BER A Failure of Global Proportions

silverfaun
Community Member

 

THE $16.2 billion Building the Education Revolution scheme, one of the signature policies of the Rudd and Gillard years, has been condemned as an international case study of legislative and ­bureaucratic failure.

 

A paper by three Australian academics published in the International Journal of Public Administration says the Labor-era stimulus program of building multi-purpose school halls, science labs and libraries highlights the pitfalls governments need to avoid when rolling out large-scale public expenditure programs.

 

It finds the BER did not “adequately capture” value for money and produced “fiscal lag’’ because its objectives to pump prime the economy with expansionary stimulus happened too late and was at odds with the ­Reserve Bank’s restrictive monetary policy.

 

More than five years after the height of the global financial crisis, The Australian can reveal there are still eight public and private school projects to be completed in NSW and one non-government project in Victoria.

 

 “In line with ‘legislative failure’ … it can be argued that the BER program’s economic stimulus purpose was limited, given that the rollout actually occurred after the worst of the impact of the GFC had already hit the Australian economy,’’ it says.

Mr Lewis, who worked for Canberra University as a visiting fellow

 

 

 

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/policy/labors-ber-reforms-a-case-study-of-failure/s...

Message 1 of 9
Latest reply
8 REPLIES 8

Re: BER A Failure of Global Proportions

it was a huge success . there are isolated right -leaning headmasters who disaprove of almost everything, but the majority are supportive of the program and its ourcomes.  you'd have a hard time selling that odd conclusion in this region ..

Message 2 of 9
Latest reply

Re: BER A Failure of Global Proportions

Morning LL, this is not my conclusion but an internationa report.

 

Sorry I can't take the credit for it but it's something we all knew about anyway.

 

BER massive fail.....check

Message 3 of 9
Latest reply

Re: BER A Failure of Global Proportions

i don't need a report from a dubious source. i see the results on the ground in the schools .. the scheme took them out of a dickensian nightmare into the 21st century .. it provided work for thousands of people . success.

Message 4 of 9
Latest reply

Re: BER A Failure of Global Proportions


@lakeland27 wrote:

i don't need a report from a dubious source. i see the results on the ground in the schools .. the scheme took them out of a dickensian nightmare into the 21st century .. it provided work for thousands of people . success.


Makes you wonder how much they were paid for the report that contradicts all others.

Every school I know benefits hugely from the program, public and private.

Message 5 of 9
Latest reply

Re: BER A Failure of Global Proportions

silverfaun
Community Member

What about all the schools that are crumbling and riddled with asbestos, what about all the schools who don't have flued heaters and still occupying demountables.

 

Yes what a great sucess BER was.

Message 6 of 9
Latest reply

Re: BER A Failure of Global Proportions

I've been reading up that Revisionalist scheme.

I'll read more of your posts soon

Message 7 of 9
Latest reply

Re: BER A Failure of Global Proportions


@silverfaun wrote:

What about all the schools that are crumbling and riddled with asbestos, what about all the schools who don't have flued heaters and still occupying demountables.

 

Yes what a great sucess BER was.


the school boards and commitees decided which areas of their schools the money would be spent on. if some schools made poor decisions as to which areas to spend that is down to them really. the nearby primary school didn't build a hall it renovated. an entire floor was able to be used after laying unused for decades.

 

Message 8 of 9
Latest reply

Re: BER A Failure of Global Proportions

Silverfaun, the accountable which was SUPPOSED to go with the Gonski funding as part of the plan would have helped to make sure our money went where it was needed.

That part of the plan (the accountability of use of our money) isn't there now as far as I am aware ?

We just throw our money at education and hope for the best .

Message 9 of 9
Latest reply