Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review

nero_bolt
Community Member

ABOUT TIME... The lefties and the greens will hate this and the left teachers and unions will hate it as well..... GOOD hope they do as its about time the left and labor and the unions and teachers stoped brain washing our children with their twisted left views and we got back to values and teaching our kids properly...... 

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

THE Abbott government has moved to reshape school education by appointing strong critics of the national curriculum to review what children are taught, amid fears a "cultural Left" agenda is failing students.

 

The Education Minister, Christopher Pyne, is seeking a blueprint by mid-year to overhaul the curriculum, warning that the rise of "remedial" classes at universities proves the depths of the problem in Australian classrooms.

 

Vowing to restore an "orthodox" curriculum, Mr Pyne named author and former teacher Kevin Donnelly and business professor Ken Wiltshire this morning to lead the review.

 

 

The appointments clear the way for reforms that could expunge parts of the history syllabus that Tony Abbott has blasted for favouring Labor and the unions but glossing over the work of Coalition prime ministers.

 

Mr Donnelly is a fierce critic of the "relativism" in the teaching program, while Professor Wiltshire has rejected the emphasis on "competencies" and urged a sharper focus on knowledge and assessment.

 

The looming changes could spark another "culture war", given past brawls, including John Howard's criticism in 2007 of the "shameful" neglect of Australian history and the disputes over Julia Gillard's introduction of the national curriculum in 2010.

 

Writing in The Australian today, Mr Pyne declares that parents want a curriculum that is "free of partisan bias" and deals with real-world issues.

 

Concerns about the teaching program have deepened in recent years as the nation lost ground in global assessments of reading, maths and science, putting Australian students behind their counterparts in Vietnam, Poland and Estonia.  (all under Julia and labor and the billions they threw at the system only to fail) 

 

 

Canberra and the states agreed on changes to the curriculum last year but the new review throws open the debate to the public, allowing for wider consultation and possibly the holding of open hearings.

 

Mr Pyne said he expected the states to accept the need for change, given signs of the problems with the current curriculum

 

I think the fact that universities are teaching maths and English remedial courses is a symptom of an education system that isn't meeting the needs of students who go on to university, and that's something the reviewers will be taking a close look at," Mr Pyne said. "The term 'remedial' implies a remedy for a problem and one of the priorities for all governments should be removing the problem."

 

 

A key complaint about the curriculum is its emphasis on seven "general capabilities" rather than essential knowledge in fields such as maths, English and history.

 

Former History Teachers Association president Paul Kiem has warned that this led to a "tick a box" approach to teaching a subject. A similar view was put by NSW Board of Studies president Tom Alegounarias.

 

Mr Donnelly, a regular contributor to The Australian, has warned against a "subjective" view of culture that neglects the Judeo-Christian values at the core of Australian institutions.

 

He has also savaged a civics curriculum that teaches that "citizenship means different things to different people at different times", rather than preparing students for an understanding of their responsibilities. "The civics curriculum argues in favour of a postmodern, deconstructed definition of citizenship," he wrote last year.

 

"The flaws are manifest. What right do Australians have to expect migrants to accept our laws, institutions and way of life?

 

"Such a subjective view of citizenship allows Islamic fundamentalists to justify mistreating women and carrying out jihad against non-believers."

 

Mandating a "cultural left national curriculum" would fail students, he wrote.

 

Professor Wiltshire branded the curriculum a "failure" last January - prior to changes that were put in place last year.

 

"A school curriculum should be based on a set of values, yet it is almost impossible to determine what values have been explicitly used to design the proposed model," he wrote of the changes under the Gillard government.

 

"Curriculum should also be knowledge-based, yet we are faced with an experiment that focuses on process or competencies."

Professor Wiltshire also attacked the "astounding devaluation of the book" in modern teaching.

 

In his outline of the changes, Mr Pyne points to complaints that history classes are not recognising the legacy of Western civilisation and not giving enough prominence to big events in Australian history such as Anzac Day.

 

Mr Pyne told The Australian yesterday he "most definitely" stood by his past criticisms of the curriculum, including its neglect of business and commerce in the country's history.

 

"I believe the curriculum should be orthodox and should tell students about where we've come from and why we are the country we are today, so we can shape our future appropriately," he said.

 

He said he supported the "unvarnished truth" in the curriculum on everything from the treatment of indigenous Australians to political history. "There is little place in a curriculum for elevating relativism over the truth."

 

Deals with the states are a key factor in the plan after The Australian reported last month that some state education ministers had challenged Mr Pyne over his "command-and-control" approach to the teaching program.

 

The ministerial talks were held amid the heated debate over the government's shifting position on a $1.2 billion outlay on the Gonski education reforms.

 

Mr Pyne told The Australian there was a "moral suasion" to improving the teaching program.

 

"The states, I am sure, would want to implement the best curriculum without a financial incentive to do so," he said.

 

The current curriculum has three priorities across subjects - indigenous culture, Asia and sustainability - but Mr Pyne questioned their merits.

 

"It's difficult to see in maths and science how those three themes are necessarily relevant," he said in an interview. "Themes should not be elevated above a robust curriculum."

 

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/pyne-tackles-bias-in-classrooms-with-national-curri...

