Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled

A commemoration for the 50th anniversary of the battle of Long Tan in Vietnam has been cancelled, despite 1000 veterans already being in the country.

 

The Vietnamese government's decision to ban the 50th anniversary commemoration for the battle of Long Tan at the last minute is a "kick in the guts" and not the act of a friend, Veterans Affairs Minister Dan Tehan says.

 

There are now concerns about 1000 veterans who have travelled to Vietnam will be "shattered" after planning and paying for their trips.

 

The federal government is deeply disappointed and is representations at what it says is the highest level to have the ban of Thursday's Veterans Day at the Long Tan cross site overturned.

 

Mr Tehan said the government was advised of the decision late on Tuesday without warning.

"For us to be given such short notice of the cancellation is, to put it in very frank terms, a kick in the guts," Mr Tehan told reporters in Canberra on Wednesday.

 

"I don't think this is the way that you should treat a friend."

 

The Vietnamese government cited concerns about "deep sensitivities" over the battle and the impact the commemorations could have on the local community.

 

It comes after about 18 months of cooperation between the two countries to organise the event.

 

Mr Tehan insists the Australian government was aware of the sensitivities and had planned a "low-key" ceremony.

Memorial events have been held at Long Tan since 1989.

 

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull was trying to speak with his Vietnamese counterpart on Wednesday.

 

"My real hope is that we will see a change of heart by the Vietnamese government," Mr Tehan said.

"One of the bitterly, bitterly disappointing things about what has occurred is the fact that this decision has taken place with such short notice."

 

Vietnam Veterans Association of Australia president Ken Foster said veterans would be devastated.

"To be told at the last minute to sit in their hotel or sit in a bar because they can't go where they want to go - they'll be shattered," he told reporters in Canberra.

 

The Department of Foreign Affairs understands private access to the site will still be permitted.

 

An official party including the Australian and New Zealand ambassadors will still lay a wreath at the cross site on Thursday.

Mr Tehan said the government's assessment was that the decision was based on sensitivities relating to the battle of Long Tan and not any other aspect of Vietnam-Australia relations.

 

Commemorations will go ahead in Australian on Wednesday evening - including at an event at Parliament House in Canberra - and on Thursday.

 

The federal opposition has backed the Australian government.

 

"The cancellation of the service, at such short notice, is shocking and deeply upsetting for the veterans and families from both countries who have travelled to commemorate this important event," Labor said in a statement on Wednesday.

 

https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/2016/08/17/long-tan-cancellation-kick-guts

 

I kind of understand the Vietnamese, but jeez I feel bad for the Aussie veterans that fought in Vietnam. They just don't get the same recognition the men in the  two WW's got.

 

But why would the Vietnamese be happy for Aussies to celebrate a battle against their own people?

 

Message 1 of 14
Latest reply
13 REPLIES 13

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled

imagine if the japanees decided they wanted to bring there veterans to darwin to 'commemorate' their attack in ww2

Message 2 of 14
Latest reply

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled

esayaf
Community Member
Aren't any whales in Darwin
Message 3 of 14
Latest reply

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled

Apparently it's not a celebration, it's a commemoration, according to the Aussie organisers.

Message 4 of 14
Latest reply

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled

One of the pilots of the Darwin bombing, who was captured and was sent to Cowra POW camp; where there was held the 70th Anniversary of the Breakout attended by one of the POWs and families of others in 2014.

 

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-08-05/pows-and-families-mark-70th-anniversary-of-cowra-breakout/5647...

Message 5 of 14
Latest reply

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled

Gallipoli?

 

 

When I was in Vietnam a couple of years ago, I spoke with a younger person about (what they call the American) war.  He said they respected the Aust. soldiers as "warriors", but hated the French as "oppressors". 

Message 6 of 14
Latest reply

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled

Anonymous
Not applicable

Not much we can do about it Icy.  But we can remember the 18 brave Australian men that died that day.  I can't believe it has been 50 years, seems like yesterday.

RIP

 

Message 7 of 14
Latest reply

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled

esayaf
Community Member
18 poor souls lost for no reason at all
Message 8 of 14
Latest reply

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled


@Anonymous wrote:

Not much we can do about it Icy.  But we can remember the 18 brave Australian men that died that day.  I can't believe it has been 50 years, seems like yesterday.

RIP

 


I know! Same here when they said 50 yrs ago I was like: Smiley Surprised

I have to agree with esayaf. What a waste of young lives.

Message 9 of 14
Latest reply

Re: Battle of Long Tan Commemoration Cancelled


@icyfroth wrote:

Apparently it's not a celebration, it's a commemoration, according to the Aussie organisers.


Didn't the Aussies also want to hold a "gala dinner" and some sort of concert in addition to the quiet and dignified remembrance ceremony?

 

I can quite understand and  support the decision of the govt of Vietnam for cancelling this tasteless show.

 

They rightly anticipate its turning into some crass commerical enterprise in future years just as the Gallipoli commemoration has become.

 

 

Message 10 of 14
Latest reply