on 05-04-2015 09:52 AM
what is Intelligence?
Are we more or less Intelligent than those who lived 50 years ago?
Are we more or less Intelligent than those who lived 500 years ago?
Are we more or less Intelligent than those who lived 5000 years ago?
Is a person of today who can read, more intelligent than the people of x,000 years ago who recognised the need for written language and set about designing one (well many)?
I am not talking about learned knowledge although that could be a subject all on it's own - I am talking about Intelligence or the ability to reason, learn.
on 11-04-2015 06:24 PM
OK. So given those examples of Intelligence (and Imagination) - ie someone had to be first to 'invent' that idea - what do you think about my original questions:
Are we more or less Intelligent than those who lived 50 years ago?
Are we more or less Intelligent than those who lived 500 years ago?
Are we more or less Intelligent than those who lived 5000 years ago?
on 12-04-2015 05:48 AM
Ummmmm. I'm interested in what people think about this subject. My brain is tired at present. I will get back some time today.
DEB
on 12-04-2015 08:49 AM
I sure wish we as a people had learnt from the mistakes and attrocities of the past............
but seems it is an impossible dream.
on 12-04-2015 11:23 AM
Ok I'll bite.
Wer'e just as intelligent as a species as has always been since humans have trod this earth.
Education has been a major factor, but knowledge doesn't necessarily equate to intelligence IMO. It depends on the curriculum and agenda of what's being taught.
on 12-04-2015 11:51 AM
@lloydslights wrote:I hadn't thought too deeply about those scenarios.
But I remember a primary school teacher telling us that the Aboriginals "hadn't even invented the wheel"
when Captain Cook arrived.
DEB
That just means they had to wait another 170 years before they all got "Toyota desease" !
Re Intel, IMHO, it is all relative to different environments.
on 12-04-2015 11:59 AM
All knowledge can be useless if not applied the correct way, and it still takes imagination to create something new with the knowledge one has.
Knowledge - Imagination - Intelligence.
JMHO, Erica
on 12-04-2015 12:07 PM
Agree.
I just think of times I have spent with Aboriginals, even in the bush some are as thick as two short planks,
even when it stares them in the face.
Where as others, like the lady I spend time with, very intelligent and very motivated as well, real get up and go,
especially when it comes to bush tucker. Some how, the others don't want to learn, just want her to do it.
A dying society - not that I would call it a "society", more like a bunch of people on a drip feed system !
on 12-04-2015 12:39 PM
@icyfroth wrote:Ok I'll bite.
Wer'e just as intelligent as a species as has always been since humans have trod this earth.
Education has been a major factor, but knowledge doesn't necessarily equate to intelligence IMO. It depends on the curriculum and agenda of what's being taught.
I agree that 'knowledge doesn't necessarily equate to intelligence' in the same way that intelligence doesn't equate to knowledge. One can be Intelligent and not have a lot of knowledge AND one can be knowledgeable and not be particularly Intelligent.
Of course, the theory in evolutionary circles is that man is evolving and becoming more Intelligent, which I disagree with. Yes, man is becoming more knowledgeable because of accessibility to past knowledge to learn from.
BUT, where does that past knowledge come from? The answer of course is Intelligent people in past generations have used their Intelligence (and Imagination) to, first of all Learn that knowledge through experimentation (plus expansion of their previous generation's knowledge). With things like advanced communication methods - first of all writing - that learned knowledge has been past on.
Now, with things like the Internet of course, just about all knowledge is easily accessible - this will make us more KNOWLEDGEABLE but NOT NECESSARILY MORE INTELLIGENT.
on 12-04-2015 11:56 PM
I dont think it matters how intelligent or knowledgable a generation is, if that generation doesnt have any common sense to go with it.
Give me a person with common sense over intellegence any day!
on 13-04-2015 08:21 AM
@janeababe wrote:I dont think it matters how intelligent or knowledgable a generation is, if that generation doesnt have any common sense to go with it.
Give me a person with common sense over intellegence any day!
that's very true, but what do you think about the questions?