on 18-03-2014 07:54 PM
The ABC has apologised to News Corp commentator Andrew Bolt after a Q&A panellist accused him of "racial abuse".
In a discussion about racial discrimination laws last Monday night, indigenous academic Marcia Langton accused Bolt of heaping "foul abuse" on indigenous woman Misty Jenkins, forcing her to withdraw from public life.
Her comments stemmed from newspaper articles Bolt wrote that questioned whether "fair-skinned" people who identified as Aboriginal, such as Ms Jenkins, had exploited their ancestry to make political or career gains.
"Nothing that he said about her was political. It was simply racial abuse," Professor Langton said on the program.
"He argued that she had no right to claim that she was Aboriginal and, like most fools who put this argument in public, we are expected to deny our parents and our grandparents because somebody believes in race theories."
Bolt wrote in a blog that he was "devastated" by the comments.
Professor Langton later apologised to Bolt in an interview with him and broadcaster Steve Price on 2GB, saying that although she does not think Bolt is racist, "he's playing with racist ideas — he goes too far to the line".
Bolt published a transcript of the interview in his blog and called on the ABC to respond.
Last night on Q&A the ABC issued an apology through host Tony Jones, who said that Professor Langton had publicly apologised "so as a result the ABC also apologises for broadcasting her remarks".
But the apology was not enough for Bolt who said it "did not go far enough".
The columnist criticised the apology for "failing to include a specific acknowledgement that claims I'd subjected Dr Misty Jenkins to "foul abuse" and driven her from "public life" were utterly false. "
"But it is a start," Bolt said.
In September 2011 a Federal Court judge found that Bolt breached a section of the Racial Discrimination Act by writing newspaper opinion pieces about "fair-skinned" indigenous people.
The section, which the federal government has pledged to repeal, protects people from "offensive behaviour because of race, colour or national or ethnic origin."
The judge ruled the offending articles were not covered by the legal exemption for making fair comment in good faith, because they "contained errors of fact, distortions of the truth and inflammatory and provocative language".
God it's wonder Tony Jones didn't choke on that apology, lol.
Some interesting comments there down to the right.
on 19-03-2014 01:55 PM
@izabsmiling wrote:It's actually disgraceful that The Jewish Council have been denied a voice here .
edit: no thinking more about it ..it is far more than disgraceful as things currently stand in our Country
I may be wrong but didn't Abbott sign up to a global Racial Vilification document related to Jews last year as part of a UN led agreement?
So that means he is supports the equivelent to 18c against Jewish people around the world but it's a free for all in Australia?
on 19-03-2014 01:59 PM
and so they should too
on 19-03-2014 02:01 PM
andrew is special martini , tone owes him a great deal. tone is possibly scared of short-changing andrew on the deal as andrew controls the minds of a vast number of his supporters as well.
on 19-03-2014 02:43 PM
@i-need-a-martini wrote:
@izabsmiling wrote:It's actually disgraceful that The Jewish Council have been denied a voice here .
edit: no thinking more about it ..it is far more than disgraceful as things currently stand in our Country
I may be wrong but didn't Abbott sign up to a global Racial Vilification document related to Jews last year as part of a UN led agreement?
So that means he is supports the equivelent to 18c against Jewish people around the world but it's a free for all in Australia
______________________________________________________________________________________________
It looks that way doesn't it ? What he does makes him appear as though he has no crystal clear and consistant personal beliefs in what is right and wrong.
18C was introduced to impliment Australia's international Legal obligations to eliminate the promotion and incitement of racial discrimination and hatred.I don't understand how it can be removed ?
Democratic rights and freedoms
Australia’s approach to human rights and freedoms reflects its liberal democratic ideals and a belief in the inherent dignity and the equal and inalienable rights of all people, as set out in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Australia played a leading role in the development of international human rights standards, and is party to six major UN human rights treaties. Australia also engages actively in UN human rights mechanisms and supports developing countries in improving human rights standards, particularly through providing significant support for the promotion of democratic institutions.
