60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.

http://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/tv-and-radio/60-minutes-reporter-tara-brown-film-crew-detained-i...

 

I hope DFAT manage to get them released, but, reading the article, it is hard to feel much sympathy for them.  I hope they are as frightened and bewildered as those poor children must have been

Regardless of the rights and wrongs of the father refusing to bring them home,  there is no evidence these children were being abused or neglected, yet suddenly, they are swooped on at a busstop by four strange men physiclly snatched from their grandmother's side, bundled into a car and  and spirited away to a secret destination. Imagine the sheer terror that  must have caused  them. And all this is being  filmed - not to mention abetted - by a TV crew whose only motive is to provide  sensationalist entertainment for TV viewers  and  boost  ratings and advertising revenue for the TV channel. 

 

 

Message 1 of 48
Latest reply
47 REPLIES 47

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.


@***super_nova*** wrote:

Reporters suppose to report, NOT stage stories.  This debacle just shows that what ever story 60minutes "covers" there is a high likelihood that some of it, if not all, has been either provoked or staged, with bits of misinformation thrown in to spice it up even more.  That is why I do not watch these sorts of programs.


It is a bit better than ACA lol

Photobucket
Message 31 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.


@***super_nova*** wrote:

Reporters suppose to report, NOT stage stories.  This debacle just shows that what ever story 60minutes "covers" there is a high likelihood that some of it, if not all, has been either provoked or staged, with bits of misinformation thrown in to spice it up even more.  That is why I do not watch these sorts of programs.


you also accused 60mins

of staging the attack in sweden,

claiming the cameraman didn't

have his foot run over which of course,

he did.

 

60mins is not a news service; i like

it because it tells the story behind the

news. 

 

they've covered some really interesting

stories over the years.  one that comes

to mind was about congo. hard to imagine

how any of it was staged.

 

 

Message 32 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.

I feel very sorry for the mother, 

 

if this is true though that channel 9 funded the kidnapping operation then imo they went too far

 

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-04-09/channel-nine-paid-for-botched-child-abduction-statement-says/7...

Message 33 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.

Anonymous
Not applicable

i wonder what that age is? -

 

looks like she had no chance Smiley Sad

 

 

Lebanon is not a party to an international agreement covering such disputes.

And Lebanese law, based on religion, is heavily stacked against the mother once children reach a certain age. Smiley Sad

 

At times during their detention, Nine reporter Tara Brown and Ms Faulkner have been kept shackled together with handcuffs.

At one point, although separated from Tara Brown, Ms Faulkner still had handcuffs dangling from one wrist.

Authorities say, despite earlier media reports, no firearms were recovered when the "recovery team" was detained.

 

And the father's family is politically connected.

His mother is a cousin of the speaker of Lebanon's parliament, Nabih Berri.

 

He leads the Amal movement and has ready access to an enormous security apparatus, which includes control of ports and airports.

 

On top of that, Mr el-Amien told the ABC he knew, to a degree that they were coming because one of the children's iPads still had access to Ms Faulkner's email account and he saw messages detailing early discussion of the operation.

The ABC has not seen that email traffic.

 

Mr el-Amien claims he warned Ms Faulkner not to try to get the children back but did not let her know he had inside knowledge about her alleged plans.

Message 34 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.

Apparently, the kids lived in Beirut for couple of years, then the mother took them to Australia and refused to return, and cut up their passports.  Although the kids were born here, they have dual citizenship.  I do not think that she went to court  to  get custody; so they basically have joined custody as far as Australian law goes, but in Lebanon it is the father who has more rights. 

.

000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

Voltaire: “Those Who Can Make You Believe Absurdities, Can Make You Commit Atrocities” .
Message 35 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.

If the situation and roles were reversed and a Lebanese 60 minutes team in cooperation with the father and a recovery team staged  an attempted abduction on an Australian street and were caught would you

 

A. expect the actions if found in breach of Australian law were brought before an Australian court and defended/prosecuted

 

or

 

 

B Be sympathetic towards the "abducters" and expect that the children should be returned to the father

 

 

 

http://www.mamamia.com.au/dont-assume-children-belong-with-mum/

 

Custody issue are almost always complex. International custody battles are a nightmare. It's certainly not up to any of us to say where the children should be or to decide who is "right" and wrong".

