on 27-08-2013 09:55 AM
Rudd's pledge to move navy from Garden Island 'a threat to NSW economy'
NSW Premier Barry O'Farrell has lashed Kevin Rudd's surprise pledge to move navy warships from Sydney's Garden Island to northern Australia as a threat to the state's economy.
The Prime Minister says the move is part of a long-term plan to modernise the navy and respond to defence and security priorities.
But the announcement, which has been costed at $6 billion, is a policy u-turn for Labor, with Julia Gillard's 2013 defence white paper deciding against the move.
Mr O'Farrell says a 2011 review found Garden Island injected $470 million a year into the NSW economy and employed 6700 people, including up to 4000 jobs at the naval base.
"My concern today waking up to this news, without any advice beforehand, off the back of a defence review that said 'don't change the current arrangements', is this is going to be devastating for those families whose loved ones work there," he told ABC radio.
And it's going to be devastating for the state's economy."
Mr O'Farrell said even if Garden Island was used for tourism, it would never support the number of defence and private industry jobs associated with the base.
Coalition frontbencher Christopher Pyne dismissed the idea as another "Kevin Rudd thought bubble."
"It's entirely uncosted," he told ABC radio.
"It could cost anything up to several billion dollars and cost several thousand jobs in NSW."
Mr Rudd was revealing more details of his proposal to move the navy north over time, in a speech to the Lowy Institute in Sydney on Tuesday.
He says there are many reasons for a relocation.
"Of course the Port of Brisbane is a big port, the Port of Brisbane also has the great advantage strategically of the proximity of the army base at Enoggera, as does Townsville with the close location of Lavarack barracks," he told ABC radio.
Malcolm Turnbull said he would be sorry to see the navy leave Sydney's Garden Island, which is located in his se
at of Wentworth.
He said the decision represented a complete U-turn after the ''realistic'' advice of the White Paper and was just a desperate bid by Mr Rudd for votes in Queensland.
''This is just another desperate effort to shore up support in Queensland and it's another empty promise, uncosted,'' Mr Turnbull told ABC radio.
''Why is Rudd making this announcement today?
''It's obvious that he is worried about losing seats in Queensland.
on 27-08-2013 11:01 AM
Talk about over reaction.
It's a task force that is going to look at Garden Island and then make a decision.
Who did you plagiarise today?
on 27-08-2013 04:41 PM
just the mule, who arrives every day, to put out the garbage.
wot's the bet o'ferrell got straight on the phone to developer/investors to figure out
how much 'e could pocket out of this new deal.
on 27-08-2013 04:49 PM
27-08-2013 05:19 PM - edited 27-08-2013 05:20 PM
Another Rudd Opus Desperandum, knowing he wont be around to deliver or even do a "study" on it.
These antics are so transparent it beggers belief
on 27-08-2013 05:33 PM
@nero_wulf wrote:Rudd's pledge to move navy from Garden Island 'a threat to NSW economy'
NSW Premier Barry O'Farrell has lashed Kevin Rudd's surprise pledge to move navy warships from Sydney's Garden Island to northern Australia as a threat to the state's economy.
The Prime Minister says the move is part of a long-term plan to modernise the navy and respond to defence and security priorities.
But the announcement, which has been costed at $6 billion, is a policy u-turn for Labor, with Julia Gillard's 2013 defence white paper deciding against the move.
Mr O'Farrell says a 2011 review found Garden Island injected $470 million a year into the NSW economy and employed 6700 people, including up to 4000 jobs at the naval base.
"My concern today waking up to this news, without any advice beforehand, off the back of a defence review that said 'don't change the current arrangements', is this is going to be devastating for those families whose loved ones work there," he told ABC radio.
And it's going to be devastating for the state's economy."
Mr O'Farrell said even if Garden Island was used for tourism, it would never support the number of defence and private industry jobs associated with the base.
Coalition frontbencher Christopher Pyne dismissed the idea as another "Kevin Rudd thought bubble."
"It's entirely uncosted," he told ABC radio.
"It could cost anything up to several billion dollars and cost several thousand jobs in NSW."
Mr Rudd was revealing more details of his proposal to move the navy north over time, in a speech to the Lowy Institute in Sydney on Tuesday.
He says there are many reasons for a relocation.
"Of course the Port of Brisbane is a big port, the Port of Brisbane also has the great advantage strategically of the proximity of the army base at Enoggera, as does Townsville with the close location of Lavarack barracks," he told ABC radio.
Malcolm Turnbull said he would be sorry to see the navy leave Sydney's Garden Island, which is located in his se
at of Wentworth.
He said the decision represented a complete U-turn after the ''realistic'' advice of the White Paper and was just a desperate bid by Mr Rudd for votes in Queensland.
''This is just another desperate effort to shore up support in Queensland and it's another empty promise, uncosted,'' Mr Turnbull told ABC radio.
''Why is Rudd making this announcement today?
''It's obvious that he is worried about losing seats in Queensland.
I think he is just trying to stop the boats, poor Mr Sheen can't get anything right
on 27-08-2013 05:43 PM
uncosted = national liberal party policies
on 27-08-2013 05:45 PM
@not_an_eloi wrote:uncosted = national liberal party policies
What ?
on 27-08-2013 05:53 PM
A typical RUDD thought bubble that no one except Rudd knew about.
IN a Harbourside showdown, NSW Premier Barry O'Farrell has lashed out at Prime Minister Kevin Rudd over a $6 billion proposal to move Navy ships from Garden Island.
The pair met 'by chance' at Mrs Macquarie's chair as Mr Rudd was leaving a media conference.
"A phone call would have been nice...4000 (Navy) jobs," Mr O'Farrell said to Mr Rudd.
"Your predecessor knew how to share, her predecessor knew how to share. You should learn to share."
on 27-08-2013 06:21 PM
to which rudd rightly replied
it's a matter of national security.
you've said you wanted more cruise ships