We all need look after the disabled.

And not just because it would make us all feel warm and fuzzy. There are good, hard-headed economic arguments for increasing our disability spend which is currently below many OECD countries.


 


 


 


PAUL Prendergast is the father of a 26-year-old daughter who - he states proudly - enjoys an "active social life, attendance of a drama group and a dance group and 10-pin bowling".


But Mr Prendergast's daughter also has Down syndrome and, like many ageing parents of a disabled child, he worries about his daughter's future. He fears she will end up in an aged care facility when he and his wife die.


 


"This thought fills us with dread as our daughter's quality of life would evaporate should she be housed far from her friends and activities," he wrote in a submission to the Productivity Commission's 2010 inquiry into disability care.


 


Trevor and Trish Browning's daughter died at just 13. In their submission, they describe the "constant battle to get assistance" for their daughter who suffered Rhett syndrome.


"We had to fight for every aid and facility" they wrote. "We saw so many people just give up in despair as they did not have the stamina or time to take on the myriad Government departments and agencies that purport to provide services."


 


These are just two of the heartbreaking stories contained in the more than 1000 public submissions to the Commission's inquiry. They detail the "emotional and financial roller coaster", the "humiliation and isolation" and "unrelenting and huge" stresses of living with a disability in this country.


Truth is, disability could happen to any one of us, at any time.


 


All of us face the very real possibility of having a child with a disability or suffering from a catastrophic injury ourselves.


 


So all Australians have an interest in providing better services and care for the sick and the disabled.


And not just because it would make us all feel warm and fuzzy. There are good, hard-headed economic arguments for increasing our disability spend which is currently below many OECD countries.


Australia has the seventh lowest employment rate for people with disabilities in the OECD.


 


Better support for disabled people wanting to enter the workforce could lift gross domestic product by a full percentage point by 2050, or $32 billion in today's prices, according to the Productivity Commission. Not only would these new workers pay income tax, they would require less income support.


There would be other benefits, too, from improving the wellbeing of people with disabilities and their carers, efficiency gains through better provision of services and reduced strain on hospital budgets from caring for disabled people.


 


"The bottom line is that benefits of the NDIS would significantly exceed the additional costs of the scheme," the Commission found.


 


Which leaves us with the thorny question of just who is going to pay?


In outlining the extra $6.5 billion a year needed to bring disability care funding up to acceptable levels, the Productivity Commission did not stipulate how this should be funded. But it did stress the funding would need to be secure and stable into the future.


 


Raising the GST was one option canvassed. A Medicare-style levy was the other and it appears the Government is readying to do just that in the May Budget.


 


The Government currently raises $9.6 billion a year through the Medicare levy which is a 1.5 per cent tax on all taxpayers earning more than around $24,000. Boosting this levy by 0.5 percentage points would raise an extra $3.2 billion a year. A person earning $50,000 would pay about $250 more a year.


Alternatively, the Government could impose a separate 1 per cent "disability care and support premium" which would raise around $6.4 billion a year - enough to fund the NDIS in its entirety.


 


There are several advantages to such a levy, particularly if badged as an insurance premium. According to the Commission: "There is some value in using the word `premium' instead of tax or levy because it would make it clear that every taxpayer is getting a service - namely an insurance product, that provides him or her with disability supports if they are required."


But let's not sugar coat it.


Any new levy would essentially be an increase to all personal income tax rates.


 


Such a hike would go some way to taking back some of the unsustainable tax cuts handed out by the Howard and Rudd governments which were funded by a once-in-a-century mining boom which has just run out of puff.


 


The downside of a levy is that it would add more complexity to the already complex tax system. But given the unpopularity of raising personal income tax rates, such chicanery may be necessary.


 


There is also a risk that a disabilities levy would make people less inclined to make separate charitable donations to disability care. But the certainty of funding would be worth it.


 


If set too low, the levy could also risk giving the false impression that it fully funds the cost of the scheme. Indeed, the Medicare levy doesn't come close to funding all Medicare linked services. 


The bottom line is that the money for disability care must come from somewhere. And that somewhere is us.


 


The Government must make every effort to cut wasteful spending and remove unfair tax concessions. But it's clear that taxes must rise too to meet the Budget challenge.


 


So how about it? Are you willing to chip in a little extra to support those suffering the most in our community, like the Prendergasts and the Brownings?


 


Are you willing to pay a little insurance for the fact that it could be you, or someone you love, one day? I am. 




 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/we-all-need-look-after-the-disabled/story-e6freuy9-12266325529...


 

Message 1 of 261
Latest reply
260 REPLIES 260

We all need look after the disabled.

http://www.abc.net.au/rampup/articles/2013/05/01/3749022.htm


Why fund NDIS?


Because one day you might need it.


Stella Young Ramp Up 1 May 2013


 


Far too many Australians seem to think that disability has nothing to do with them. But the NDIS is not about people like me who currently live with disabilities, it's about all of those who might in the future, writes Stella Young.


 


The question of how we fund the National Disability Insurance Scheme is one that I've managed to avoid quite well for the past 12 months.


 


For people with disabilities, myself included, discussions about the money are simply beside the point. We don't think about the NDIS in terms of dollars; we think about it in terms of showers per week, mobility aids that meet our needs and general access to our communities.


 


I've been known to say quite publicly that I don't give a rat's cracker how we fund it, as long as it happens. But with the...


The Productivity Commission recommended the NDIS be funded from general revenue. That'd be great wou...


 


The levy would be an addition to the Medicare levy currently paid by Australians - an increase from 1.5 to 2 per cent....


