cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Jane Caro on Julia Gillard

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/jun/27/julia-gillard-sexism-feminism


 


Julia Gillard is a flawed human being. But she wasn't allowed to be one


When she made mistakes, as she was bound to do, her opponents pounced. Our binary view of women at the top was a gift for them


 


It doesn’t explain everything. It doesn’t explain nothing. It does explain some things.


This is part of what Julia Gillard said about her gender as she departed from the office of Australia’s prime minister after losing the leadership ballot last night. In my opinion, her summary is perfect.


Gillard’s problem is that she, like all the rest us, is just a flawed human being. Despite our desire for messiahs, if we’re honest or – dare I say – grown up, it’s the best we can ever get in our leaders. It is my observation, however, after a lifetime spent watching, studying and writing about women and power, that the problem for female leaders is that we are still not yet ready to give them the space to be merely human. We allow them an either/or position only. They can either be inspirational and amazing or terrible, dreadful, the worst we’ve ever had. For women, the difficulty is that there is no middle ground. If you get to the top you better prove you deserve to be there, girlie.


There is still a hint of the usurper around a woman who reaches the top. This works in both positive and negative ways. Difference both repels and attracts. Even those of us who pride ourselves on being "gender blind" greeted the idea of our first female prime minister with an excitement and anticipation that would not ordinarily accompany one of the usual suspects. And it’s not just women leaders who experience this euphoria. President Obama was also burdened by a level of public expectation that could not possibly be met. I suppose we recognise that the degree of difficulty for an outsider is much higher, so we feel that perhaps these people are going to be a bit special. By paying such leaders this compliment, we also inadvertently raise the bar too high.


 


It's worth a read. I've only posted half the story as it's long.


 

Message 1 of 17
Latest reply
16 REPLIES 16

Jane Caro on Julia Gillard


Interesting read, thank you.


Yes, we best get back to our cooking and cleaning she ele......



 


and don't forget the ironing  :^O

Message 11 of 17
Latest reply

Jane Caro on Julia Gillard

ironing......:|


thanks.... best go do it now before the massa comes home for dinner.....

Message 12 of 17
Latest reply

Jane Caro on Julia Gillard


ironing......:|


thanks.... best go do it now before the massa comes home for dinner.....



 


:^O:^O:^O:^O:^O

Message 13 of 17
Latest reply

Jane Caro on Julia Gillard


 


:^O:^O:^O:^O:^O



 


I have been out all afternoon and left the grandsons with OH. So I guess I really do not know my place. I am not even going to cook dinner. He can get his own. Grandsons and nanna are out to Maccas for dinner.

Message 14 of 17
Latest reply

Jane Caro on Julia Gillard

It is a wonder they even gave women the vote, with some of the attitudes you read here from males.

Message 15 of 17
Latest reply

Jane Caro on Julia Gillard


It is a wonder they even gave women the vote, with some of the attitudes you read here from males.



 


I know. Some men think they are the superior ones of the species.

Message 16 of 17
Latest reply

Jane Caro on Julia Gillard


It is a wonder they even gave women the vote, with some of the attitudes you read here from males.



 


They couldn't let NZ show them up for long. Once NZ did our old boys club had to copy.

Message 17 of 17
Latest reply

Type a product name