PM makes us a nation without honour

Posted all of it because it's behind a paywall. Woman Happy

 

http://www.theage.com.au/comment/pm-makes-us-nation-without-honour-20140328-35ory.html

 

Who is Tony Abbott? Do we know him? I would not ask these questions, for example, of John Howard. His family was very much fashioned by World War I – both his father and grandfather enlisting (one incredible story has them meeting up, on the battlefield, a few hours before the lethal hostilities resumed). John Winston Howard, born in 1939, got his middle name from Winston Churchill. John Howard is what was once known as an Australian Briton.

 

Born in England, Abbott is a Catholic monarchist – a curious combination. One of his close friends, the late Christopher Pearson, used to hear the Mass in Latin. For a time, I likened Abbott to Guy Crouchback, a character from the pen of the English Catholic novelist Evelyn Waugh, a man with a reactionary and religious bent – hence Abbott's spell in the seminary as a young man.

 

But how do you square Catholic theology with wealthy Australia offloading its asylum-seeker problem to impoverished countries such as Papua New Guinea and Nauru? Cambodia? I'm sure one Catholic who wouldn't buy it is Pope Francis.

 

I always thought Abbott shared, with Julia Gillard, an awkwardness with Australian culture that was expressed, in Gillard's case, through her exaggerated accent, and, in Abbott's case, through the countless interviews he gave as opposition leader in his budgie smugglers.

 

When Rupert Murdoch tweeted his endorsement of Abbott before the last federal election, he described him as a conviction politician. Is he? By his own account, Abbott nearly joined the Labor Party and, prior to him becoming Prime Minister, I always understood him to be a DLP type. Not any more.

 

The DLP has always been clear about what it deems to be moral issues – for example, West Papua. Last year, Abbott described the actions of three West Papuans who climbed the wall into the Australian embassy in Bali to protest about the plight of their people as grandstanding. He then declared that conditions in West Papua were improving. DLP senator John Madigan flatly told him he was wrong.

 

In 2011, journalist John Van Tiggelen wrote an extended profile on Andrew Bolt after the case in which Bolt was found guilty under the Racial Discrimination Act. I saw that case up close through the eyes of a friend, Anita Heiss. Irrespective of the argument about that particular legislation, Bolt's treatment of Heiss was journalistically indefensible and caused deep and repeated hurt. I saw that as clearly as I've seen injuries on the football field.

 

In the aftermath of the case, Bolt was apparently thinking of stepping away from the media when a "very influential person" (Bolt's words) arrived at his house and urged him to keep going. Van Tiggelen established the very influential visitor was Abbott.

Abbott's government is now seeking to alter the Racial Discrimination Act. As has been observed elsewhere, the government's original proposal would have meant that indigenous AFL star Adam Goodes could be called an ape everywhere in Australia but on the football field. Then, this week, Abbott reintroduced knights and dames and, like Henry VIII, the decision was his alone.

 

The Anzac legend becomes more distorted and hyperbolic every year, but there are elements of the story that are important to me. One is that Australian soldiers wouldn't salute the English officers. Why should they? Respect does not come with titles – respect is earned. That belief, as much as any, defines me as an Australian.

 

Now Tony Abbott has reinstated a vain and empty honours system from another time and place. The country, which is outsourcing its asylum-seeker problem to its poorer neighbours, has just reinstituted an order of knights and dames in its society.

 

Where is our self-respect?

Message 1 of 31
Latest reply
30 REPLIES 30

PM makes us a nation without honour

...with an international reputation as backwards and ridiculous 😞

Snippets from UK telegraph:



January 30 2014 | Jonathan Pearlman | News
Australia’s prime minister threatens to deport asylum seekers who spit, swear or “irritate people”



February 17 2014 | Jonathan Pearlman | Earth
Tony Abbott launches fresh attack against climate change action, appointing a “sceptic” to review Australia’s renewable energy target
.
Message 2 of 31
Latest reply

PM makes us a nation without honour

It's not behind a paywall, and I can't see who the author is.   Flanagan?

Message 3 of 31
Latest reply

PM makes us a nation without honour


@just_me_karen wrote:
...with an international reputation as backwards and ridiculous 😞

Snippets from UK telegraph:



January 30 2014 | Jonathan Pearlman | News
Australia’s prime minister threatens to deport asylum seekers who spit, swear or “irritate people”



February 17 2014 | Jonathan Pearlman | Earth
Tony Abbott launches fresh attack against climate change action, appointing a “sceptic” to review Australia’s renewable energy target

 

He is doing exactly what he was elected to do and the only people that dont like it are the losing left and a SPORTS WRITER from the age thats written a page filler of tripe.

 

Just remeber that that there  138 less Labor members of Federal, State and Territory parliaments than in 2010.  138 LESS...... HUGE LOSS 🙂 

 

Martin FlanaganSports Writer for The Age 

 

 

Message 4 of 31
Latest reply

PM makes us a nation without honour

Really, Nero? He was elected to make us internationally ridiculed?

Australia Has Knights Again | VICE United Kingdom
www.vice.com/en_uk/read/australia-has-knights-again
2 days ago - It's a moment for celebration, if only for the fact that it's the first actual thing the Abbott Government has contributed.

.
Message 5 of 31
Latest reply

PM makes us a nation without honour

hhh.jpg

Message 6 of 31
Latest reply

PM makes us a nation without honour

 

He is doing exactly what he was elected to do

 


Wrong he's doing exactly what HE wants to do, he doesn't even consult with his cabinet on his hair brain knights and Dames stupidity.

Message 7 of 31
Latest reply

PM makes us a nation without honour


@polksaladallie wrote:

It's not behind a paywall, and I can't see who the author is.   Flanagan?


?? The writer is clearly there. I pay a sub - I will be asking for a refund.

Message 8 of 31
Latest reply

PM makes us a nation without honour

"He is doing exactly what he was elected to do"

Really? I know lib policy was pretty hard to find before the last election, but I'm certain that no one, not even you nero, had any idea that within six months of taking office Abbott (not even his party) was going to reinstate Knights and Dames.
Hand on heart, can you really say that is what you voted for?
_______________________________________________

Creator of the Most Awesome Thread Topic EVER
_______________________________________________
Message 9 of 31
Latest reply

PM makes us a nation without honour

what worries me is how much more damage can he do to us within the next 2/12 years

Message 10 of 31
Latest reply