on 04-07-2014 10:02 AM
So heres the video footage
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBdYvN49eRU
She was angry that two kids did not get up and give her a seat, So she called the police to report it. Then things got a bit crazy as others started, imo, adding fuel to the fire.
She has been charged with using offensive language/
https://au.tv.yahoo.com/sunrise/video/watch/24384893/
In no way do i condone her behavior, but i also dont condone the behaviou of the guy filming it who stirred it up even more by calling her a rude name.
Opinions?
05-07-2014 08:26 AM - edited 05-07-2014 08:27 AM
i don't think she is not 'normal' as in that her behaviour was caused by a mental illness.
she is just a rude person who took her bad day out on kids and then on the adults who intervened
on 05-07-2014 08:31 AM
I must live a sheltered life pepe, I just can't imagine a person talking like that. Makes me glad to be out of the rat race but I guess if there are people who go off like that because of a "bad day" I'll run into one some day.
05-07-2014 08:45 AM - edited 05-07-2014 08:47 AM
@j*oono wrote:
As for the woman, wow, she really lost it. I'm not saying I condone her behaviour because I think it was pretty disgusting but I think everyone attacking her is just as bad. She needs help in a big way.
Joono, this is a regular occurrence on Sydney (city) public transport. I witness at least one incident every week, usually race related or directed at those that can't help how they look (obese people, people with glasses, whatever).
And every few months I will see something about the level of this womans abuse. This high profile (and similar) incident happened only 6 months ago in Melbourne. http://www.mamamia.com.au/news/racism-jeremy-fernandez-jamila-rizvi/#hMyVkdWVz60QsgSC.97 And there have been various recorded similar incidences since.
Not that long ago, I was on a train where a business man was hurling abuse at a young mum and her newish baby. Baby wouldn't stop crying and he went off his nut. A couple of other passengers even joined in by agreeing that she should leave the train. Mum was distressed and crying making it impossible to calm the baby down. A few passengers, including myself, had a go at him and that made us the target of abuse. I couldn't repeat on here what he said to me.
My point being that we would have to offer help to an awful lot of people who go nuts on a train or bus.
I think it has nothing to do with their mental state. But it has all to do with underlying racism that too many Australians have and a sense of entitlement that extends to every aspect of their lives.
on 05-07-2014 08:49 AM
wow martini, I really had no idea how common this is. That poor mum !
on 05-07-2014 08:52 AM
i don't even think this was about racism so much as just ooking for someone to be a witch to to make herself feel better
on 05-07-2014 08:54 AM
More just in the last 6 months. These on trains. And these are only the ones that are filmed. So you can imagine how many others there are.
http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/man-jailed-for-racist-bus-rant-20140117-30zyx.html
on 05-07-2014 09:04 AM
@*pepe wrote:i don't even think this was about racism so much as just ooking for someone to be a witch to to make herself feel better
And that is why I say "underlying racism".
These people are looking to take it out on anyone. Someone from a different race is an easy target. Same with children.
My 2 kids travel with me on the train and then a bus every morning. My son (15 and incredibly polite) always stands up on public transport yet people are incredibly rude to him. Daily he is asked to move, get off stairs, move his bag. Or things that have nothing to do with travel - stand up straight, take your ear phone out, stop playing on your phone. I dont have enough fingers to count the number of times he steps off a train in order to let people on a station alight the train easily and then he gets left behind because they won't let him back on the train. I have told him not to do this anymore as it make him late for school.
My 12 year old daughter sits with me. The train is too crowded to have her squashed up standing next to people she doesn't know and away from me. People will often stand over her expected her to give up her seat even though there are plenty of other seats to choose from. When I point out other seats I get a lecture about manners.
Every year it gets worse.
on 05-07-2014 09:08 AM
THe sadder part is there're plenty out there just like her.
on 05-07-2014 09:12 AM
It's incredibly sad to hear how widespread this behaviour is. It seems some people have trouble keeping there thoughts to themselves and where does all this hostility come from?
on 05-07-2014 09:14 AM
It's called shifting the blame.