Reflection on Gillard and the media

Dennis Muller writes about ethical lapses by journalists


disclosure: academic not political writer


 


I have posted the first part of the article. 


 


 


http://theconversation.com/ethical-lapses-by-journalists-contributed-to-gillards-demise-15595?utm_me...


 


An integral power of the media is that of portrayal: the act of determining how people, events, ideas and organisations are described to the public, and therefore how they are perceived by the public. In this way, the media constructs for us our understanding of the world beyond our personal knowledge and experience.


 


For those of us who have never met Julia Gillard, our perceptions of her are based almost entirely on what we see, hear and read of her in the media. These perceptions are then reflected in public opinion polling, and the publication of these poll results tends to reinforce the perceptions. It becomes a self-perpetuating cycle.


 


Eventually, in this case, the poll results got so bad that Gillard’s parliamentary colleagues replaced her as Labor leader with Kevin Rudd.


So of course it is true to say the media played a part in the demise of Gillard as prime minister. The harder question is: did the media play a part that was ethically wrong?


 


Some elements of the media, notably commercial radio talkback shock jocks Alan Jones, Ray Hadley and Chris Smith, clearly did. Their depictions of, and remarks about, Gillard were disgustingly offensive. Not only were they sexist, extremist and malicious, but in Jones’s case involved encouragement of the idea that the prime minister should be dumped at sea.


 


 


 

Message 1 of 80
Latest reply
79 REPLIES 79

Reflection on Gillard and the media


is this the author ?


 


http://theconversation.com/profiles/denis-muller-1865/profile_bio


 


 


..In 2006 he completed a doctoral thesis on media ethics and accountability, and was appointed a Visiting Fellow at the Centre for Public Policy, where he has taught in the Public Policy program since 1997.


He has also taught research methodology at RMIT University, and teaches defamation law to practising journalists through the Communication Law Centre.


 


 


if he can't make those statements and have them given credit ...who can ?



 


Yes, exactly Iza.


 


It was a point of discussion about what happened and journalist ethics. Not an invitation to attack the ex Prime Minister and it certainly was not an attack on anyone in opposition.

Message 21 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media

there is no such thing as "journalistic ethics"


 


Journalists will report on whatever is the flavour of the news on the day, right or wrong.


That's their job.


It will be slanted  according to the opinion of particular journalist, of course, but that doesn't prove the veracity of it.


 


 


 

Message 22 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media

I think there is Icy...that's what Dennis Muller studied and taught and is referring to

Message 23 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media


there is no such thing as "journalistic ethics"


 


Journalists will report on whatever is the flavour of the news on the day, right or wrong.


That's their job.


It will be slanted  according to the opinion of particular journalist, of course, but that doesn't prove the veracity of it.


 


 


 



 


The professor of communications disagrees. 


 


Ethics are covered in journalism and communication degrees.

Message 24 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media

The journalists cods of ethics is here


 


http://www.alliance.org.au/code-of-ethics.html


 


How many of the anti Gillard "journalists" can honestly say the followed this code? 


 


 

.
Message 25 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media

JG during her time in  parliament achieved more than any other PM in history.  Considering that it was a hung parliament, and to get bills passed she had to negotiate with the independents and deal with very hostile opposition, her achievement is quite extraordinary.


 


000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

Voltaire: “Those Who Can Make You Believe Absurdities, Can Make You Commit Atrocities” .
Message 26 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media

So how come the media did not report on that? 

000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

Voltaire: “Those Who Can Make You Believe Absurdities, Can Make You Commit Atrocities” .
Message 27 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media

nero_bolt
Community Member

Just remember FREAK and the luvvies that a MAN in a BLUE tie knifed Julia.  Lots of MEN in blue ties knifed her actually.....


 


I wonder if Penny Ding Dong was wearing a blue tie that day as well... Or something blue anyway 🙂


 



 


 


Just for you FREAK as you seem rather upset by Julias demise and knifing 


 



 

Message 28 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media

 


 



The journalists cods of ethics is here


 


http://www.alliance.org.au/code-of-ethics.html


 


How many of the anti Gillard "journalists" can honestly say the followed this code? 


 


 



 


Oh yes I'm sure there is a CODE OF ETHICS that doesn't mean journalists necessarily follow it.

Message 29 of 80
Latest reply

Reflection on Gillard and the media

They all sign it and agree to follow it. The industry led code of ethics is to prevent governments from legislating a code of ethics. It's a similar reason our free TV has a code of ethics... and most professions.


 


When professions consistently fail to meet acceptable standards, govts will step in to legislate,.. an example of this are the various business codes, ie fair trading.


 


 

.
Message 30 of 80
Latest reply