on 15-01-2014 08:03 PM
Immigration minister Scott Morrison urged to reinstate student visa of neo-Nazi gang attack victim
Minh Duong was almost beaten to death by neo-Nazis on a Melbourne street and with the help of a good Samaritan, was planning to travel to Vietnam to see his family for the first time since the race-hate attack.
But Immigration Department officials have cancelled his student visa.
Minh is now stranded in Vietnam after being accused of overstaying his visa and banned from returning to Australia for three years.
Minh's good Samaritan, piano teacher Adrian De Luca, has started a petition on change.org which already has more than 13,000 signatures calling on Immigration Minister Scott Morrison to urgently intervene and allow the 23-year-old to return to Melbourne to complete his final year of study.
Minh's visa was valid until March 14 this year and he had the necessary documents required to seek an extension – normally considered a formality.
Minh, who was studying for an advanced diploma of accounting at Swinburne University, was attacked on an Ascot Vale street in June 2012 by three members of a neo-Nazi gang.
He was punched, kicked, stabbed and had a brick smashed over his head with such force the brick broke in two.
Minh, who a judge said was almost unrecognisable as a human being after the bashing, suffered multiple cuts to the head, face and body; a fractured skull; a torn left cheek and lip requiring stitches and plastic surgery; stab wounds to the left forearm and lower back; the loss of several front teeth and numerous crooked teeth which required realignment or removal.
He needed facial reconstructive surgery and continues to receive treatment, particularly in relation to his jaw and dental problems.
Mr De Luca, who has helped Minh's recovery by teaching him the piano, organised to travel to Vietnam with Minh to visit his family for the first time since the bashing.
They were at Melbourne airport last Wednesday checking in when confronted by Immigration officials who claimed Minh's student visa had expired.
“Minh was ordered to get on the plane straight away and told he was banned from coming to Australia for three years," Mr De Luca said.
“This is a shocking and cruel way to treat a young man who was subjected to unimaginable violence on the streets of Melbourne.
"I'm shocked and ashamed that our government could treat him this way. Minh simply wants to return to Melbourne, where his brother still lives, and complete his final year of study. That's not much to ask, given the appalling things that have happened to him.”
Mr De Luca said he tried to explain how Minh had been a victim of crime and was lucky to be alive but the immigration officer's response was: "He looks fine to me."
A Supreme Court judge described the attack by a former member of a neo-Nazi gang and two accomplices on Minh as "deplorable", "brutal" and "unprovoked".
Solved! Go to Solution.
on 15-01-2014 10:41 PM
I don't think the attack will have any bearing on the outcome for his reapplying for his student visa though.
Which doesn't mean people don't feel terrible that he suffered such an awful attack.
on 15-01-2014 10:41 PM
not sure Am3 , I'm ashamed that people like those who brutally attacked him on racial grounds exist .The young unfortunately do tend to copy what they see,hear and read around them .....more so at time if it invokes anger
on 15-01-2014 10:47 PM
that was in reply to the questions in your other post
on 16-01-2014 10:47 AM
@am*3 wrote:I don't think the attack will have any bearing on the outcome for his reapplying for his student visa though.
Which doesn't mean people don't feel terrible that he suffered such an awful attack.
Considering that Australia is actually making money on education, and this student would have paid for his tuitions, to have his student visa canceled without being told, and forced to return back to Vietnam to re-apply is just disgrace. Hope Morrison will step in and sorts it out.
on 16-01-2014 12:04 PM
Does he still need more sugery ? If so I think that we owe him that
on 16-01-2014 12:14 PM
@izabsmiling wrote:Does he still need more sugery ? If so I think that we owe him that
if he was here on a student visa. i don't think he would be covered by medicare.
travel insurance should be his responsibility.
i don't think he has been charged for any surgery to date
on 16-01-2014 12:29 PM
He was a Victim of Crime here ...would that have covered his treatment ?....if more is needed ...can he access it in Vietnam ?
Some angry ,bitter ,immature ,violent, self focused,ignorant people here attacked him almost making him unrecognisable as a human being apparently .......
done supposedly because he is different to what these Aussie crims find acceptable in our Country ..
on 16-01-2014 12:31 PM
and he paid for that in one of the most disgusting ways....we should pay for the damage we caused him and work on
NOT DOING THIS IN OUR NAME
on 16-01-2014 12:52 PM
@izabsmiling wrote:and he paid for that in one of the most disgusting ways....we should pay for the damage we caused him and work on
NOT DOING THIS IN OUR NAME
you seem to think we owe everyone something
i did him no harm
on 16-01-2014 01:17 PM
It's about our Country's accountability imo
I hope that there are some answers regarding this because especially given the current attitudes it looks wrong
and like it or not it doesn't reflect well on us as a Country
nor does imo allowing what some believe are known as the Vietnamese secret police into our dentention centres to interograte
question vietnamese detainees imo.
Those who speak/publish publicly and strongly advocate that WE should welcome people like Geert Wilder
play their part in the abuse that man and indeed Australian's of ethnic appearance may suffer due to the acts of Australians .
That is a shame we all have to wear .