Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

http://www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/coming_up.htm


Hope I remember to watch it.

Message 1 of 44
Latest reply
43 REPLIES 43

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

**meep**
Community Member

OK ๐Ÿ™‚

Message 31 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

**meep**
Community Member

 


what false information, LL?  (some of the kids were from my local area :-))

Message 32 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.


 


what false information, LL?  (some of the kids were from my local area :-))



 


just BS regarding school funding.

Message 33 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

**meep**
Community Member

Az, i'm sure I have posted a link to it here somewhere but cant find the thread and cant find the link either but here is the youtube link (goes for over an hour) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yoC67sZzUcs

Message 34 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

**meep**
Community Member

Az, i'll keep looking if you prefer the transcript...its gotta be here somewhere..

Message 35 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

It's ok, I can manage the youtube tomorrow, thank you ๐Ÿ™‚ had to go out and inspect/tour a nursing home.

Message 36 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

**meep**
Community Member

 


Sorry Az. I found  Gillard's transcript from the same forum but cant remember where I found Abbott's


 


I had a look a their website again but only found the video.  http://www.tonyabbott.com.au/News/tabid/94/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/9157/Peoples-Forum-Geelong-Victoria.aspx

Message 37 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

Sorry Meep but I'm not sure there could be any comparison between the 2 shows.


 


Gillard on Q&A answered the questions put to her directly and with no spin and no finger pointing (she didn't mention the opposition or the opposition leader once). She never made any comments along the lines of "when I am re-elected" or any other "me, my, I, our" statements. She brought up policies in direct relation to the questions asked and the language she used was incredibly appropriate to the age group represented. There was absolutely no spin whatsoever.


 


On the other hand, every question Abbott answered was all about demonising Gillard. So much so that 45mins in, someone prefaced their question with "With all due respect, if you could concentrate on your policies rather than how bad the carbon tax is I would really appreciate that." and everyone clapped (it was the only time the audience actually clapped in the middle of the forum).


 


And many of his answers just didn't relate to the question cause he was so focused on bringing it back to the carbon tax or 'illegal' refugees even without a context. He often talked about the 'changes' that would occur under his govt but then failed to follow up with what the changes would be. He just keep saying "there is more we will say. But we will release the information later...". If I was in the audience I would have been screaming out "WHEN???!"


 


It was absolute spin with no substance or committment.


 


 


 


 

Message 38 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.

Couldn't they both be answering genuinely? with no spin.....

Message 39 of 44
Latest reply

Re: Q and A tonight. Julia Gillard and High School Special.


aM watching.      one word


 


 


 


SPIN:-(



 


I hadn't picked you for a masochist.

Message 40 of 44
Latest reply