We all need look after the disabled.

And not just because it would make us all feel warm and fuzzy. There are good, hard-headed economic arguments for increasing our disability spend which is currently below many OECD countries.


 


 


 


PAUL Prendergast is the father of a 26-year-old daughter who - he states proudly - enjoys an "active social life, attendance of a drama group and a dance group and 10-pin bowling".


But Mr Prendergast's daughter also has Down syndrome and, like many ageing parents of a disabled child, he worries about his daughter's future. He fears she will end up in an aged care facility when he and his wife die.


 


"This thought fills us with dread as our daughter's quality of life would evaporate should she be housed far from her friends and activities," he wrote in a submission to the Productivity Commission's 2010 inquiry into disability care.


 


Trevor and Trish Browning's daughter died at just 13. In their submission, they describe the "constant battle to get assistance" for their daughter who suffered Rhett syndrome.


"We had to fight for every aid and facility" they wrote. "We saw so many people just give up in despair as they did not have the stamina or time to take on the myriad Government departments and agencies that purport to provide services."


 


These are just two of the heartbreaking stories contained in the more than 1000 public submissions to the Commission's inquiry. They detail the "emotional and financial roller coaster", the "humiliation and isolation" and "unrelenting and huge" stresses of living with a disability in this country.


Truth is, disability could happen to any one of us, at any time.


 


All of us face the very real possibility of having a child with a disability or suffering from a catastrophic injury ourselves.


 


So all Australians have an interest in providing better services and care for the sick and the disabled.


And not just because it would make us all feel warm and fuzzy. There are good, hard-headed economic arguments for increasing our disability spend which is currently below many OECD countries.


Australia has the seventh lowest employment rate for people with disabilities in the OECD.


 


Better support for disabled people wanting to enter the workforce could lift gross domestic product by a full percentage point by 2050, or $32 billion in today's prices, according to the Productivity Commission. Not only would these new workers pay income tax, they would require less income support.


There would be other benefits, too, from improving the wellbeing of people with disabilities and their carers, efficiency gains through better provision of services and reduced strain on hospital budgets from caring for disabled people.


 


"The bottom line is that benefits of the NDIS would significantly exceed the additional costs of the scheme," the Commission found.


 


Which leaves us with the thorny question of just who is going to pay?


In outlining the extra $6.5 billion a year needed to bring disability care funding up to acceptable levels, the Productivity Commission did not stipulate how this should be funded. But it did stress the funding would need to be secure and stable into the future.


 


Raising the GST was one option canvassed. A Medicare-style levy was the other and it appears the Government is readying to do just that in the May Budget.


 


The Government currently raises $9.6 billion a year through the Medicare levy which is a 1.5 per cent tax on all taxpayers earning more than around $24,000. Boosting this levy by 0.5 percentage points would raise an extra $3.2 billion a year. A person earning $50,000 would pay about $250 more a year.


Alternatively, the Government could impose a separate 1 per cent "disability care and support premium" which would raise around $6.4 billion a year - enough to fund the NDIS in its entirety.


 


There are several advantages to such a levy, particularly if badged as an insurance premium. According to the Commission: "There is some value in using the word `premium' instead of tax or levy because it would make it clear that every taxpayer is getting a service - namely an insurance product, that provides him or her with disability supports if they are required."


But let's not sugar coat it.


Any new levy would essentially be an increase to all personal income tax rates.


 


Such a hike would go some way to taking back some of the unsustainable tax cuts handed out by the Howard and Rudd governments which were funded by a once-in-a-century mining boom which has just run out of puff.


 


The downside of a levy is that it would add more complexity to the already complex tax system. But given the unpopularity of raising personal income tax rates, such chicanery may be necessary.


 


There is also a risk that a disabilities levy would make people less inclined to make separate charitable donations to disability care. But the certainty of funding would be worth it.


 


If set too low, the levy could also risk giving the false impression that it fully funds the cost of the scheme. Indeed, the Medicare levy doesn't come close to funding all Medicare linked services. 


The bottom line is that the money for disability care must come from somewhere. And that somewhere is us.


 


The Government must make every effort to cut wasteful spending and remove unfair tax concessions. But it's clear that taxes must rise too to meet the Budget challenge.


 


So how about it? Are you willing to chip in a little extra to support those suffering the most in our community, like the Prendergasts and the Brownings?


 


Are you willing to pay a little insurance for the fact that it could be you, or someone you love, one day? I am. 




 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/we-all-need-look-after-the-disabled/story-e6freuy9-12266325529...


 

Message 1 of 261
Latest reply
260 REPLIES 260

We all need look after the disabled.


I think a lot of the problems governments face with funding is due to trying to keep up with societal changes.  Unfortunately, we have become very insular.


There are so many ways of dealing with things that don't necessarily have to cost money or rely on funding.


There are a group of us who help out with another friend's child who has a brain injury.  She requires a lot of physio to prevent contractions and painful muscle spasming and chest percussion to prevent chest infections.  We take turns at helping with the exercises (usually requires 2 people).  A physio friend showed us what to do and checks in every now and then.


 


Just this small amount of voluntary assistance helps to reduce appointments, both in and out of hospital, to a minimum thus saving the system some money.  As a result of the contact we have with the child,  most of us are now confident in looking after her if mum wants to go out, do the shopping, activities with the other kids etc.  One friend in particular, has stayed on weekends with her so that the family can have a weekend away.  This reduces the need for respite.


 


I think a more beneficial way of alleviating some of the problems we have is to look at old fashioned solutions.  We need to encourage community spirit and get some soul back into society.  Look after each other at a grass roots level.


