Re-casting made movies

Are there movies you wish had been re-cast with other actors? How much of a difference do you believe switching a lead actress or supporting actor etc would make to the quality of a film? 

Message 1 of 33
Latest reply
32 REPLIES 32

Re-casting made movies

Kathleen Turner was offered "Ghost" but turned it down at a time when she also really needed a hit. She says the reason she said no was because she "didn't play victims." Demi Moore, who won the role, later turned down "While You Were Sleeping" because they didn't offer her enough money and two years later she was offering her services at a rock bottom price ($1 million instead of $12 million) for "The Bone Collector", and still didn't get the part.

 

Message 11 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies


@secondhand-wonderland wrote:

Thats all very interesting 🙂 The donkey in Shrek was oiginally cast for Chris Farley.  He died half way through the shooting of the film (or sometime early on in the piece) so Eddie Murphy took over the role.  Wonder what Chris Farley was like as Donkey...  He was awesome.


 

Was he that very large comic with blonde hair? I recall he was quite young? That's sad. I guess it's easier to replace an actor when it's voice-over than having to re-shoot half a movie. In "The Gladiator" when Oliver Reed died before end of shooting, they had his head digitally inserted in a few scenes and made him say lines he hadn't yet spoken. It looked very convincing.

Message 12 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies

Julia Roberts, who hasn't had a hit in over a decade, was first choice for the "Blind Side", a part you would think she would have been perfect for as she is a Southerner and a natural blonde. The part won Sandra Bullock an Oscar.

Message 13 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies

Michelle Pfeiffer wasn't the only actor who turned down "Silence of the Lambs". The studio, Orion, wanted "Sean Connery" for the part of Hannibal Lector. Fortunately for film history, the unsexy Scot wouldn't have a bar of it.

 

Get it, bars??? 

Message 14 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies

James Cameron wanted only one actress for "Titanic"... Gwyneth Paltrow. He spent six months trying to woo her for the part of Rose but she was turned off by all the physical demands the part entailed...

Message 15 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies

Speaking of Titanic, David Warner, who played Billy Zane's bodyguard, was originally cast as Freddy Krueger in "Nightmare On Elm St". He had another film commitment which ran into shooting delays so he had to bow out of the horror movie, leaving the door wide open for Robert Englund.

Message 16 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies


@bushies.girl.is.best wrote:

@secondhand-wonderland wrote:

Thats all very interesting 🙂 The donkey in Shrek was oiginally cast for Chris Farley.  He died half way through the shooting of the film (or sometime early on in the piece) so Eddie Murphy took over the role.  Wonder what Chris Farley was like as Donkey...  He was awesome.


 

Was he that very large comic with blonde hair? I recall he was quite young? That's sad. I guess it's easier to replace an actor when it's voice-over than having to re-shoot half a movie. In "The Gladiator" when Oliver Reed died before end of shooting, they had his head digitally inserted in a few scenes and made him say lines he hadn't yet spoken. It looked very convincing.


Yeah thats him, he used to be on Saturday night live and did some funny skits with Adam Sandler when they were younger. He was a bit over the top, but I loved him and found him hilarious, still do when I watch his stuff.  Apparently he lived a life of excess too much alcohol, too many drugs and too much bad food...

Message 17 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies

Scarlett O'Hara.... *sigh*... We've all heard the stories. The two front runners were actually Bette Davis and Paulette Goddard (a co-star in several Chaplin films, she also lived with him "in sin"). Bette Davis took herself out of the running when she accepted the Southern vixen role in Warners' "Jezebel" which was more or less a GWTW rip-off. Before Vivien Leigh came on the scene, Goddard had almost secured the role - in her screen tests she is quite good but she just didn't look like Leigh, nor did she possess her range.

 

Leigh was a unique movie star of the day - a great beauty and a great actress. She just hated doing films and had she not wrangled her way out of her seven year contract with Selznick by blaming the war and spending most of the 40's doing theatre in England, she might just have rivalled Davis as Queen of Hollywood. Such a shame as she was the only actress who had Bette Davis's intensity, but on top of this had unbelievable beauty too, making her the total package.

Message 18 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies

Also in GWTW, Selznick tested a little known actress called Joan Fontaine for the part of Melanie. After the audition she suggested Selznick test her sister, Olivia de Havilland...

 

A year later, de Havilland returned the favour, when unable to get out of her Warner's contract to play the lead in "Rebecca", she suggested Selznick and Hitchcock hire her sister, Fontaine, which made a star of her.

 

Two years later, Fontaine, now a firmly established star, won the Oscar for her role in Hitchcock's "Suspicion" a good four years or so before de Havilland would win. De Havilland, who was a major name by the mid 30's was enraged at being up-staged by her little sister, beginning a lifelong feud which only ended with Fontaine's death in December last year.

 

Incidentally, at the time, both actresses, well into their 90's were two of the oldest living female stars from the golden years of picture making. De Havilland, at 98 lives in Paris and still occasionally attends award shows and screenings.

Message 19 of 33
Latest reply

Re-casting made movies


@secondhand-wonderland wrote:

@bushies.girl.is.best wrote:

@secondhand-wonderland wrote:

Thats all very interesting 🙂 The donkey in Shrek was oiginally cast for Chris Farley.  He died half way through the shooting of the film (or sometime early on in the piece) so Eddie Murphy took over the role.  Wonder what Chris Farley was like as Donkey...  He was awesome.


 

Was he that very large comic with blonde hair? I recall he was quite young? That's sad. I guess it's easier to replace an actor when it's voice-over than having to re-shoot half a movie. In "The Gladiator" when Oliver Reed died before end of shooting, they had his head digitally inserted in a few scenes and made him say lines he hadn't yet spoken. It looked very convincing.


Yeah thats him, he used to be on Saturday night live and did some funny skits with Adam Sandler when they were younger. He was a bit over the top, but I loved him and found him hilarious, still do when I watch his stuff.  Apparently he lived a life of excess too much alcohol, too many drugs and too much bad food...


 

I remember him but I'm surprised you know about SNL, are you American? I lived in the USA for a while that's why I know about the show but I didn't think it aired in Australia, even on cable. I always thought he looked unhealthy - not just his weight but he seemed to sweat and pant alot but I was never sure if it was just part of his act. John Belushi, another SNL member lived a similar life of excess. There's only one way to go...

Message 20 of 33
Latest reply