Key facts
on 19-03-2014 02:44 PM
@izabsmiling wrote:Abbott observed that there had been a very exhaustive process of consultation and the party needed to reconcile the three points of views. He went on to praise long serving member Philip Ruddock for transforming the relationship between the Coalition and areas of the Australian community, referring to ethnic groups.
“We are the right party to represent a diverse country,” Abbott said.
That would be the Philip Ruddock that told Dr Munjed Al Muderis that he would never practice medicine or be allowed to finish his specialty training in Australia. How lucky for Australia that Ruddock was proved wrong.
on 19-03-2014 02:57 PM
over and over Freaki unfortunately.
I appreciate that Wareen Mundeen may support the clause.
But his twitter remarks re 100 000 or so Australian people during the March on march was not supportive at all
Especially considering why a good number of Marchers were Marching for
19-03-2014 03:05 PM - edited 19-03-2014 03:06 PM
An Indigenous activist spoke of the need for a treaty. I agree. The Coalition is all over the place on Indigenous affairs, with no coherent story to tell. But what Australian government ever had a coherent story to tell about the first Australians?
http://www.independentaustralia.net/politics/politics-display/melbourne-march-in-march,6283
Has Warren Mundeen apologised yet ?
http://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/2014/03/17/thousands-gather-march-march-across-australia
on 19-03-2014 03:19 PM
@izabsmiling wrote:An Indigenous activist spoke of the need for a treaty. I agree. The Coalition is all over the place on Indigenous affairs, with no coherent story to tell. But what Australian government ever had a coherent story to tell about the first Australians?
http://www.independentaustralia.net/politics/politics-display/melbourne-march-in-march,6283
Has Warren Mundeen apologised yet ?
http://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/2014/03/17/thousands-gather-march-march-across-australia
Iza: Has Warren Mundeen apologised yet ?
you mean for this bit?
It seems to me that when we talk about reconciliation in the context of Indigenous affairs, we talk a lot about the sorry part but we don't talk much about the forgiveness part.
"As a nation, Australia and its citizens have taken major steps of remorse and amends, both symbolic and practical."
Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/comment/to-move-on-indigenous-people-must-forgive-20140127-31i9n.html#ixzz2...
on 19-03-2014 03:26 PM
not sure what happened with that link ...I edited it to put the correct one in and it reads correctly in the post but doesn't show the sbs link ...it shows the IA one ?
no Icy , I meant for this
Head of the Prime Minister’s Indigenous Council Warren Mundine weighed in on the debate online, describing the event as a “total time waste” on twitter and its attendees as “w—kers”.
on 19-03-2014 03:35 PM
or this ?
I will start with a statement: “I despise racism, homophobia, religious intolerance, sexism, you name it... I honestly fail to comprehend how human beings cannot be respectful of each other FULL STOP.” I do understand that there are many reasons why people will be bigots or racists and you can’t just wish it away, all you can do is keep working with others to try to stamp it out. Everyday people can assist in this, though good leadership is paramount. So please read this rant in the manner it is intended. It is about respect - or lack of it – insulting behaviour and extremely poor judgement on behalf of someone who should be displaying leadership qualities.
Last night while checking twitter I was horrified to see the following tweet from Warren Mundine:
see link.
Now, I know that David Donovan (Journalist and Managing Editor of Independent Australia) can be acerbic at times, is not exactly well loved by a lot of Journalists and to be frank, when he gets a sniff of an issue can be like a dog with a bone, so my immediate reaction was “OHNO! What did you say David to get that awful response?”. Looking back in the timeline, he said nothing to deserve the above tweet. There are two very serious issues here that make this tweet so wrong.
To be quite frank, “Put ur hood back on” in this context can only be construed in one way and for a man in Mr Mundine’s position to say something so racist is beyond expectation and not befitting of the man who is now the chairman of Mr Abbott's advisory council on indigenous affairs. For any caucasian who is NOT racist, who does care about racism and in the case of David, even has a category of news on his site called “Indigenous Australia” (something a lot of mainstream news sites don’t bother having) to be referred to in the insulting manner of a Ku Klux Klan (KKK) reference is beyond the pale.
http://yathink.com.au/article-display/ffsf-warren-mundines-racist-tweet-is-beyond-the-pale,94