Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

While Labor wallows in a mess of its own making Tony Abbott is getting on with the job of running the country in a competent manner that we haven't seen for the 6 years Labor was in power, who failed at 99% of their policies & then turned around & blamed it all on Rudd & "dysfunction".

 

There has been no critique of their massive loss & policies failures, they are blindly going along looking at themselves "again" whilst the majority of Labor members look on incredulously &  in disbelief at the blindness & ignorance of the leaders of just why they lost power.

 

This is all not good news for Labor all over again, they have learnt nothing, arrogantly ignore the fact that they failed the Australian people in just about every way & their crowing about the "big reforms" will have to be somehow paid for whilst the coalition struggle with a weakening economy & massive debt burden.

 

Below is an article every Labor supporter should read as it's playing out all over again today.

 

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

 

DURING the 1996 election campaign, prime minister Paul Keating told a radio interviewer that Asian leaders, including Indonesia's president Suharto, would not "deal" with his opponent, John Howard.

 

Mr Keating's speechwriter and biographer Don Watson would later recall there was "a significant element of truth in what at face value looked like lunacy". Mr Keating did not flesh out the idea, Dr Watson lamented in Recollections of a Bleeding Heart, his portrait of the Labor PM: "Asian leaders would not listen to Howard as they listened to Keating. They would not be persuaded as they had been persuaded. The momentum of engagement would be lost. There would be costs to the national interest. All that could be convincingly argued." Mr Howard immediately called it "crazy" talk and even Dr Watson would conclude the remark sounded "at once wrong, arrogant and desperate". Mr Howard went on to govern for almost 12 years, during a period of economic abundance, while deepening and strengthening relations with Indonesia, China, Japan, South Korea and India, against the backdrop of regional crises, terrorist attacks, civil unrest and wars.

 

Three governments later, Labor is making the same mistake about its opponents and its loss: underestimating the leader, repeating follies of the past and failing to learn the lessons from the election result. After a convincing victory on September 7, Tony Abbott is governing with steady purpose and defying the wayward predictions of critics. But as Chris Kenny writes in Inquirer today, Labor and its friendlies in the media are displaying the same anti-Howard whining of the previous era; by focusing resentment on the victor, the same clique, give or take, is now avoiding an examination of its own thinking, policies and behaviours. Blinded by disdain, as they were in the Howard era, the critics are hopelessly out of touch with mainstream sensibilities and the message voters emphatically delivered last month.

 

Mr Howard was once derided as "little Johnny", but not at the end of his premiership; in fact, Kevin Rudd, his successor, won in 2007 with a political persona that promised a younger, kinder and gentler simulacrum of the veteran Liberal leader. Yet when Mr Abbott, to the surprise of most, emerged as the challenger in December 2009, he was immediately dismissed as unelectable. The Australian Financial Review's Laura Tingle wrote of his ascension as "a disaster of epic proportions." In an essay last year, David Marr concluded: "Australia doesn't want Tony Abbott. We never have." During the election campaign, Mr Abbott was lambasted as out of his depth in economics and as a clumsy neophyte on foreign affairs. Many critics were willing him to fail on his first overseas missions, believing that the energetic man who destroyed an inept Labor government was reckless, lacking the grace and intellect to engage the region's leaders and argue persuasively for Australia's interests.

 

Yet the net effect of Labor's taunts and progressive critics' jibes has been a lowering of expectations about the new government -- a bar that has not been difficult to leap for a disciplined unit, as the Coalition has, so far, proven to be. Mr Abbott has adopted the example of his esteemed political mentor about presentation and plain language; he is firmly in the mainstream of Australian life, in the way he thinks and behaves. His mandate is to stop the boats, abolish the mining and carbon taxes, end waste, pay down debt and convene an adult administration. Mr Abbott promised to be calm, measured and steady, leading a government that "says what it means and does what it says." On this standard he will be judged.

 

Labor and its attendant scribes again face the challenge of 1996: accept the verdict of the popular ballot and listen to the electorate's judgment on policy, or fight on into oblivion with rejected ideas. The month-long leadership contest between Bill Shorten and Anthony Albanese, with a winner to be declared on Sunday, has not helped the party on this score.

 

Rather than grappling with the major issues, the combatants have been friendly to a fault, thereby sparing Labor's diehard supporters in the election aftermath from difficult, but necessary, debates. Arguments postponed, however, will not make Labor's reality check any easier, nor will a lack of clarity about their failed policy prescriptions.

Message 1 of 72
Latest reply
71 REPLIES 71

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

didn't you know about the children overboard scandal ?

Message 31 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

Indeed, lightning. Like calling people intellectually moribund,,,, is that name calling?

Iza is correct.
.
Message 32 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

 I hope the author is right really, i want to be wrong. please convince me i am somehow.

Message 33 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

Karen , Maybe I'll take up the attitude that it can't hurt me if I don't understand 

 

I'm thinking that the article in the op fits within The Backfire Model 

 

Message 34 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

im really interested in the "War Criminal Prime Minister" statement 

 

 

yo iza, care to elaborate?

Message 35 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

they weren't my words Ibis ..maybe this was the reason for the title ?

 

Howard is war criminal, says former colleague

July 19, 2004
 

John Valder told a peace forum in Sydney yesterday the invasion of Iraq by the United States-led coalition was one of the great military atrocities of our time.

Mr Valder likened the war to a person breaking into a neighbour's house.

If a person invaded a home, killing one or two of its occupants, and subsequently found no evidence for their bad behaviour, that person would be arrested and imprisoned, he said.

"Bush, Blair, and Howard, as leaders of the three members of the coalition of the willing, inflicted enormous suffering on the people of Iraq. And, as such, they are criminals," Mr Valder said.

"I believe the only deterrent to a repetition of the Iraq situation is punishment in some form as war criminals."

Labor, the Greens and the Australian Democrats also attended the forum, hosted by journalist Quentin Dempster.

 

 

 

read more:http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/07/18/1090089035899.html

 

 

Message 36 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

i quit reading after July 19, 2004

Message 37 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

sorry if you think it old news Ibis .John Howard wasn't PM after 2004 .

Message 38 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

ok now post a link were john howard was convicted of being a war criminal

 

and i wont care what year it comes from

Message 39 of 72
Latest reply

Left misreads Tony Abbott as they did John Howard

 too slow you lot ...2004 should be 2007 

Message 40 of 72
Latest reply