Broken promises. What is acceptable?

Lots of broken promises are made by governments. If the promises are broken because of economic need, I understand.

 

But what of the empty promises that they know they can never keep. Like the 'Stop the Boats' promise?

 

Or this one: where Abbott promised at the Garma festival in the weeks leading up to the election that he would spend his first week as Prime Minister in Yolgnu country.

 

To break promises like this is just a low act by someone who knew he would never be able to keep it.

 

See where he says it clearly here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F1OKujvU2wQ

 

I wouldn't bother to listen to the whole boring speech (although many of his off the cuff comments are a little eyebrow raising) but at 21:40 he starts making promises he can't keep.

Message 1 of 116
Latest reply
115 REPLIES 115

Broken promises. What is acceptable?

yes, well, Crikey, where would you go from here? how far?  lol

Message 61 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?

what do you mean, meep?

 

 


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 62 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?

Howard aimed at the worst in us .. don't inspire, provide a whipping boy, a bogey man. take the publics eye off yourself and keep it on the monster. pretty basic GOP  textbook stuff that.

Message 63 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?

Howard aimed at the worst in us

 

in your opinion

 

pretty basic GOP  textbook stuff

 

 

LOL got a link to this so called handbook?

Message 64 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?


@**meep** wrote:

@izabsmiling wrote:

@poddster wrote:

Are you saying that the PM at time was not the leader of the government???

 

Amazing !!!!


Poddster , as  Ian Robinson reported Smiley Happy

 

Although in general it is not commendable to break commitments, it is not even clear that this is what has happened.

The Prime Minister's commitment not to introduce a tax on carbon was implicitly premised on her being in a position to keep the commitment, by leading a majority government after the election.

This didn't happen, so her pre-election commitment was effectively null and void.

Instead, she found herself in a minority government in which she was not in total control of all the outcomes. She therefore had to work out a compromise with the other stakeholders.

Abbott is reported as saying during the post-election negotiations that he would ''do anything'' to be prime minister. This implies that he, too, would have accepted a carbon tax as part of a minority government compromise.

Perhaps in hindsight the Prime Minister could have made the limitation to her commitment clearer by saying there would be no carbon tax under ''a majority government led by me''.



Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-opinion/taxing-the-truth-why-we-must-not-let-abbott...


Mein Kampf?  Really?   Is that where you got your idea about our PM being a dictator?

 

Nazi analogies don't usually receive positive reactions and should not be tolerated, to say the least.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


I added this for other reasons (the part I put in the post)...however did you read all  the article. ? 

and have you not noticed our media portraying our leaders and conroy as dictators in recent years ...republished here ?

 

No I didn't need this for any of my own or others opinions .Similar opinions are are being expressed elsewhere. 

 

 

 

 

Message 65 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?

heresay


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 66 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?


@**meep** wrote:

yes, well, Crikey, where would you go from here? how far?  lol


and btw ANYONE fleeing war/ persecuation is the same imo .Regardless of how they flee or what papers they have/don't have when they arrive at a safe destination



Message 67 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?

and btw ANYONE fleeing war/ persecuation is the same imo

 

what about people fleeing sea level rises?

 

 

Message 68 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?

The multitude arriving in Indonesia have passports otherwise they would not be allowed to enter but they all happen to lose those documents when they board a leaky fishing boat what a coincidence

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 69 of 116
Latest reply

Broken promises. What is acceptable?

The multitude arriving in Indonesia have passports otherwise they would not be allowed to enter but they all happen to lose those documents when they board a leaky fishing boat 

 

The multitude arriving in Indonesia have passports otherwise they would not be allowed to enter but they all happen to lose those documents when they board a leaky fishing boat to welfareland

 

ftfy 

Message 70 of 116
Latest reply