Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy

NATIONAL Commission of Audit chairman Tony Shepherd has urged the Coalition and crossbench senators to reach a compromise on the budget, warning uncertainty will drain business confidence and distract the government from other important ­reforms.

 

Amid escalating frustration in the business community about the Senate derailing the ­Coalition’s agenda, the former Business Council of Australia president and respected company director has likened maintaining current government spending levels to a “short-term sugar hit”.

 

“Special interest groups say not us but the naysayers are not offering realistic alternatives to reducing expenditure and returning the budget to a sustainable surplus,” he writes.

 

If Australia continues down the fiscal path it’s on, there will be “no reserve” to deal with a future crisis.

 

And failing to put the budget on a sustainable path will “saddle our children and grandchildren with our profligacy”.

 

Entire Article Here

 

Totally agree. The media needs to stop pouncing on every utterance, every phrase or slip of the  tongue the Minister or Treasurer may make and let them get on with the job. 

This misplaced hostility against the current government because it won the election is deconstructive and bordering on the ridiculous.

Message 1 of 15
Latest reply
14 REPLIES 14

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy

Tony Shepherd was not elected and has already been allowed far too much influence over the budget.

 

If he wants influence he should stand for election not just scam a highly paid job to manipulate policy to his own advantage from the suckers in the Liberal party. 

 

If the treasurer wants to stop the ridicule he needs to stop being a foot in mouth ass.

Message 2 of 15
Latest reply

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy


@icyfroth wrote:

This misplaced hostility against the current government because it won the election is deconstructive and bordering on the ridiculous.


Actually what is ridiculous is that this government is in their 1st budget breaking just about every promise it gave us before the elections.  They are exactly in the same position as the previous government, except TA is concentrating on such things as criticizing Russia, telling the Scots how to vote, and generally insulting every other head of state, instead of negotiating with the people who hold the balance of power.  Gillard managed to get through about 600 legislation by lengthy negotiation.  The trouble is LNP would not know how to negotiate.  They are out of touch with ordinary people who voted for them. 

 

 

Message 3 of 15
Latest reply

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy

The Treasurer did his job - he produced a Budget that is a fail. Should all measures he proposed in the Budget pass without question?. Of course not.

Hockey is doing a poor job of "selling" his Budget ( poor people and cars comments etc). Even members of his own party don't approve of some proposals.

Is the media allowed to leap on every utterance from a Labor Govt in when in (PM and MP's) but not a LNP govt?.????????????

Tony Abbott was the most aggressive Opposition leader ever in Aust, he set the bar.
Message 4 of 15
Latest reply

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy

poor big business not getting their own way, boo hoo - shepherd, who cares what he has to say - he's already pocketed enough public money so maybe it's time for him to shut up and slither off quietly. 

 

Audit chief Tony Shepherd pushed traffic forecasts on Lane Cove Tunnel

 

 

Tony Shepherd, one of the key business advisers to the Abbott and Baird governments, was one of a group of ''big wigs'' trying to drive up traffic forecasts on the ill-fated Lane Cove Tunnel project, the Supreme Court has heard.

 

 

Mr Shepherd now chairs the WestConnex Delivery Authority, the organisation in charge of building the biggest motorway project in the country's history, and was the head of the Prime Minister's National Commission of Audit.

 

 

But in a former role as an executive at Transfield Holdings, Mr Shepherd ran the consortium that won the right in 2003 to build the Lane Cove Tunnel – a project now the subject of a $144 million legal battle between one of its investors and traffic forecasters.



Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/audit-chief-tony-shepherd-pushed-traffic-forecasts-on-lane-cove-tunnel-201...

 

http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/labor-says-budget-needs-boot-not-reboot-20140816-3dt45...

 

Labor says budget needs boot not reboot

 

"The budget needs the boot, not a reboot. Perhaps a Treasurer needs a boot up the backside too for his comments on poorer Australians."

 

Similarly, Labor finance spokesman Tony Burke said rebooting a computer meant it turned off, then came back exactly the same.

 

"We don't need to see a budget in reboot. We need to see the current priorities abandoned and for the government to start again," he told reporters in Sydney.

Message 5 of 15
Latest reply

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy

Icy "entire article is here" No it isn't, it is behind a paywall.
Message 6 of 15
Latest reply

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy

Actually this IS a ridiculous comment. Is it original or did you read it somewhere else?



"This misplaced hostility against the current government because it won the election is deconstructive and bordering on the ridiculous."

The hostility (well deserved) is coming from Uni students, Aged pensioners, disabled persons, unemployed youth (under 30's especially), charities, Churches... as a result of the proposed measures in Joe Hockeys Budget. Real people who are going to be much worse off under this Govt, if all the changes in the Budget get passed in Senate.

Charities and Churches are against the Budget measures that effect people on pensions. Who is going to provide food to an unemployed 25 yo with no income?
Message 7 of 15
Latest reply

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy

icyfroth wrote - This misplaced hostility against the current government because it won the election is deconstructive and bordering on the ridiculous.

