unsporting?

US Open: Naomi Osaka beats Serena Williams in controversial women's singles final

 

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-09-09/us-open-naomi-osaka-beats-serena-williams-controversy/10218766

 

dear serena, when your getting beaten by a better player on the day best not to be a cow and start blaming others.

they wont overturn the umpires ruling and all you get is a reputation of being a bad sport.

Message 1 of 61
Latest reply
60 REPLIES 60

unsporting?


@johcaschro wrote:

 

 

Which half of her is Japanese?

 

What nationality is her other "half"?

 

Is that anything like a blonde, blue eyed, self-identifying aboriginal person being only half (or other percentage) aboriginal?

 

Just wondering.


People were saying that she should have been drawn as Japanese.  That is not what she looks like.  It is not about self identifying, it is about drawing caricature on what person looked like, and giving them size that indicated the importance of the person in the incident; in this case Naomi being diminished by Serena's tantrums.  Both women were depicted lighter than they are and Naomi has her hair bleached yellow. 

Message 31 of 61
Latest reply

unsporting?


@davidc4430 wrote:

i see a common way for cartoonists to show japanese girls looks nothing like a real japanese girl, is it also racist?

1271d0fa5ee941339c5f0d2041b9105b.jpg


Actually, that is how many Japaneese girls would want to look, and some bleach their hair, whiten their skin, they dream of large breasts and have their eyes "fixed". 
whysojapan_instagram_tokyofashion.jpg

 

Message 32 of 61
Latest reply

unsporting?

i know the Cosplay movement,

but i think its kids copying the cartoons not cartoons copying the kids.

 

the serena caricture is exactly how cartoonists depict people, exagerate features for effect.

 

for anyone to call it racists is so out of line.

Message 33 of 61
Latest reply

unsporting?

I thought Knight's cartoon of Serena was hilarious.

 

It was immistakably her.....in the same way that when Tony Abbott was PM he was often depicted as big eared and skinnier than in reality....and of course wearing red speedos. Very unflattering. Smiley Embarassed

 

Apparently depicting someone in a caricature is only racist if the person is 'not white'.

Message 34 of 61
Latest reply

unsporting?

US Open Winner Naomi Osaka Speaks

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEwcMuXmgcY

Message 35 of 61
Latest reply

unsporting?

just saw an ad for chanel 10 sunday night, interview serena by lisa wilkins.

Message 36 of 61
Latest reply

unsporting?

Tennis stats.jpg

Message 38 of 61
Latest reply

unsporting?

seems girls coaches get caught coaching more often than men.

not much else in a girls favour.

Message 39 of 61
Latest reply

unsporting?

Incredible truth about chair umpire in Serena Williams’ controversy

 

https://www.news.com.au/sport/tennis/incredible-truth-about-chair-umpire-in-serena-williams-controve...

Message 40 of 61
Latest reply