on 16-05-2014 08:54 AM
Shorten is playing the lying game again, re igniting the class war and showing Labor has not changed from the Rudd Gillard years of failure and division.
His reply offered no solution to the problem they left behind, the silvertail socialist lecturing the government on how to run the budget staggers belief.
Shorten completely failed this test. He offered no solutions and accepted no responsibility to help fix the mess left by Labor.
on 16-05-2014 11:10 AM
I don't think you quite understand what the budget reply is for.
on 16-05-2014 11:22 AM
Abbott is the one who put the elephant in the room. So he’s really has no one, but himself, to blame for its existence.
Before the last election, when it came to election promises, the expectation was they were given in good faith, on the understanding that sometimes, things happens, which means they can’t be kept. As to mandates, the expectation was that Governments would limit themselves to what they had a mandate to do (express or implied), but again, on the understanding that sometimes, things happens which requires the Government to act in the absence of one. It then was then up to the electorate, at the next election, to decide the bona fides o the explanations given. These were norms accepted by all sides of politics, because all sides benefited from them, and they are the norms which the Abbott government wants it actions to be measured now.
So where’s the Elephant? During his last term in opposition, he, (Abbott), abandoned these norms. Instead from that point onwards promises became sacrosanct and incapable of being being broken irrespective of any change in circumstance. Now governments were bound by mandates or the absence thereof. Then he put the final nail in his own coffin by saying any Government which beaks It’s promises or introduced or amended legislation without a mandate was morally corrupt and therefore had right to govern.
So what happening now. He’s simply being measured against a yardstick of his own creation.
.....................................................................................................................................................................
........new Senate is looking even more precarious for the government agenda with each passing week.
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/comment/new-senators-could-still-block-budget-20140514-zrcn2.html
on 16-05-2014 11:26 AM
The budget reply is to outlay their plans to draw down debt and a vision for the future of Australia. Bill wants to bring back the welfare state, employ more service industry that relies on taxpayer money so same old same old from the old Bill.
All Bill did was rail and rant, whip up fear and start the class war all over again.
I suppose we can expect nothing else from Picket Line Bill whipping up unrest in the workplace after all that's all he's ever done.
Labor must look at the leader and wonder what on earth they did to deserve this hollow man, how could they make this leadership mistake again? The confected outrage that falls flat, the lies and innuendo and the what if's is all he ever does, the phoniness is obvious.
Personally I don't care if they keep him for the next decade, that will cement Labor's stay in Opposition.
on 16-05-2014 11:26 AM
on 16-05-2014 11:44 AM
yes i have ordered my I Bill T-shirt.
on 16-05-2014 12:10 PM
Speaker Bronwyn Bishop is prompted by Christopher Pyne to stop the applause for Bill Shorten after he gives a speech in response to the Budget.
on 16-05-2014 12:13 PM
I saw that, Boris, and I didn't know whether to laugh or shake my head in disbelief, so, I did both.
on 16-05-2014 12:17 PM
Reminds me of "Mum, Muuuuuum tell him to stop laughing - mum, muuuum........it's not fair......mum, muuuum.....
all in a whiney nasally voice.
on 16-05-2014 12:20 PM
on 16-05-2014 12:30 PM
@am*3 wrote:
Did Abbott do any different?
" In his first Budget reply speech as Opposition Leader, Abbott sought to portray the Rudd Government's third budget as a "tax and spend" budget and promised to fight the election on the new mining "super-profits" tax proposed by Rudd."
Yes, I don't think he had a gallery packed full of people applauding him.
The crowd applause seemed to upset Abbott and Hokey.