Here's A Situation........

An individual who alledges he interrupted a burglary at his home, jumped in his vehicle, trailed the fleeing perpetrator for a distance, then ran him over...........fatally.  Some folks on facebook laud him as a hero, far too few bother to examine the consequences of his actions.  He had already notified the police, and he was in no fear for his life.

 

Do you think, with the information provided, he should be indicted for, at least, 2nd degree murder?

 

Back a few years ago,  armed gunmen entered a drugstore in Oklahoma.......the manager wounded one, then chased the others outside.  He returned, went into the back room to obtain another weapon, then pumped five more shots into the first thug, who was laying on the floor.

 

A jury found that he was justified in the first shot, but the following five shots constituted murder, and the manager was sentenced to life in prison.  That same week, the other robbers were convicted of murder and sentenced also.

Message 1 of 98
Latest reply
97 REPLIES 97

Here's A Situation........

Good for you...Woman Happy



____________________________
"High and low pressure systems cause the day-to-day changes in our weather." ...Metoffice.......


siggie-reported-by-alarmists..............
Message 81 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

Heart

Message 82 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

Gotta love it 4c.

 

 

 

Some sho know how to work it.  

 

We call it self-serving in my neck of the woods.

 

 

I would just simply suggest this, post the link in the op, at the beginning, if the intent is to have an intellectually honest debate.

 

And you are so correct, each state has different laws.  Thank God for that!




"If it is once again one against forty-eight, then I am very sorry for the forty-eight." ~ Margaret Thatcher

“I predict future happiness for Americans, if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them.” ― Thomas Jefferson
Message 83 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

I like what you're saying, but I think the shark's been jumped.

 

I've repeatedly tried to stay on topic and have a serious discussion, but it just isn't happening.

 

Do they lock threads here when they devolve to this extent?

Message 84 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

Boy, again, far be it from me to explain some things, lol.

 

You did your best, kept it on topic.  What else can you do?  Tried hard to get at the crux, the truth of the matter.

 

You did a fine job exposing some things, it is clear to those who can see and think.

 

Better to live and fight another day, lol.




"If it is once again one against forty-eight, then I am very sorry for the forty-eight." ~ Margaret Thatcher

“I predict future happiness for Americans, if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them.” ― Thomas Jefferson
Message 85 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

you're welcome,bless your heart! Heart

taste my religion! nibble a witch! 😄
Message 86 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

Did someone intentionally run someone down?

 

(The apparently forgotten topic of diccussion here.)

 

---------------------------

 

Did the victim chase the criminal down with the intent of killing him, or was his intent to apprehend, and the death an accident precipitated by the home invader's criminal act? 

 

I don't believe the OP said the home-owner intentionally ran over the burglar.  Here are his exact words:

 

An individual who alledges he interrupted a burglary at his home, jumped in his vehicle, trailed the fleeing perpetrator for a distance, then ran him over...........fatally.

 

He never used the word intentional at all.  And he did ask the question, that if this man caused a death, should he be charged with at least 2nd degree murder.  He threw this topic out for discussion.  Not to be attacked.  Not to start a fight.  But to discuss.  Unfortunately some people want to do nothing but start interpersonal disputes.  Day in and day out.  Sad.

Message 87 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

Hello, everyone.

 

 

This thread is getting a little off-topic and interpersonal disputes are taking place.

 

Please remember the Community guidelines when making comment. In particular, Posting disruptive or hostile comments including interpersonal disputes.

 

You can review the Community Guidelines here: http://pages.ebay.com.au/help/policies/everyone-boards.html

 

Cheers,

Luna

 

Message 88 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

sgt schultz photo:  SgtSchultz.jpg
Message 89 of 98
Latest reply

Here's A Situation........

i believe i'll walk away now. nighters!!Heart

taste my religion! nibble a witch! 😄
Message 90 of 98
Latest reply