Can a buyer give a negative feedback to seller if they don't return the item.

[bazdel1623]

Can a buyer give a negative feedback to seller if they don't return the item.

[sandypebbles]

Yes they can

But if they leave abusive feedback/mention a dispute or otherwise breach feedback policy you should be able to get it removed

Was the reason they wanted to return the item due to a change of mind?

Or did the buyer open a dispute for not as described/faulty ?

[twyngwyn]

maybe the red dot from 6 months ago; if so, smashed item