What do you think of this idea?

Asian Nannies at half the price.

An no, it's not an April Fools joke, that articles are dated 29/3.

http://www.smh.com.au/national/asian-nannies-one-answer-to-childcare-costs-20140328-35olr.html#poll

 

The cost of childcare has been a political bugbear for more than a decade. But a submission to a crucial government inquiry into childcare has come up with a novel solution: low-cost Asian nannies.

The Indonesia Institute, a Perth-based think tank, says carers from countries such as Indonesia and the Philippines should be allowed to come to Australia and mind children for $200 a week to help ease pressure on family budgets.

Families would provide their Asian child carers with accommodation, clothing and medical insurance. The nannies would also be entitled to Sundays off and a return airfare home for two weeks each year.

 



Message 1 of 46
Latest reply
45 REPLIES 45

What do you think of this idea?

Overall it is a dumb idea (and illegal) and should not even have been included in the papers that went up for review.

Message 11 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?


@i-need-a-martini wrote:

Overall it is a dumb idea (and illegal) and should not even have been included in the papers that went up for review.


I thought it was a racist April Fools gag when I saw it.

Message 12 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?

maybe it is? I can't help thinking about slavery 😞 and 1 day off a week? do they have to live in an attic or a basement too?

Message 13 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?


@polksaladallie wrote:

Already motels, hotels, nursing homes etc, have an abundance of these visa holders, I see this as just an extension of this policy.

 

Some of them don't enjoy their work (to the detriment of others), so it stands to reason the same will occur. 


 

It's hard personally and professionally

for people who do care,value their professional duty of care to others,enjoy and take pride in their work to work with and to have to deal with the consequences of others who don't 

Message 14 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?

to OP, ref. : "...carers from countries such as Indonesia and the Philippines should be allowed to come to Australia and mind children for $200 a week to help ease pressure on family budgets.

Families would provide their Asian child carers with accommodation, clothing and medical insurance. The nannies would also be entitled to Sundays off and a return airfare home for two weeks each year....."

................................................................................................................................................................................................................

 

All sounds good in theory perhaps....BUT those proposing this really should take a visit to some of these impoverished regions and experience for themselves the treatment of children in domestic situations.

It is not pretty.

What is acceptable treatment of children in these cultures is not anywhere what is acceptable in ours. Beatings are acceptable for example. Physical punishment is quite acceptable..........I am saying that culturally there are vast differences.

So what sort of 'training' time for these 457 worker 'nanny's' ?.....you can't wipe out a lifetime of practises in a few weeks.

I am not racist BTW, just being real.

IMO this is asking for trouble.

Some male Govt planner has come up with this idea.....one who has no idea about and does not care about children.  

 

Message 15 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?


@acacia_pycnantha wrote:

That's a real example of how immigration could place a downwards pressure on local domestic wages.

 

No, if anyone from overseas wants to work here, they should be paid the same as locally sourced labour.

 

 


 

I don't know about anyone else but I don't want to hear any more complaints about  Asylum seekers taking our jobs,that we have no room for them blah blah blah

Message 16 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?

Women should stay at home and care for their own children, at least until they're school age. If childcare becomes any more expensive, only the highly paid executive types would find it worthwhile going out to work.

Message 17 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?

What is so new about this ??

 

For years people have been employing Au Pair's from overseas.

Message 18 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?

Maybe we may need to view the overall picture and read the Child Care Policy which the Coalition released late and unannounced pre-federal election 2013 (and take note of that and the fact that fully funded and fully costed claim was just BS put in a pre-election flyer)?

 

 

 

 

Abbott lays out terms for child care costs inquiry

Updated Mon 19 Nov 2012, 

 

He wants the commission to look at whether the current system is meeting the needs of parents as they balance the need for work and study.

It would also take into account the particular needs of families in regional and remote areas, as well as shift workers.

"One of the difficulties that we've got is that our child care system was generally formulated a generation ago when the vast majority of people were working nine til five," Mr Abbott told reporters at a child care centre in Canberra.

"These days, we've got a 24/7 economy and we need a childcare sector that reflects the economic and the family realities that Australians today face."

Mr Abbott was joined by his wife Margie in making today's announcement, declaring he wants the commission to take into account the economic benefits of having more women in the workforce.

He says the inquiry will be broad ranging, and not put things off limits.

However, the terms of reference make clear that whatever ideas the commission comes up with, they would need to be paid for "within the existing funding parameters".

"What I've said is that we need to operate within the current funding envelope," Mr Abbott said.

"

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-11-19/abbott-details-proposed-inquiry-into-childcare-costs/4379418

 

End the bipartisan scorn for voters

Sept 7 2013

 

Unannounced releases late on Thursday of important social policies - indigenous affairs, childcare, women and aged care - also say much about the Coalition's sense of priorities.

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/comment/the-age-editorial/end-the-bipartisan-scorn-for-voters-20130906-2tah...

 

Tony Abbott announces biggest child-care revolution

  Childcare workers asked to hand back wage rise



Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/childcare-workers-asked-to-hand-back-wage-rise...

 

 

Prime Minister Tony Abbott's plan for childcare choice as parents have their say

PARENTS will be asked to deliver their verdict on childcare assistance, tax breaks for nannies, workplace childcare and after-school care in the biggest childcare review in two decades.

Declaring the current 9-5 model for childcare out of touch with the modern workplace, Prime Minister Tony Abbott will today announce a major Productivity Commission inquiry into childcare.

But the inquiry will ask for any fresh ideas to remain within the "current funding parameters'' of the $5 billion-a-year childcare rebate and childcare benefit, raising fears the Productivity Commission may consider means testing of the 50 per cent rebate.

Long daycare, family daycare, after-school care, nannies, au pairs, childcare at work and mobile childcare will be canvassed by the review which will report by October, 2014.

The Prime Minister said the government was determined to ensure childcare was more flexible, affordable and accessible, including for shift workers and families in the bush.

"Our childcare system should be responsive to the needs of today's families and today's economy, not the five-day 9am-5pm working week of last century. More flexible, affordable and accessible,'' Mr Abbott said.

"We want to ensure that Australia has a system that provides a safe, nurturing environment for children, but which also meets the working needs of families.''

Childcare Minister Sussan Ley said the government had no plans to consider means testing the childcare rebate but wanted the Productivity Commission to conduct a root and branch review of the system.

"The current system is causing too much stress on families when there's two working parents, a mortgage and when children are young. It's a stressful time and it never gets busier,'' she said.

 

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/nsw/prime-minister-tony-abbotts-plan-for-childcare-choice-as-p...   Tony Abbott's move to freeze child care claims means fees could double for thousands of families
Message 19 of 46
Latest reply

What do you think of this idea?


@icyfroth wrote:

Women should stay at home and care for their own children, at least until they're school age. If childcare becomes any more expensive, only the highly paid executive types would find it worthwhile going out to work.


So women of calibre should get out of the workforce you think ?

they don't need that parental scheme if that is how you feel

Message 20 of 46
Latest reply