 


Throwing money at things all the time has proven that it is not always the answer to solving problems.



 


EXCELLENT POST.
You are a wonderful person for your part in that families life.


Your story made my heart smile :-x

********* *********** *********** ************ ************ *********** ***********
Be Kind To Nurses....
They Stop The Doctors From Killing You.
Message 21 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.


  We need to encourage community spirit and get some soul back into society.  Look after each other at a grass roots level.


 



I agree with that, although more people work outside the home than they did years ago, so not that many with the free time to help out others in need.



 


You are right Am, ......finding time is difficult but can also become an excuse.  I look at volunteering like exercise......if you want to see results then you just have to do it.


 


We work on a roster basis...some can do more than others and others are restricted to when they can do it.  The sense of goodwill far outweighs the inconvenience.  You get a great buzz seeing the family 'coping'.


 


 

Message 22 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

Mrs Wormwood, good on you.


Unfortunately those who have a problem with the cost of a cup of coffee ...won't be very inclined to do what you do...which is soooooooo much more 

Message 23 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.


 


yes and this new tax will be just as helpful as that tax 😞


 


tell me what is the difference between a tax and a levy?



 


 


The funny thing is The Carbon Tax was never about revenue raising..


 


the NDIS is about people and has the potential to create/save money.


 


I don't know the difference between a tax/levy to me they are just names....it's what/who;us in this case...it is for that matters to me.

Message 24 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

Can we start a Mrs M fan club?


 


I lubs her heart so much♥

Message 25 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

Iza, individual, targeted care based on the kind of disability with the aim of them being able to cope as well as is possible, and IF possible enter the workforce.  A massive campaign to encourage employers to employ people with disabilities.  Heaps of information about the various kinds of disabilities that there are and how people (bosses, other staff), can work WITH people with disability.  I think that there is a whole heap of ignorance out there about disability ... 


 


And, it can vary so much.  A person without a leg ... a blind person ... a person with a mental illness or depression ... a person with Down syndrome ... but they're often all shoved together as "a person with a disability".  I worked for a while with people with an intellectual disability ... absolutely gorgeous wonderful people who wanted to work and pay taxes and BE productive.  What happened to them?  Sacked or forced to quit.  


 


 

Message 26 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

And, didn't I hear that the Disability Support Pension is likely to be cut to help pay for the NDIS?  


 


 

Message 27 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

http://www.ndis.gov.au/about-an-ndis/what-is-an-ndis/


 


What is an NDIS?


 


Depending on life’s chances, any one of us could be living with a permanent disability that significantly reduces our ability to independently care for ourselves. On average, every 30 minutes someone in Australia is diagnosed with a significant disability.


 


Yet in Australia, we have a cruel lottery where the services and support people with disability, their families and carers receive depends on where they live, what disability they have, and how they attained that disability.


 


As the Productivity Commission found, while there are pockets of success in some states, no disability supp...


This is despite the enormous effort of disability workers on the ground helping to provide support a...


 


Instead, people with disability are caught in a system that responds to crisis; a system that drips ...


The Prime Minister released the Productivity Commission’s report on 10 August 2011 and all governments agreed with the recommendatio...


 


An NDIS will turn the way we currently provide disability services on its head. Rather than funding ...


 


It will recognise that disability is for a lifetime, and so it will take a lifelong approach to prov...


 


Taking a lifelong approach also means focusing on intensive early intervention, particularly for peo...


 


Importantly, an NDIS will support choice for people with disability, their families and carers, and ...


 


An NDIS will ensure people are no longer “shut out” from opportunities and from independence by prov...


It will nurture and sustain the support of families, carers and friendship groups — the very communi...


 


And it will include a comprehensive information and referral service, to help people with a disabili...


 


A National Disability Insurance Scheme will give all Australians the peace of mind to know that if t...ted

Message 28 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.


Moorna, I know that you have been through quite a lot.The services need to exist don't they? Even people who may have the money to pay may find that the services they need no not exist..


 



 


I'm sick and tired of people sobbing on my shoulders about their personal issues while having ever more money gouged out of my pockets that I worked bloody hard for all my working life without receiving help from anyone else during the bad times.


 


No-one gave a stuff years ago when I couldn't work for months after a bad road crash that was due to someone else's carelessness, and the government wouldn't offer me a cent to help us get by because they considered that because I had my own business I could afford to look after my own needs, but when you are stuck flat out on a bed unable to work at your own business it's impossible to raise money to cover anything.


It near on sent us to the wall financially, and if it hadn't been for the bit of money my wife was able to bring in by taking on a menial part time job cleaning motel rooms while also trying her best to look after me at the same time while I was laid up we would have not only lost everything, but ended up deep in debt. 


In the end I had to find the money to pay for my own spinal fusion operation so I could work properly again, and that took some real doing at the time I can tell you.


I still suffer daily pain from it all now, but I get past it by grinning and bearing it with the help of a few strong painkillers.


 


I have always taken care of my own, and now I pay private insurances to ensure that I am taken care of properly should the need ever arise as I have no-one else left to do it, so I see no reason why I should be expected to pay more taxes to be wasted on things that are not my responsibility.


 


I only still work at what I do for the simple pleasure of it, not to hand out my money to every Tom, Dick or Harry with yet another sob story, or an ever increasingly greedy taxman.

Message 29 of 261
Latest reply

We all need look after the disabled.

Katy, The FAQ on the NDIS site may answer some of your questions...who it will cover..short and long term plans 

Message 30 of 261
Latest reply