someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW

i have a previous buyer selling one of my reborns that was purchased from me back in march this year. she has listed it as a NEW item and date of birth as december 2012 and though she has not claimed to have made it she has presented it in such a way on a template so that it appears she is the artist. i have sent her an email telling her that her listing is fraudulent and that i would report her if she did not remove it or adjust her listing. i intend to do this tomorrow if i do not see any changes or response from her but wanted to know ...does ebay block them if they see that they have posted a dishonest listing. am thinking of naming and shaming her by posting her item number and ebay id here as well as a warning to others?? she paid $350 for her, has had her for 9 months. listed her as new and is asking for $525 on buy it now +$35 postage for a used item. maybe i should be flattered??? lol anyone else had this happen? 

Message 1 of 85
Latest reply
84 REPLIES 84

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW

Well said DG.






Message 71 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW

Agree with you DG.



Some of the comments on this thread are an absolute disgrace. There's lots of things I don't understand about the human psyche but it doesn't give me the right to belittle others and make judgemental remarks because of my own lack of knowledge.

Message 72 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW

 Alzheimerโ€™s patients in nursing homes can find them comforting too apparently.


I was reading up on how they can be made to closely resemble a particular real life baby.The idea of having one that looks like my DD did as a baby for her to give to her children (should she have any) is quite a nice idea ๐Ÿ™‚



Re the OP If any listing description and or item condition isn't correct and/or is misleading that is a listing violation isn't it ? 

Message 73 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW

Yes, i agree some people here got unecesariloy nasty and criticla about anybody involved with these dolls.  However, what these dolls are and what they are not is very much relevant to the issue of the current listing.



if you accept that they are all piece of art, and as a such intelectual property of the artist, then they should be signed and only re-sold with certificate.  However, these dolls are made out of a kit, so while one person puts them together and paints them, the basic shape of face and limbs is the creation of the original creator.  I know some people who buy these dolls and the first thing they do when they get them is they take them apart, often "fix" the paint job.


As I already said above; it is very difficult to state what can or cannot be termed NEW here on eBay.  In case of the doll; if a person who paints these dolls finishes one, packs it in a box and leaves it in her cuppoboard before sellinig it, is it still new?  if she sells it and somebody keeps it in their cupboard for 6 months - is that different?  What if somebody makes a doll, leaves it sitting around for 6 months, then decides it is not quite right and so does bit more work on it - what should its certificate say?



Without answering these questions there is no way to answer OP's question about how/what she can report.



As far as "collectibility" goes, it will be the same as those reproduction china dolls that people used to make in 1970s and 80s.  I paid small fortune for couple - few hundred dollars = close to my weekly wage.  We were also told they are collector items; I bought them from the special shop in Bloch Arcade in Melbourne; they were made by recognised "artists".  and I can tell you they are worth zilch.  I have seen one in perfect condition, made by one of the well known people, on eBay early this year, and I think it went for $5.

000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

Voltaire: โ€œThose Who Can Make You Believe Absurdities, Can Make You Commit Atrocitiesโ€ .
Message 74 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW

Totally off topic I know - but I just looked at them. Luv 'em or hate 'em, that is fantastic work, wish I had half of your creative talent OP.

_________________________________________________________

You can't please all the people all the time, so now I just please myself


Message 75 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW


I meant that your post just serves to validate some of the justifications that those particular posters continually use in other threads when denigrating OPs as they seem to delight in doing.



 




Well, it shouldn't have, and was very far from my intention. Perhaps I should have said "understandably defensive", as I in no way condone the condemning of a poster just because they haven't taken every little stab in their stride with a gracious smile and a "please sir, may I have another".



I've seen some people react very badly to criticism in the past, whether it was constructive or not, and that just adds fuel to the fire in threads like this, but I saw nonesuch response from the OP and whether I have a right to or not, I take offense when criticism is levelled at someone for being a little defensive after posts have been made that are bound to hit an emotional nerve. For my money the OP wasn't overly defensive anyway, just had to continually explain what they had an issue with to people who weren't/aren't getting it. 

Message 76 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW

Has the listing changed or maybe I'm looking at the wrong one ?

Message 77 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW

Yes the DOB is now May and says:  Bella Rose is in a new condition and only occasionally taken out of original packaging.

000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

Voltaire: โ€œThose Who Can Make You Believe Absurdities, Can Make You Commit Atrocitiesโ€ .
Message 78 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW


Yes the DOB is now May and says:  Bella Rose is in a new condition and only occasionally taken out of original packaging.




Terrific, OP no longer has any cause for concern. ๐Ÿ™‚



____________________________
"High and low pressure systems cause the day-to-day changes in our weather." ...Metoffice.......


siggie-reported-by-alarmists..............
Message 79 of 85
Latest reply

someone selling one of my custom made dolls as their own and as NEW


but my philosophy is that if I can't understand it, then I am the least qualified to judge it.



 


DG, this is the most sensible thing I have read on the boards for quite some time.  Thanks for this little gem.

___________________________________________________
"if a story doesn't make sense . . . . then it is not true" - Judge Judy
Message 80 of 85
Latest reply