 


Predictably, cries of "It's so unfair" and "Why should I have to pay for these people" came thick an...a piece by Matt Young. Despite our shared surname, Matt is no relation to me and I don't know him pe...


 


It's just that he, like far too many Australians, seems to think that disability has nothing to do w...


"How selfish of me to want to spend money that I'm working hard for on myself! To put clothes on my ...


 


In the spirit of healthy debate, news.com.au invited a response from me. I'm a fellow taxpayer, after all. I share some of Matt's concerns about wanting ...


 


I told Matt that I also spend money on my clothes, my food and my morning coffees, but that in 2012 ...


I wrote that because I live in Victoria where the current maximum funding for a wheelchair is $8,000...


Interestingly, much of the criticism I've received since news.com.au published my response has focus...


Perhaps I should have clarified that my wheelchair is by no means a Porsche among Holdens. It has a ...


 


Let me make this clear; my impairment is such that without a wheelchair, I can't do very much for my...


 


I also need to declare my relative position of privilege as a person with disability in Australia. I...


 


Australia ranks last among the OECD countries when measured on quality of life for people with disab...


 


This is not the case for many people. Half of all people with disabilities live near or below the poverty li...


 


I may not need a new wheelchair for another 10 years. Heck, I managed to get 17 out of my old one. I...


Because just as I might maintain my independence, you might lose yours.


The National Disability Insurance Scheme is an investment in all Australians. It's not about people ...


 


With the time to talk about funding comes the time to talk about what kind of country we want to be....


Mine's out.


What about yours?


 


 


 


Crikey, I think that it is to be expected that the cost and needs may  change as will the population .The number of those needing support and the type of support and the cost of that in the future can't be predicted with accuracy  can it ? 


 


 


 

Message 151 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

well our leaders have certainly proven to us that they can't determine anything long term.


 


And that's the whole point. The NDIS is a short term money grab to raise revenue for promises they already lack the funds to keep.


 


The public are buying the general propaganda and puffery without understanding exactly what it is and what it is designed to do.


 


The system as it is being sold to us, is NOT sustainable long term.


 


It will pave the way for abuse by non genuine claims (look at our current worker's compensation system). It will eradicate our fault based compensation system, and for what? The people who need the help, those who suffer non traumatic illnesses and disabilities will once again be left to suffer from underfunding.


 


People need to open their eyes! They need to look at the whole picture instead of "What's in it for me" because the bottom line is, there is nothing in it for anyone.


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 152 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

people think that everyone will be able to "participate" that everyone will have access to the level of service and assistance that they require....


 


ROFL - that worked out so well for our education and health systems, didn't it?


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 153 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

who thinks that Crikey Mate ? 


doesn't it make sense that without some things (ie;Stella Young needs a wheelchair) some never will even have the chance to function at all ?As Stella says without that wheelchair she is total DEPENDENT 


 


http://www.abc.net.au/pm/content/2013/s3749523.htm


 


isability employer hits out at NDIS critics


Sally Sara reported this story on Wednesday, May 1, 2013 17:04:00


 


TIM PALMER: Australia's largest employer of people with disabilities, the Endeavour Foundation, has ...










read more:http://www.abc.net.au/pm/content/2013/s3749523.htm

Message 154 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

our education system and health system is still feeling it's way around the Community focus that was supposed to replace segregation in education and institutions of the pre 1990's.

Message 155 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

http://www.brw.com.au/p/business/outsmarting_the_politicians_disabled_sa1rvgCztQb4gfs6L8VkQM


 


A rather cynical comment by Michelle Grattan on politics, planning, and paying for the NDIS.  


 


 


 


 

Message 156 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

Disability advocate backs levy for NDIS


Updated Wed May 1, 2013 12:46pm AEST


 


President of People with Disability Australia Craig Wallace says an increase to the Medicare levy is the right way to fund the NDIS.


 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-05-01/disability-advocate-backs-levy-for-ndis/4662420


 


 


 

Message 157 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

How many "Stella's" will get the wheelchair they need and for how long?


 


And that's just the tip of the iceberg.


 


How many non traumatic tetraplegics will be afforded assistance for more than 3 hours a week?


 


(That's one hour a day, three times a week for everything! to shower, toilet, clean the house, change clothes, run errands etc etc)


 


At least in the current fault based system, those suffering from traumatic injuries/illnesses get some kind of compensation to sustain their lives, as do some non traumatic ones - with an unsustainable no fault based system, eventually no one will get any reasonable level of care as the coffers empty and funds are stretched to breaking.


 


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 158 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.


So what happens when the NDIS system doesn't have the funds to provide people with what they need? What happens if the gov has underestimated future demands and costs again?


 



That is what I was wondering as well. The full  NDIS system doesn't come in place until 2018. That is quite awhile away and changes in Govt, funding etc could impact on that between now and then.



 


It's already known that NDIS will have nowhere near enough funds to make it an effective operation so it will be forced to raise more money from the taxpayer yet again or crash and burn.


Either way, a great deal of the revenues raised from this new levy will never see any disabled usage because it will be paying ever more useless civil servants wages instead.

Message 159 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

Anonymous
Not applicable

Lakeland, in the bush, our small Fire Brigades are always looking for funding, much of it we raise ourselves, this levy will help all of us have good equipment and infastructure, to fight fires,  hopefully the Governments won't cut their funding and put us back in the dark ages again.


 


My niece is looking forward to the new Disability Scheme, it will mean she won't have to fight for the help she both needs and deserves.  Everyone will be on an equal footing.  That's the theory, hope it is the outcome too.

Message 160 of 261
Latest reply