 

But it's concerning when there is an automatic assumption the children are being "rescued'" and returned to their rightful home.

 

 

The family had previously lived together in Lebanon. No doubt their father believes their rightful home is with him.



atheism is a non prophet organization
Message 36 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.

I also note with disdain that the channel nine news reports (starting at % thism morning) of the incidents are dropping the mums cause (and

 

the recovery team) like  hot potatoes... and suddenly it's the 'poor reporters,cameraman and producer stuck in the

 

middle of the ever spreading brown stuff flying off the fan.

 

 

the other side of the fence below

 

http://www.news.com.au/entertainment/tv/finding-my-daughter-the-parents-who-kidnap-their-children-an...

 

Four hundred children are abducted by a parent or family member every year in Australia, accordingto a documentary Bringing Them Home at 8.30pm on 101 East tomorrow on Al Jazeera English.

 

Australia has the highest rate per capita of international parental abductions in the world, averaging two a week.

 

That’s in part because parental abduction is not a crime in this country, unlike in the US and UK.

 

While it’s an offence to remove a child from Australia without the permission of the court or the other parent, it’s not a criminal offence if there are no court proceedings or orders preventing it.

 

 

 

http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/101east/2015/10/australia-bringing-home-151007110008612.html

 

 

 

 

atheism is a non prophet organization
Message 37 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.


colic2bullsgirlore wrote: it’s not a criminal offence if there are no court proceedings or orders preventing it.

 

 


Apparently, the father did go to court in Lebanon and was granted custody there. 

000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

Voltaire: “Those Who Can Make You Believe Absurdities, Can Make You Commit Atrocities” .
Message 38 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.

esayaf
Community Member
The world will be a better place with Tara Brown locked up for a few years
Message 39 of 48
Latest reply

60 Minutes Reporter And Crew Detained in Lebanon.

If the situation and roles were reversed and a Lebanese 60 minutes team in cooperation with the father and a recovery team staged  an attempted abduction on an Australian street and were caught would you

 

i would feel the same.

 

our family law is not governed by

religious courts so hopefully the father

would have other options to have access

to his children.

 

 

i dont blame this father either:

 

 

Four hundred children are abducted by a parent or family member every year in Australia, accordingto a documentary Bringing Them Home at 8.30pm on 101 Easttomorrow on Al Jazeera English.

 

Australia has the highest rate per capita of international parental abductions in the world, averaging two a week. That’s in part because parental abduction is not a crime in this country, unlike in the US and UK. While it’s an offence to remove a child from Australia without the permission of the court or the other parent, it’s not a criminal offence if there are no court proceedings or orders preventing it.

 

It means parents whose children have been taken overseas have little legal power to retrieve them, and there are many stories of bereft mothers and fathers unable to see or contact their children, including Patricia Nunez, who hasn’t seen her two sons since they were kidnapped and taken to Taiwan by their father a year and a half ago.

 

 

Longing to see his only child, Kennedy Kembo spent $50,000 on his quest to find her. His last attempt was paying notorious “child recovery specialist” Colin Chapman to find her. After months of surveillance, there was a lead, and Kennedy and the filmmakers headed to Jakarta to look for his family.

 

 

Chapman’s espionage techniques led them to Kayla, capturing footage of her at her primary school. But there were grave concerns among the filmmakers about what many see as the private investigator’s vigilante techniques, and it started to look as though Chapman wouldn’t be able to simply whisk the little girl away under the eyes of the authorities.

 

In a last-ditch effort to help the desperate father, the film crew went to Karina’s home with her family and banged on the door. They showed her a court order giving Kennedy custody in Australia, and she agreed he could come in and see Kayla.

After an hour together, she finally consented to allowing him access to his little girl. In heartbreaking scenes, Kennedy shows the filmmakers photos of his delighted daughter posing with her daddy.

 

While there are still question marks over why Karina vanished, this family’s story may have a happy ending. Other parents in Australia face never seeing the children who mean everything to them again.

 

http://www.news.com.au/entertainment/tv/finding-my-daughter-the-parents-who-kidnap-their-children-an...

 

Message 40 of 48
Latest reply