turn back boats policy doomed to failure

 

 

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-18/barrie-on-asylum-seeker-boat-policy-dound-to-fail/4965582

 

 

anybody watch border security - australia's front line    7 network @ 7.30 last evenin'

reality   -  far from wot abbrot and cohorts would 'ave australians believe.

 

why's AMSA's site been gagged from givin' australians current incident reports.   hmmm ..

Message 1 of 134
Latest reply
133 REPLIES 133

turn back boats policy doomed to failure

I was looking at his comments earler. this isn't the first time he's made these points either.

 

Retired Admiral Chris Barrie was required to implement former prime minister John Howard's policy of turning back boats when safe to do so.

Now that the policy is being revived as one of Prime Minister Tony Abbott’s key election promises, Admiral Barrie fears there will be a return to people smugglers sabotaging their boats.

He says previously, people smugglers would destroy their engines to stop the Royal Australian Navy from returning boats to Indonesia.

He says a return to the 'turn back the boats’ policy will put the Navy at greater risk, because they will have to respond to boats that are intentionally scuttled, and rescue drowning asylum seekers. 

“People smugglers will want to frustrate that policy in every way possible, and that will put people’s lives at risk,” Admiral Barrie told ABC Radio's Richard Margetson in Darwin.

“Our people are going to jump into the sea to save their lives and do extraordinary things because they're so compassionate about it.

“I hope no one from our navy or the customs service will lose their lives but it puts people at risk and that is why it's a bad policy, in my view.”

Message 2 of 134
Latest reply

turn back boats policy doomed to failure

Only of they let the Indonesian government bluff them. If the people smugglers scuttle the boats and risk people's lives they must be responsible, our customs should not ever risk their lives to save the people as sad as it might be.

Keep it nice, I might cry if you write anything upsetting (like not)
Message 3 of 134
Latest reply

turn back boats policy doomed to failure

There should be an addition to the "when it is safe to do so"

 

That addition should read the rescue of people put at risk by deliberate sabotage should be carried out only "if it is safe to do so"

 

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 4 of 134
Latest reply

turn back boats policy doomed to failure


@poddster wrote:

There should be an addition to the "when it is safe to do so"

 

That addition should read the rescue of people put at risk by deliberate sabotage should be carried out only "if it is safe to do so"

 


it appears it is almost never 'safe to do so' the entire thing, the policy . its rubbish. the move to hide the actual numbers is virtual confession of that.

Message 5 of 134
Latest reply

turn back boats policy doomed to failure

Perhaps you remember a movie called Blazing Saddles.

 

The scene where the Sheriff put a gun to his own head and says to his would be attackers "Stop or I will shoot" bit like people scuttling their boat as blackmail.

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 6 of 134
Latest reply

turn back boats policy doomed to failure

sovreign borders, the biggest joke since little johnny howard got into office

 

i note how silent the press is on the several boat arrivals since the election....as is the lnp....

 

sly, sneaky and almost criminal they are

 

Message 7 of 134
Latest reply

turn back boats policy doomed to failure

Fiesta, may i ask you a question?

 

 

I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
Message 8 of 134
Latest reply

turn back boats policy doomed to failure

that's exactly what my kids are saying too Fiesta, how come boat arrivals are not headlines any more, nor even making the news., the kids tell me at least 5 arrivals over the past week

 

 

poddy in  respnse to your blazing saddles post ~`what do you think is better about today's policy than last months?

Message 9 of 134
Latest reply

turn back boats policy doomed to failure


@poddster wrote:

Perhaps you remember a movie called Blazing Saddles.

 

The scene where the Sheriff put a gun to his own head and says to his would be attackers "Stop or I will shoot" bit like people scuttling their boat as blackmail.


   and what happens next if you apply that to this situation ?  

Message 10 of 134
Latest reply