kitchen stool with a wheel on it - took my fancy. When I save up enough money, I might buy that. 

 

 

 

 

edit: Another example of the value of higher education - probably did 6 years at uni to think of that.


Thats pretty funny rabbit- 'almost' remembering a Duchamp..

 

 

 

Pity. I see your mockery..

Message 42 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.

re. It looks like a 5 yr old has done it ...

 

"Fiction is the lie through which we tell the truth."


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disumbrationism


http://blogs.artinfo.com/lacmonfire/2014/03/06/the-man-who-hated-futurism/

 

The front page headline of the August 14, 1927, Los Angeles Times read INTERNATIONAL ART HOAX BARED BY LOS ANGELES AUTHOR.

 

The story revealed that the modern art movement known as โ€œDisumbrationismโ€ was a complete fraudโ€”a โ€œremarkable revenge put over on Futurist critics.โ€ (Above, one of that faux-movementโ€™s masterworks: Pavel Jerdanowitchโ€™s Illumination, c. 1926.)

 

Paul Jordan Smith was an L.A. Times journalist and author. His wife, Sarah Bixby Smith, was an amateur painter whose work was rejected for a exhibition at Claremont.

 

The judges faulted it for being too conservative.

 

This provoked her husband, who had no artistic training, to paint โ€œa weird futuristic-**bleep**-impressionist-**bleep**-kindergarten canvas in riotous color.โ€

 

 Inspired by Gauguin, the painting presents a Polynesian woman holding a banana, โ€œprimitiveโ€ in drawing and uncomfortable stereotype.

 

The Times account says that Smith initially used the painting as a firescreen.

 

Then he decided to enter the painting in an exhibition of โ€œindependentsโ€ being held at New Yorkโ€™s Waldorf-Astoria hotel in spring 1925. He submitted under the name โ€œPavel Jerdanowitchโ€ and titled the painting โ€œExaltation.โ€

 

As this was a selling exhibition, he put โ€œan impossible price on itโ€ฆ he did not want to trap any innocent buyer.โ€

 

He made a suitably dark and brooding photograph of himself as Jerdanowitch, and submitted the work to the same group of critics as representative of the new school, "Disumbrationism".

 

He explained "Exaltation" as a symbol of "breaking the shackles of womanhood.

 

To his dismay, if not to his surprise, the Disumbrationist daub won praise from the critics who had belittled his wife's realistic painting.

 

More Disumbrationist paintings followed: a composition of zig-zag lines and eyeballs he called "Illumination"; a garish picture of a black woman doing laundry which he called "Aspiration", and which a critic praised as "a delightful jumble of Gauguin, Pop Hart and Negro minstrelsy, with a lot of Jerdanowitch individuality"; "Gination", an ugly, lopsided portrait; and a painting named "Adoration", of a woman worshipping an immense phallic idol, which was exhibited in 1927.

 

 

The same year, Jordan-Smith confessed to the Los Angeles Times that the Disumbrationist paintings were meant as a spoof.

 

atheism is a non prophet organization
Message 43 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.

The art world can be very fickle and elitist.  It is interesting to see how Impressionism was first viewed,  and how Manet was at first laughed at. 

 

This makes an interesting read for those who are interested...

 

http://www.impressionism.org/teachimpress/browse/aboutimpress.htm

 

Although some people appreciated the new paintings, many did not. The critics and the public agreed the Impressionists couldnโ€™t draw and their colors were considered vulgar. Their compositions were strange. Their short, slapdash brushstrokes made their paintings practically illegible. Why didnโ€™t these artists take the time to finish their canvases, viewers wondered?

Indeed, Impressionism broke every rule of the French Academy of Fine Arts, the conservative school that had dominated art training and taste since 1648. Impressionist scenes of modern urban and country life were a far cry from the Academic efforts to teach moral lessons through historic, mythological, and Biblical themes.,,,,,,,,,

Message 44 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.


@youcandoityoucandoityoucandoit wrote:

@rabbitearbandicoot wrote:

we went to a gallery once - Canberra I think - one particular piece of ART - a kitchen stool with a wheel on it - took my fancy. When I save up enough money, I might buy that. 

 

 

 

 

edit: Another example of the value of higher education - probably did 6 years at uni to think of that.


Thats pretty funny rabbit- 'almost' remembering a Duchamp..

 

 

 

Pity. I see your mockery..


 

You mean to tell me that would require an artistic temperament and training??

Message 45 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.

 

This is a good friend's daughters art. I admire her skill and creativity. She is also an excellent writer and songstress

 

http://www.ambercarbury.com/2014.html

atheism is a non prophet organization
Message 46 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.


@colic2bullsgirlore wrote:

 

This is a good friend's daughters art. I admire her skill and creativity. She is also an excellent writer and songstress

 

http://www.ambercarbury.com/2014.html


Yes, very nice. You can see what they are.

Message 47 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.

he also seems to have facination with urinals and hat racks.

Message 48 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.


@rabbitearbandicoot wrote:
 

 

 


An upside down parked unicycle with peddals stolen

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 49 of 368
Latest reply

Abstract Art - why talk about it if you don't get it.

@i-need-a-martini wrote:

 

But the ones that get up my goat are the ones who say "That looks like something a 5 year old would do." and expect me to agree with them.

 

 

I think you should ring the RSPCA.

Message 50 of 368
Latest reply

Type a product name