Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

nero_bolt
Community Member

Tasmania's economy is a green labor basket case and the state is bankrupt and dependent on wealfare from the rest of Australia to survive. 

 

An interesting article thats actually true about Tasmania  written by David Leyonhjelm

 

 

Having once lived there, I know Tasmania is a pleasant place to live. But so is Greece. And if Tasmania was an independent country, it would be in more trouble than Greece.

 

There was quite a lot of discussion about this in 2013. A good summary came in an article by Jonathan West, director of the Australian Innovation Research Centre and a resident of Tasmania, who described the state as follow: “Tasmania ranks at the bottom among Australian states on virtually every dimension of economic, social, and cultural performance

 

  • highest unemployment,
  • lowest incomes,
  • languishing investment,
  • lowest home prices,
  • least educated,
  • lowest literacy,
  • most chronic disease,
  • poorest longevity,
  • most likely to smoke,
  • greatest obesity,
  • highest teenage pregnancy,
  • highest petty crime,
  • worst domestic violence

Tasmania is also a mendicant state, highly reliant on the rest of the country. It generates about a third of its state budget, the rest being GST allocations and specific purpose payments from the commonwealth.

 

GST and income tax originating within the state fall well short of what it receives, meaning the government effectively receives welfare from the rest of the country.

 

When the NSW economy goes into recession, one of the consequences is less money for Tasmania.

 

This is on top of the higher proportions of welfare that Tasmanian individuals receive

 

The rest of the interesting article can be read here and its a very good read...... http://catallaxyfiles.com/2014/03/07/david-leyonhjelm-tasmania-a-province-of-victoria/ 

 

 

 

So should Tasmania become a province of Victoria? 

 

 

That is if Victoraia would want a  green/labor bankrupt basket case that is Tasmania as part of it

 

 

 

Message 1 of 58
Latest reply
57 REPLIES 57

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

perhaps the population could sell the island state for $5,000,000 per head of population. To Australian buyers

 

That would be a very cheap price to pay for the island state.

 

That would generate 240,000millionairs to invest in new ventures and create employment and investment

 

 

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 11 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

Soooo...Tasmania could become an independent island with a new Head of State (with a large chequebook).

 

A trifle alarming considering the applicants for Malta's sell-off of citizenship.

 

how would the creator of Harry Potter feel about that? She buys a house, then the whole place is up for sale.

 

I would feel rather aggrieved in her position.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Buttercup: You mock my pain! Man in Black: Life is pain, Highness. Anyone who says differently is selling something.
Message 12 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

It could become a tax free haven like Monaco or even like Andorra, only bigger. A playpen for the rich and famous 🙂

 

Some days you can skii and swim on the same day.

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 13 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

You really should avoid showing off your maths skills.

Message 14 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

Imagine this as you private playground

 

Wineglass Bay.jpg

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 15 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

NZ might be interested

Message 16 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

How are you going to manage living under a liberal government come the 16th. March Freaki?

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 17 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?


@*mrgrizz* wrote:

NZ might be interested


mrgrizz NZ may have a sheep problem but they are not that stupid 🙂 

 

So whats everyone’s thoughts on this assessment of Tasmania, very damming and it sure isnt a  pretty picture of the state or the people that live there....

 

: “Tasmania ranks at the bottom among Australian states on virtually every dimension of economic, social, and cultural performance

 

  • highest unemployment,
  • lowest incomes,
  • languishing investment,
  • lowest home prices,
  • least educated,
  • lowest literacy,
  • most chronic disease,
  • poorest longevity,
  • most likely to smoke,
  • greatest obesity,
  • highest teenage pregnancy,
  • highest petty crime,
  • worst domestic violence

Tasmania is also a mendicant state, highly reliant on the rest of the country. It generates about a third of its state budget, the rest being GST allocations and specific purpose payments from the commonwealth.

Message 18 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?

The same as I do now.

Message 19 of 58
Latest reply

Tasmania – a province of Victoria?


@nero_wulf wrote:

@*mrgrizz* wrote:

NZ might be interested


mrgrizz NZ may have a sheep problem but they are not that stupid 🙂 

 

So whats everyone’s thoughts on this assessment of Tasmania, very damming and it sure isnt a  pretty picture of the state or the people that live there....

 

: “Tasmania ranks at the bottom among Australian states on virtually every dimension of economic, social, and cultural performance

 

  • highest unemployment,
  • lowest incomes,
  • languishing investment,
  • lowest home prices,
  • least educated,
  • lowest literacy,
  • most chronic disease,
  • poorest longevity,
  • most likely to smoke,
  • greatest obesity,
  • highest teenage pregnancy,
  • highest petty crime,
  • worst domestic violence

Tasmania is also a mendicant state, highly reliant on the rest of the country. It generates about a third of its state budget, the rest being GST allocations and specific purpose payments from the commonwealth.


well then lets give it to Indonesia

a lot shorter and safer trip for boat people

Message 20 of 58
Latest reply