Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?

BINDI Irwin has been caught up in an animal welfare controversy in the US by partnering with marine theme park company SeaWorld.

 

The 15-year-old Queenslander outraged animal rights groups when she announced on the top-rated US morning TV talk show, Good Morning America, she would be working with SeaWorld to encourage “kids to change the world”.

 

The promotional opportunity comes as SeaWorld fights an image problem brought about by the award-winning film documentary Blackfish, which probed the treatment of killer whales at the company’s parks.

 

“The Irwin family has been exploiting animals for years, so it comes as no surprise that Bindi has agreed to become SeaWorld’s latest shill,” PETA senior vice president of communications Lisa Lange said.

 

“But plastering her face on SeaWorld’s website won’t cover up the fact that orcas, dolphins, and other animals are suffering in SeaWorld’s tiny tanks after being ripped from their families.”

 

Bindi, daughter of the late Steve “The Crocodile Hunter” Irwin, said she was “excited to be carrying on in Dad’s footsteps” and urged viewers to log into seaworldkids.com.

 

Click Here For Entire Article

 

I'm a bit torn on the subject. I'd like to see her be able to work in her field of knowledge and expertise, but I think Steve would not have liked her part of cruel animal exploitation. Isn't that kind of what zoos are about, though, including  Australia Zoo?

 

Also her paycheck would help boost the family income. I've heard  Australia Zoo is not doing so well.

Message 1 of 41
Latest reply
40 REPLIES 40

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?


@kilroy_is_here wrote:
If a small number of captive whales and dolphins can introduce thousands of people to a specie s and raise it's profile to a point that that species is saved from extinction via other far more damaging practices then it's a a small price to pay .
PETA spend so much time and energy protesting against every possible thing in an attempt to make them selfs relevant that they have missed the the opportunity to actually be relevant , working to raise education through these types of ventures can have a massive impact on the survival of a species Steve Erwin knew that hence the showmanship and Australia zoo

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouKBbogpDKE

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uzuSULcqgxQ

 

The man holding the screen at the end of the first clip is Ric O'Barry, owner and trainer of Flipper.  He holds himself responsible for the cruelty in the Sea Worlds of the world, because he started it.  He regrets what he did, and now devotes his life to trying to stop this cruel trade.  He risks his life releasing dolphins and whales from captivity.

Message 11 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?

From the op:
“But plastering her face on SeaWorld’s website won’t cover up the fact that orcas, dolphins, and other animals are suffering in SeaWorld’s tiny tanks after being ripped from their families.”

I am wondering if that is accurate. The bit about being ripped from their families. They get a lot of injured marine life brought in, look after them till they recover and some may be kept on to perform. If Sea World didn't rescue them they would be dead.
Message 12 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?

If you watch the film "The Cove", you will learn that the dolphins are drugged in order to do these tricks. 

Message 13 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?


@icyfroth wrote:

BINDI Irwin has been caught up in an animal welfare controversy in the US by partnering with marine theme park company SeaWorld.

 

“The Irwin family has been exploiting animals for years, so it comes as no surprise that Bindi has agreed to become SeaWorld’s latest shill,” PETA senior vice president of communications Lisa Lange said.

 

“But plastering her face on SeaWorld’s website won’t cover up the fact that orcas, dolphins, and other animals are suffering in SeaWorld’s tiny tanks after being ripped from their families.”

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

"After being ripped from their families"?????

 

This statement is very serious, indeed.

 

DEB

Message 14 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?


@lloydslights wrote:

"After being ripped from their families"?????
This statement is very serious, indeed.

DEB


Watch the clips, and any other clips on the subject, and you will see them being ripped from their families.

Message 15 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?

Azurline: " I think she should do whatever she and her mum think is right for her.
Changing the world via children is a good thing."

I agree with that.
Message 16 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?

Blackfish trailer

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G93beiYiE74

**************************

"There is nothing more; but I want nothing more." Christopher Hitchins
Message 17 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?

I have very little respect for the Irwins - a pack of show ponies.

**************************

"There is nothing more; but I want nothing more." Christopher Hitchins
Message 18 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?


@bluecat*dancing wrote:

I have very little respect for the Irwins - a pack of show ponies.


Not all of them.  Bob is not.

Message 19 of 41
Latest reply

Re: Should Bindi Irwin Partner With SeaWorld US?

There is always an exception. Smiley Happy

**************************

"There is nothing more; but I want nothing more." Christopher Hitchins
Message 20 of 41
Latest reply