Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

http://www.smh.com.au/comment/tony-abbott-opposition-leader-bites-tony-abbott-pm-20140214-32r1i.html

 

The last paragraph was really interesting about pronunciations, that is pretty terrible isn't it?

 

I flicked around the radio and TV dials. No one came within a bull's roar of getting Kerobokan right, let alone the Balinese capital, Denpasar, or the resort precinct of Seminyak. For the record, it's not Ker-Robber-kan. It's Kra-BOKE-un, a light accent on the second syllable, as it generally is with Bahasa Indonesia. D'n-PAHS-ar, not DEN-pasar. I don't expect the commercial lot to get it right but you'd think the ABC might give it a go.

Nitpicking, perhaps. Yet the same reporters are aware they'd be laughed off the air if they pronounced, say, Illinois or Arkansas or Connecticut phonetically. Because it's only Indonesia, developing nation and all that, near enough is good enough. We Australians are hopelessly bad at our neighbours' languages.



Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/comment/tony-abbott-opposition-leader-bites-tony-abbott-pm-20140214-32r1i.html...

Photobucket
Message 1 of 67
Latest reply
2 ACCEPTED SOLUTIONS

Accepted Solutions

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

I think it comes down to a level of professionalism.  the average person may not know the correct pronounciation of place names and people's names but imo journalists and politicians should make sure they are saying things correctly. It is the same with Sochi. one of the morning shows had a very cringeworthy segment about how it should be pronounced which made the presenters  look stupid and ignorant.   it doesn't take much effort to find out correct pronounciations.  

Such is life.

View solution in original post

Message 38 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?


@donnashuggy wrote:

What does it matter?

 

Because it is incorrect. If a child pronounces a word incorrectly they are generally corrected, why not politicians and newsreaders?


I'm with you donna, pronunciation might seem irrelevant, just like correct spelling etc, but language is how we communicate - maybe I'm just a stick in the mud but do we really want it to get to the point where we can no longer understand each other and speak and write in initials. (OK that may be taking the point a little far down the road but it's raining and I'm a little restless.)

Woman Happy

View solution in original post

Message 51 of 67
Latest reply
66 REPLIES 66

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

and our own - Whar are you doin on sundy me and the hubs are gunna go to dha club eh - Woman LOLWoman LOL

Message 2 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

You ever been to Bali Donna? We all laugh at each other's pronunciations of words, the Balineese have no letter corresponding with our letter F so they pronounce it P, they drink Panta and speak on the pone lol. One funny one is also the translation of veal cordon blur the eat Gordon Blue.
"You say potato potarto". 🙂
Message 3 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

Yes I have been but don't really remember. I love the way the New Zealand Sky news always pronounces Maori language beautifully. Well I think they are doing it correctly.

 

This is poor form though for journalists, I hope his article makes them think about getting it right.

Photobucket
Message 4 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

I hope the Pry Minister read that article.
Message 5 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

No-one at the ABC or SBS can pronounce Chile correctly.   The foreign editor of the Australian who often struts his knowledge of Asia cannot pronounce Afghanistan, Pakistan etc correctly.  IMO it is insulting to those neighbours.  We would bristle if someone called our country Australeeah.

Message 6 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

What about the fiefighters battling the fies?

Message 7 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

He is very shallow isn't he? I wonder what he will come out with next as a diversionary tactic?

Photobucket
Message 8 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

What about the fiefighters battling the fies?

 

Pie Pighters battling Pies of course Smiley Very Happy


Message 9 of 67
Latest reply

Did anyone read Mike Carlton this morning?

Hahahaha!
Message 10 of 67
Latest reply