Don't renovators have any taste?

goo**spew
Community Member

I am currently searching for a home - a traditional Victorian or Edwardian/Federation style that has been sensitively renovated and restored - an oxymoron if ever I heard one!

 

Why is it, there are so many beautiful old frontages for sale and then when you click through the photos, the first four are lovely, showing well maintained high ceilings and fireplaces, plaster cornices et al and then you click on the kitchen and there is this laminate open plan monstrocity with horrendous halogen lighting, faux granite worktops and units that look like they were put together by Ikea?

 

Why on earth don't these homeowners or developers consider the original property and simply build an extension that mirrors the front? Fake Victorian fireplaces and imitation antique lighting cost less than this modern nonsense and as for open plan... sheesh, I understand we no longer want cramped living rooms and lean-to kitchens but why don't the designers take the sensibly sized front rooms as a guide, instead of building an air-plane hanger sized living, eating area that in some cases completely gobbles into the garden leaving a strip of grass the size of a nature strip and a view of the back fence a meter from your patio doors? With all that room, you would think the developers could at least do away with those horrible stainless steel features and fridges and washing machines that should be hidden behind wooden doors. And as for the outer extension, at least clad it in wood or reclaimed bricks - enough with the grey render that makes it look like a public toilet block. (*waves to she_ele*) What on earth will future generations think of the designs of this early millenium?

 

The worst offenders are the bathrooms. For goodness sake, buy a copper bath and use imitation old tiling and butler sink basins, anything other than those horrid purple glass bowls that stick up from white plastic shelves. You don't have to be an expert in the era of your home. Five minutes of googling will give you exact ideas on what design road to take. 

 

Personally I love old blue stone/sand stone houses but I have yet to see someone take an old house and restore it to its former glory without adding plasma tv's attached to walls, ducted heating and generic carpeting over beautiful floorboards when a nice persian rug would do the job far more effectively. Don't people realise the 21st century is ugly? You bought an old house - Keep it that way!

 

In all my searching I have only found one place that has not been renovated as described above and that's because they have an original verandah scaling the entire perimeter of the property. And they obviously know what they have as it's priced at least half a million over what it is worth.

 

Surely someone out there shares my disdain for the current slap-it-up extensions?

Message 1 of 124
Latest reply
123 REPLIES 123

Don't renovators have any taste?


@j*oono wrote:

 


I couldn't agree with your more Martini.  There is nothing worse than a beautiful old home with fake imitation fittings and tiles and borders and fake claw foot baths.

A period home can look stunning with a modern revamp.


LOL joono, you are so predictable. I never said imitation fittings were preferable but if someone only has a limited budget so intends affixing a grey toilet block airplane hanger extension, even something as horrendous as a Disneyfied mock Federation would be preferable. But no matter, if I had said I like single story extensions, you would say, tacky, always go double. If I had said, airplane hanger extensions are tasteful, you would have said small, lean-to clad in weather-board. So sad...

 

As for "fake" claw foot baths, I would rather a new, custom made one than some dirty old Victorian original that has seen just how many bodies washed in it? Many cost over $10,000 and are worth it, although I agree that fake light fittings etc look awful, as well as borders etc... but still preferable to an airplane hanger extension, thankyou.

Message 41 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?

I still can't find any decent grooved wood panelling. The stuff Bunnings have is very second rate to say the least. Certainly wouldn't do justice to the flying ducks.

____________________________________________________________

Yes, I have an opinion. No you don't have to agree with it. Yes I do have a right to it.
Message 42 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?

Not sure where you get that from. I've never been jealous of other people's credit cards. I had enough problems with my own ones in the past. And a big plasma? No thanks. Would look most out of place in my little retro shoe box.

____________________________________________________________

Yes, I have an opinion. No you don't have to agree with it. Yes I do have a right to it.
Message 43 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?


@carls*world wrote:

Not sure where you get that from. I've never been jealous of other people's credit cards. I had enough problems with my own ones in the past. And a big plasma? No thanks. Would look most out of place in my little retro shoe box.


 

I thought you lived in a refrigerator box under a bridge? You've downgraded?

Message 44 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?

huh.png

Message 45 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?

the concept of 'taste' is entirely dependent on preference. the idea that one person has superior taste to another is rubbish. i have spent more than a little time in kew myself, and the repro housing you describe i find the antithesis of good taste, but that's only my opinion, aye  spew ?

Message 46 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?


@lakeland27 wrote:

the concept of 'taste' is entirely dependent on preference. the idea that one person has superior taste to another is rubbish. i have spent more than a little time in kew myself, and the repro housing you describe i find the antithesis of good taste, but that's only my opinion, aye  spew ?


We have one or two of them in my home town, LL they are mostly built with drug money, so I'm told.  the locals refer to them as "Monuments To Money And Bad Taste."

Message 47 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?


@lakeland27 wrote:

the concept of 'taste' is entirely dependent on preference. the idea that one person has superior taste to another is rubbish. i have spent more than a little time in kew myself, and the repro housing you describe i find the antithesis of good taste, but that's only my opinion, aye  spew ?


 

Nah, what you describe are the MacMansions of Greenvale. I don't doubtt you have spent time in Kew as there is an upper-class section, middle and naturally, lower...

 

The mansions I describe are in Shakespeare Grove, Hawthorn. Google the street and you will see what good taste is. The "repro" housing I describe is identical to the original Victorian, Edwardian and Federation mansions of the period, using original fittings and building techniques used at the time. If you think these homes are the antithesis of good taste, I would love to know what you think good taste is???

Message 48 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?

We have an old house, it was used by the council as offices before we bought it. The kitchen and bathrooms were pretty much unusable, we renovated it ourselves and yes we even have an original old claw foot bath that was found in a paddock and was resurfaced. Some of our light fittings are original old ones, some are repro. You need deep pockets to be able to buy everything that's original, so some repro stuff had to do. We like it and we're comfortable with it now, it's how we like to live. I am not keen on homes that have that industrial, office feel to them, but everyone's different
Message 49 of 124
Latest reply

Don't renovators have any taste?

Debra, your house sounds lovely
Message 50 of 124
Latest reply