That is what I thought yet despite the buyer giving feedback "Received
and does a great job" and getting a working item back after a month,
ebay still found in the buyers favor. Doesn't seem 50/50 to me.
quote from ebay customer support "We didn’t see the original item that
you sent to the buyer and we didn’t we see the item the buyer returned
to you, we are not in a position to take sides in these situations and
verify who has the valid complaint." ...