 

Message 1 of 271
Latest reply
270 REPLIES 270

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review


@*mrgrizz* wrote:

did you know "F" no longer appears on report cards

 

can't have your children thinking they are dumb


 if a child is struggling they already know it. no need to rub it in .  how about a return to dunce caps ?

Message 31 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review


@lakeland27 wrote:

@polocross58 wrote:

quote

 

'  .... while most students learn about the Holocaust and what happened under the Nazis, few know about atrocities in the Asian Pacific.  The Japanese aggression began in 1931, and most history classes don’t get into what was going on before America got involved in the war.'  end quote

 

 

http://thealternativepress.com/articles/exhibit-sparks-students-to-learn-about-world-war


there is only so much time.  and there is no more to tell fgs. WW2 history is a hobby for old men. its no more than a script for a first person shooter .


I don't agree with that either.

 

When we understand why WW2 happened in the first place, which takes us back before WW1 and the TOV, and evaluate what happened as a result of that (including beliefs of today - this is not a Godwin Statement, it is far more overarching than that) we understand society and how it operates today and why and how events effect each other.

 

Now I might accidentally godwin LOL, but if iot wasn't fior the TOV and the effects that it had, what reason would Hitler have used to gain control of a country and lead a world into war? Think about how he was able to do that. History shows us how people think the way that they do.


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 32 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review

The best thing you can learn in life is people skills, I don't care how many degrees a person has, I want to have someone I can communicate with.

 

But unfortunately just about every man and his dog goes to university these days, the ads on the radio basically selling an education to dummies makes me feel ill.

Photobucket
Message 33 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review

I thought that post was funny, lighten up Lakeland 🙂

Photobucket
Message 34 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review


@polocross58 wrote:

quote:

 

We're sure that's why Australia's aid budget is so generous to Indonesia. We  appreciate that the $647 million allocated this financial year is a lot and we  thank you. Will it continue? The priorities of Australia's aid budget are  consistent with ours, including education, rural development and health.

 

Australia's program to build or improve 2000 schools will increase access for  300,000 students.(in Indonesia)  It will help moderate Islamic schools to provide education  consistent with national standards and exams. And your country's scholarship  program aims to fund more than 500 Indonesian postgraduate students in Australia  next year.'  end quote

 

Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/comment/boat-quarrel-must-not-turn-friend-into-foe-20130929-2umfw.html#ixzz2px...

 

 

 

Wow --- we sure do a lot for Indonesia, huh

 

 


if we fund their schools, we get to influence what they learn. Otherwise it is reliant on what their gov chooses to teach them. This has helped bring about the peace talks in Burma, for example after 60 odd years of persecution. This allows "us" to have some control over countries that may be a threat to us, or increase things such as the need to seek asylum here.

 

If we provide Burma with a stable gov, there will be less need for people to leave.... can you see where this is headed? Less people requiring asylum....

 

and what is the best way to infiltrate a country and train it's people? History showed us this, (modern history via hitler and his education system that was pervasive throughout society, in and out of school) by being in control of what is taught.


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 35 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review

I think the fact that universities are teaching maths and English remedial courses is a symptom of an education system that isn't meeting the needs of students who go on to university

 


So what is new? When I first met Elizabeth Jolley 20 odd years ago she was teaching remedial English at a University. How many Governments, both State and Federal and on both sides of politics have we had in that tme?

 

When I did my O levels in UK (roughly the equivalent then of the old Leaving Certificatehere) we studied two English courses, English Literature and English Language. English Language encompassed all the 'boring' bits - grammar, syntax, spelling comprehension etc - BU,T a pass in this subject was the one thing  demanded by nearly all prospective employers.

I can't speak for what the current situation is in England , but I'm pretty sure if the current Austrlalian system put more emphasis on teaching the mechanics of the English Language, then I wouldn't be conducting workshops with creativeely gifted children who simply don't have the tools to express clearly what they want to write. 

Message 36 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review

its funny. but i'm serious about dunce caps.

Message 37 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review


@azureline** wrote:

There is a lot of wasted time in school.

How many times have you heard a parent say they are keeping a child home because they don't do much in the last week of school?

I always thought the purpose of education was to impart the knowledge children need, to be able to get to a point where what interests them, can be learned by themselves?


not just that, but all the things that schools are expected to fit into the school day. And "didn't do much in the last week" is subjective. That's when the covert curriculum is in play.

 

Remember that there are two curriculums in an education,

 

The overt one addressed by official policy documents. and the covert one, which delivers the kind of curriculum that underpins the true purpose of schools.

 

and your last sentence - we teach them what we want them to know so that they can learn the things that we want them to learn and so we can manipulate their thinking conducive to the society in which they live.


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 38 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review

Those who fail to learn from the mistkes of History are doomed to repeat them.

 


I hope we remember that when we teach our chidren about Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan

Message 39 of 271
Latest reply

Pyne tackles 'bias' in classrooms with national curriculum review


@*mrgrizz* wrote:

did you know "F" no longer appears on report cards

 

can't have your children thinking they are dumb


it does at uni....

 

so think about the ramifications of that in relation to the remedial classes in uni in the OP...

 

for 12 years a child learns to be "average" (a C is "meeting standards/expectations, but the important factors here are "whose standards" and "who determines how those standards have been met"? )

 

Then the ballgame changes and they get an F when the effects of the sorting house start to be realized...


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 40 of 271
Latest reply