 

Misplaced hostility? How is it misplaced? They were elected by outright lying to the Australian public - they lied about health, education, SBS, ABC, welfare, pensions  but that's just fine is it? They also lied about the so called "budget emergency", so now we are all just supposed to grin and bare it, smiling and nodding while they rip apart every thing that makes this country great - not a chance. How is it "deconstructive"? Is that the bolters "word of the day"....Woman LOL

Message 8 of 15
Latest reply

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy

Who has the ear of the Govt? Big business

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 13, 2014

Big business now calling the economic shots

Sometimes I wonder whether the economy is being managed for our benefit or for the benefit of the big businesses that dominate it. The two big supermarket chains we get to choose between, the two domestic airlines and privately owned airports, the three foreign mining giants that were allowed to redesign the mining tax they didn't like, and the four big banks that control so much of our superannuation and the investment advice we get, not to mention our savings accounts and mortgages.

I'm old enough to remember when economic life seemed to be dominated by big unions. Hardly a month passed without our lives being disrupted by some strike. We'd be walking miles to work or finding someone to mind the kids while the teachers were out.

I remember finishing a holiday in New Zealand with our young family, only to find the baggage handlers in Sydney were on strike and being stuck in Christchurch for an extra two days.

Thank goodness we don't have to put up with all that any more. But in place of being bossed around by the unions, we now have big business calling the shots. They don't inconvenience us like the unions did, but they do seem to have the ear of government.

http://www.rossgittins.com/2014/08/big-business-now-calling-economic-shots.html
Message 9 of 15
Latest reply

Fix Budget Quit The Argy Bargy


@am*3 wrote:
Icy "entire article is here" No it isn't, it is behind a paywall.

 

 

Try This Link

 

or here's the entire text although I know long C&P's are frowned on:

 

NATIONAL Commission of Audit chairman Tony Shepherd has urged the Coalition and crossbench senators to reach a compromise on the budget, warning uncertainty will drain business confidence and distract the government from other important ­reforms.

 

Amid escalating frustration in the business community about the Senate derailing the ­Coalition’s agenda, the former Business Council of Australia president and respected company director has likened maintaining current government spending levels to a “short-term sugar hit”.

 

Writing in The Weekend Australian today, Mr Shepherd says that in the “toing and froing” on the budget, people have lost sight of why government spending needs to be cut.

“Special interest groups say not us but the naysayers are not offering realistic alternatives to reducing expenditure and returning the budget to a sustainable surplus,” he writes.

 

If Australia continues down the fiscal path it’s on, there will be “no reserve” to deal with a future crisis.

 

And failing to put the budget on a sustainable path will “saddle our children and grandchildren with our profligacy”.

“But eventually we, and the rest of the world, will wake up,” he writes.

 

“We will then be forced to take drastic action which will be far more difficult for the community and the economy to absorb.”

The comments come after Andrew Liveris, Australian-born chief executive of US multinational Dow Chemical, warned on Thursday that the “scary” new political paradigm was an “embarrassment on the world stage” over the past six years.

 

Business leaders have been lining up to warn about the risks of a dysfunctional Senate as Joe Hockey has tried to negotiate deals on unpopular budget savings. Former BHP Billiton chairman Don Argus has recently ­decried as “nonsense” that budget measures could be blocked by the Senate and warned this could stunt the economy.

 

Problems with the political setting are expected to be discussed at this weekend’s closed-door ADC Forum retreat at Hayman Island, which will be attended by senior politicians, bureaucrats and chief executives.

 

Corporate leaders from Telstra, BHP Billiton, ANZ and GE Mining have also warned about the budget impasse and called on the business community to back the government’s agenda — a call echoed today by Mr Shepherd, who writes that the Coalition was voted in with an election platform that made fiscal reform a central pillar. “I trust the minor parties and independents will recognise what the government is seeking to achieve and recognise this is not the time for sectoral or special interests to prevail,” he says.

But he also says all sides will need to come to the table. “This will require negotiation with the minor parties and independents in the Senate and compromise on both sides,” Mr Shepherd says. “This is democracy.”

 

Long-term structural savings including the $7 GP co-payment, university deregulation and the fuel excise are opposed by the Palmer United Party, while other crossbenchers fear the impacts of the budget on low-income earners.

 

While the Treasurer has crisscrossed Australia in a bid to secure support from powerful crossbenchers for his budget, doubts within Coalition ranks have emerged over his selling of a tough budget.

 

The audit commission’s report warned that to “do nothing” would result in a string of deficits to 2023-24, while the situation would worsen after that.

 

However, it was released on May 1 — less than a fortnight ­before Mr Hockey delivered the budget.

Critics say it was released too close to the budget, meaning there was not enough time to explain the structural challenges to voters and argue the need for action.

 

Speaking to The Weekend Australian yesterday, Mr Shepherd said convincing people of unpopular reforms took time.

“The Australian public are one of the best educated in the world and if things are explained carefully to them, even though they are not happy, they will come on board,” he said. “And this does take time.”

 

In his article today, he notes the commission’s report is not the budget. But both assume “we are living beyond our means” and that this gets worse in later years as the cost of spending on new programs, including the National Disability Insurance Scheme, ramps up.

 

Mr Shepherd writes today that tax reform is “necessary”, but bringing the budget back to a “sustainable” surplus by revenue measures alone would “strangle the economy”. He singles out the top marginal tax rate of 49 per cent and the company tax rate, which was higher than that in Britain.

Message 10 of 15
Latest reply