DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

OK folks, I need advice. the Elephants are looking for a new car. Our little shopping trolley (Suzuki Swift)  has served us faithfully for 21 years and has nearly 300,000 ks on the clock, but it is  now fast approaching retirement. We want something small, nippy and cheap to run  - a car that will only be used around town as we have a Lancer for longer runs.


 


Options we are looking at are Mitsubishi Mirage, Suzuki Alto, Volkswagon Up!  Nissan Micra, or Mazda 2.


 


Which one would you recommend and why?


 


Or would you suggest something other than any of these. (I would dearly love a smart for 2 but Mr Elephant says no and anyway they are a bit outside of our budget.)

Message 1 of 60
Latest reply
59 REPLIES 59

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

rosymog
Community Member

the mirage,  its zippy, lots of space inside, got all the bling re  usb points, bluetoofs stuff , abs, ebblahblahblah stuffs, umm sensors so that is controls it better? when you go slippy round a corner but you don't cos its got that button that makes it not do that *thats as good as my car techno stuff is going to get miss ellphants!*  now if it was a motorbike that would be different, but l digress


 


its super cheap to run, comes in purdy colours, 4 doors, and its got a cute beep beep horn.

Message 2 of 60
Latest reply

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

rosymog
Community Member

oh and the auto one has that  cvt? funny auto stick thing that means you glide and you don't feel it change gears.


 


and it goes like the clappers too when needed.


for a small car its zippydoodar.

Message 3 of 60
Latest reply

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

Mazda 3 because they are cute.

Message 4 of 60
Latest reply

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

oops finger slipped ^^ Mazda 2.

Message 5 of 60
Latest reply

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

It may take me a while to decide which car is suitable for elephants......

TCT
Message 6 of 60
Latest reply

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!


It may take me a while to decide which car is suitable for elephants......



 


volkswagons arent bad, but, im going have cross that one off the list....


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


,


Signatures suck.
Message 7 of 60
Latest reply

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

There's a very old joke - it goes something like;


How many elephants can you fit in a Mini ?


2 in the back and 2 in the front !


( I don't expect anyone to laugh. )

TCT
Message 8 of 60
Latest reply

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

Nissan Micra...


Zippy handling and sharp pricing but the engine's a little underdone and lagging on safety. New model soon.


 


Suzuki Alto...


Great value and strong safety story but cramped and has an underpowered engine.


 


 


Mazda2


 


Mazda recently shifted production of the 2 from Japan to Thailand, lowering labour costs and taking advantage of the Free Trade Agreement between Thailand and Australia, which means zero tariffs (instead of the 5 per cent impost on other imports).


For the buyer, that means standard stability control and a value equation that Mazda says has improved by about $1000. Add to that the fact Mazda doesn't charge you for prestige paint - the Toyota, Hyundai and Volkswagen do - and the 2 looks like good value.


Inside, the 2's cabin is neat, simple and well laid out, although it's let down a little by large expanses of plain, black, hard plastic and no digital trip computer readout. The seats are comfortable, with good side support, although the steering wheel only adjusts for height.


The back seat is fairly tight, with our rear seat testers ranking it the most cramped of the five, but the rear load area was a decent size. Niggles include a space-saver tyre sitting under the floor and a middle child-restraint anchor placed on the rear load lip, allowing the strap to eat into cargo space.


We had the top-of-the-range Genki version, which gets larger wheels, a body kit, fog lamps and a leather-wrapped steering wheel and gear knob. It also gets the full safety package, including curtain airbags to protect rear passengers. Unfortunately, the Mazda - along with the i20 and Toyota Yaris - doesn't get cruise control.


On the road, the Mazda is an accomplished performer. It steers accurately, is composed and agile through the corners and has a slightly more cosseting ride than the Fiesta. Its weakness is the 1.5-litre engine under its bonnet.


It struggles to conquer hills with a couple of people on board. In our four-aboard, uphill acceleration test it was the slowest by a decent margin (even the automatic Yaris was more than two seconds quicker).


With less of a load on board, though, the Mazda feels spritely enough. The engine likes to rev and the five-speed manual gearbox feels precise, while engine noise and vibration are well suppressed.


Mazda2 Genki


How much? $20,940 (auto $1650 more) plus on-road and dealer costs


Engine: 1.5-litre 4-cyl


Power: 76kW at 6000rpm


Torque: 135Nm at 4000rpm


Transmission: 5-sp manual, FWD


Weight: 1038kg


Fuel use: 6.4L/100km (6.8L/100km auto)


Emissions: 152g/km CO2 (162g/km CO2 auto)


Safety: Five-star crash rating; front, front-side and curtain airbags; stability control


Rating: 4/5


 


?


 


 


Ford fiesta


 


This pint-sized Ford has enjoyed a sales revival since the new model arrived early last year.


The Fiesta is attractively priced for a European-sourced car. Our test car was the 1.6-litre manual version, which Ford says is the most popular choice. That's unusual, because most light-car buyers favour autos, but the anomaly can be traced to the fact that the manual gets a bigger engine (the auto mates it to a 1.4) and it's $1500 cheaper.


That will change when Fiesta production shifts to Thailand later this year, and the 1.6-litre engine becomes standard across the range.


We chose the five-door, middle-of-the-range Fiesta LX, which costs $1800 more than the base model and gets voice-activated Bluetooth, a leather steering wheel, power rear windows and bigger, 15-inch alloy wheels.


The LX model on sale now doesn't get standard stability control (which can prevent a skid) or side airbags, while no Fiesta gets curtain airbags to protect rear-seat passengers.


That will also change with the shift to the Thai plant, with all but the CL model getting seven airbags and stability control standard.


