10-07-2015 02:52 PM - edited 10-07-2015 02:53 PM
In days gone by there used to be very knowledgeable Carnival Glass people on the Board. If anybody is still interested Sydney Auctioneers Vickers and Hoad is having an on-line only auction of a single-owner collection of 225 pieces of Carnival Glass (click on link below)
Single Owner Carnival Glass Collection Auction
I know nothing about Carnival Glass, but the estimates are very low, and the opening bids mainly in the $10-$20 range. It would appear you can’t view but can ask for Condition Reports; and it says V & H will provide in house shipping (which they don’t usually do.) The bidding is being handled by Invaluable.
on 13-07-2015 04:20 PM
Thaks siddie. I used to collect. Not as many as that though.
Have mum's when she bought it new in the thirties, lol
Will be a guide (maybe) to what mine are worth.
Didn't see any Australiana in that lot, may have missed it though.
My prized possession is a large amethyst fluted comport
with an emu on it - 20cm high
on 13-07-2015 05:07 PM
What I think is interesting is that 80% of the items have bids already. Of course many of them are very low bids (because the starting price is low) but if the idea is to get rid of a collection, then they are well on the way. I actually think it is quite a clever way to do things; that many carnival glass items would deluge a regular auction, and knowing that auctioneer, he would get very VERY tired of it very quickly. If they are in good condition (and as a specialist collection you would hope/ assume so) (and the ability is there to ask for a condition report) then it probably doesn't matter that you can't inspect, as a dedicated collector would understand what they were buying from the description and photos.
"Will be a guide (maybe) to what mine are worth." Who knows? There are 2 schools of thought here. One is that you are swamping the market, and would do better if the items were drip-fed. The other is that all serious collectors are attracted in one hit; they know what is available and bid appropriately. Went to an auction a couple of weeks ago where there were a large number of Australian etchings (I collect in a small way.) One person bought nearly every one, outbidding all comers, consequently prices were sky-high. IMO it has set an unrealistic bench mark for some fairly run-of-the-mill artists.
"My prized possession is a large amethyst fluted comport with an emu on it - 20cm high".
Sounds lovely. Although I collect Australiana, carnival glass is something I have always steered away from, mainly because I do not know enough about it to be able to be sure I was not buying one of the "repros" that flooded the market some years back. In the same way I steer well clear of Asian works.
on 28-07-2015 06:07 PM
For any who were interested, the results of this auction are on Invaluable, if you have a subscription. I presume V & H will get around to posting the results on their own web site sooner or later.
In brief the vast majority (70-80%) went for the minimum opening bid ($20-30) and there were quite a lot where the opening bid was only $10. However there were only a handful that didn't sell. So if the purpose of the exercise was to clear everything with minimum effort, then it worked.
As I am not a Carnival Glass collector, I don't know whether these prices were about right, or ridiculously low. I am assuming that like all most collectables, the individual pieces would be nowhere near worth what a collector may have paid 20-30 years ago. On the other hand, maybe they were all pretty ordinary pieces, and that was about the right price. There were a few that went over the $100 mark, so I am guessing that like most things, when seen on the Net, competition will mean prices find the right level. I would be interested to hear from anyone who has knowledge in this field. I know Mr Carter tried some time ago to set up premises where individual collectors could place whole collections to be sold, but like most of his ideas, it ended in tears. It almost seems these days that unless your collections are Asian / Oriental, your family will be in for grave disappointment when they come to pass the items on. But that is how it should be really; collections are there to please the collector, not to try and appreciate in value. If they have given you the collector pleasure, then they have served their purpose.