The Fiesta's cabin has its ups and downs. The seats are comfortable and supportive, with good-looking cloth trim, while the central information screen looks good and is easy to read.


There are also steering wheel-mounted controls for the stereo and cruise control, a welcome addition at this end of the market.


Soft-touch plastic on the dash is a rare touch in this class but the overall cabin design lacks cohesion, with too many different colours and textures.


The rear of the Fiesta isn't as spacious as some light cars, with leg, shoulder and headroom on the tight side for adults. The rear load area is reasonable, although there's exposed metal on the backs of the rear seats.


The Fiesta's strong suit is the way it drives. The 1.6-litre engine is one of the perkiest in the class, getting along reasonably swiftly even with four adults on board. It can get a little buzzy on the freeway but, for the most part, it is refined.


The ride is firmer than most but not unduly uncomfortable, save for the occasional thud on sharper potholes. Through the corners, the little Ford sits flat and feels composed, with nicely weighted steering.


If you enjoy driving, the Fiesta is an excellent companion on a twisty road.


Ford Fiesta LX


How much? $18,790 (auto $1500 more) plus on-road and dealer costs


Engine: 1.6-litre 4-cyl


Power: 88kW at 6000rpm


Torque: 152Nm at 4050rpm


Transmission: 5-sp manual, FWD


Weight: 1099kg


Fuel use: 6.1L/100km (6.9L/100km auto)


Emissions: 143g/km CO2 (164g/km CO2 auto)


Safety: Two airbags; knee and side airbags and stability control as a $1000 option.


Rating: 4/5


 


?


Signatures suck.
Message 9 of 60
Latest reply

DECISIONS, DECISIONS!

Volkswagon up!


 


VW's marketing gurus like the new model’s name to be spelled as up!


– complete with lower-case ‘u’ and an exclamation mark. Our computer’s spelling checker hates it, but ...


VALUE


Volkswagen up! is the reigning World Car of the Year and is available in three- and five-door hatchback bodies, with just one equipment level but a number of option packages. More about the latter.


There are a number of cost-saving cues in the up! including sealed side windows in the rear of the three-door version and hinge-out windows (only to about 10 degrees) in the five-door.


Fuel consumption during our test week was generally in the six to seven litres per hundred kilometres range, on the open road it was possible to get it under five litres without using any extreme economy driving measures.


There are three option packages available with the up!. The biggest seller will almost certainly be the Maps+More Package; a portable infotainment system displayed on a five-inch touchscreen monitor mounted onto a bracket above the centre console. Features include satellite navigation, Bluetooth phone and audio streaming, trip computer with a fuel-saving trainer and media player. At just $500 it’s a steal.


The Comfort Drive Package ($600) provides cruise control, multi-function display and rear parking sensors. The $2500 Comfort Style Package includes 15-inch alloy wheels, front foglights, leather trimmed steering wheel, parking brake lever and gearshift knob, heated front seats and carpet floor mats. A panoramic powered sunroof is available for just $1400, so is also likely to be a popular option.


TECHNOLOGY


Power for the cute little Volkswagen up! comes from a three-cylinder 1.0-litre petrol engine. Peak power is 55 kW at 6200 rpm and 95 Nm of torque between 3000 and 4300 rpm.


By their nature lower-powered cars do require a bit more thought and planning in the driving technique needed to get best out of them. For the time being, there is no automatic transmission on offer. It’s sold only with a five-speed manual gearbox.


DESIGN


The Volkswagen up! has a cheeky shape that’s like nothing else on the road. This is a very difficult thing to achieve because the smallest VeeDub could have looked like any other low-priced hatchback. Full marks to the designers who have used a clever front grille style and a distinctive kink in the rear pillar to make their up! stand out from the madding automotive crowd.


There is seating for four, although rear seat adult passengers will need to impose on those in the front seat to get comfortable legroom. If you’re buying an up! as a small family car make sure the kids are aware that they won’t be able to wind down the rear windows.


There are no headroom problems in any seat and just the occasional elbow bumping between the two front seat occupants.


Maximising the size of the passenger cabin inevitably reduces storage space and, at 251 litres maximum, the boot is relatively small. However it is quite deep and can take a single large suitcase with several soft bags squeezed in around it. The rear seatbacks fold down to greatly increase carrying capacity.


SAFETY


A major safety feature of the up! Is City Emergency Braking (CEM). This uses a laser sensor mounted at the top of the windscreen to scan a space in front of the car, detect the risk of imminent collision and selectively apply the brakes depending upon the force required. It will either prevent or reduce the impact of a collision at speeds up to 30 km/h.


DRIVING


The blast from the past we mentioned in the intro is that there’s more than a hint of the original VW Beetle in the way up! feels on the road. Not in its handling, which is infinitely better than the old swing-axle Beetle that could see the car tipped onto its roof at a moment’s notice, but in the cheeky way it accelerated and the happy way it corners and stops. The buzzy sound from the three-cylinder engine is another endearing feature.


If you don’t smile from time to time while in the driving seat of an up! we feel for you. At just 3.54 metres in length the VW up! is a delight in tight city areas and we found ourselves having access to parking spots that nothing else with four wheels could fit into.


Volkswagen Up


Price: from $13,990
Engine: 1.0-litre 3-cyl, 55kW/95Nm
Transmission: 5-speed manual, FWD
Warranty: 3 years/unlimited km
Crash rating: n/a
Dimensions: 3540mm (L); 1641mm (W); 1476mm (H)
Thirst: 4.9L/100km 114g/km CO2


Signatures suck.
Message 10 of 60
Latest reply