on 25-02-2014 09:18 PM
The new law, which came into force yesterday, has been criticised by religious groups.
But minister for agriculture and food Dan Jørgensen said that "animal rights come before religion".
European regulations require animals to be stunned before they are slaughtered, but exemptions can be made on religious grounds.
Some Halal and Kosher consumers believe it is acceptable for the animal to be stunned before it is slaughtered, but many others insist that the animal is fully conscious when it has its throat cut.
Condemning the Danish change in the law, Israel’s deputy minister of religious services Rabbi Eli Ben Dahan said: "European anti-Semitism is showing its true colours across Europe, and is even intensifying in the government institutions."
Al Jazeera quoted the monitoring group Danish Halal, which launched a petition against the ban, as saying it was "a clear interference in religious freedom limiting the rights of Muslims and Jews to practice their religion in Denmark".
Critics also pointed out that in the same country, Marius the giraffe was shot dead by a zoo because he was surplus to requirements for their breeding program.
Last year, British politicians said that they would not be outlawing religious slaughter despite "strong pressure" from the RSPCA and other bodies.
The organisation for the English beef and sheep industry (EBLEX) has called for two different Halal logos - one for stunned beef and lamb and one for non-stunned - to be introduced to allow more animals slaughtered by Halal to be rendered unconscious.
John Blackwell, president elect of the British Veterinary Association and practising vet, supported the idea, saying: "I think the proposals are all about choice – if people want to consume halal and they don’t have a strong opinion about stunning then they have a freedom of choice to do that.
"Our position remains that animals should all be stunned prior to slaughter such as that they’re rendered insensible to pain at the point of death.
"All the evidence I’ve seen and interpreted suggests there is a welfare issue associated to the perception of pain during the period between the throat being cut and the animal’s loss of sensibility."
Dr Julia Wrathall, head of the RSPCA’s farm animal science department, said: "We want to see all animals rendered unconscious before slaughter.
"Until that time we are calling for clear labelling so shoppers are armed with information that can enable them to make an informed choice about whether they buy meat from animals which have not been stunned before slaughter."
Solved! Go to Solution.
on 26-02-2014 03:24 PM
A friend's husband once worked in a halal abbotoir and compared to standard abbotoir procedure it was more humane. The animals do not see other animals being slaughtered, the animals were kept calm at all times, there was no fear and death was quick.
Nothing like what happened in Indonesia.
I deplore animal cruelty.
on 26-02-2014 04:06 PM
@id-to-post-anything wrote:sounds like you just need to join the Amish 🙂
How about Neolithicism, Erica .
on 26-02-2014 06:51 PM
you people need to do more reasearch
RITUAL halal slaugther is not common practise.
denmark kills mainly only pigs anyway........which muslims can't eat
Oh really, MrGriz?
There are 270,000 Muslims living in Denmark....3.7% of a population of 5.6 million...(Australia is only 2.2%)
There is ritual Muslim slaughter performed in Denmark.
There has not been kosher slaughter for some years because it was not viable for the small Jewish population, who import their kosher meats.
The blanket ban on ritual slaughter is also to stop kosher resuming.
on 26-02-2014 07:22 PM
@thicksozzie wrote:Vegemite since it was first made has always been Halal and Kosher.
All it is is a paste made from Yeast, salt, malt and spices - there are no animal products (thus Halal and Kosher).
So if you liked it before it had that little symbol on it why stop eating it
The moment companies put halal or kosher on their product I boycott completely. Halal and kosher is the promotion of animal cruelty. It is unethical and morally wrong to buy products that encourage animal cruelty.
on 26-02-2014 07:47 PM
Oh boy, She Ele, I had to google the meaning of Neolithicism. Must admit I am ignorant of a lot of english expressions.
Now I furthered my education in a small way again. Very interesting to read about the developement of mankind. Of course before guns were invented, people had to use spears, clubs, stone axes etc., to kill animals for meat. I don't know if they had some rituals or prayers over the animal before killing it, but I could always devise some kind of rhyming verse like prayer and make it a ritual before killing an animal, or the members eating it without the ceremony will go to hell.
And that is all that Halal or Kosher means. A pagan ritual before eating a creature God created, and finding an excuse to be cruel when killing it. I's a sadistic dogma in my opinion.
Erica
26-02-2014 08:08 PM - edited 26-02-2014 08:08 PM
Erica
you obviously have no idea at all what Kosher means.
and firstly, it certainly not only to do with the slaughter of animals. It is FAR more reaching than that narrow view
on 26-02-2014 08:12 PM
@id-to-post-anything wrote:Erica
you obviously have no idea at all what Kosher means.
and firstly, it certainly not only to do with the slaughter of animals. It is FAR more reaching than that narrow view
Sorry, but I do know. Only Kosher is included in this topic about the way animals are slaughtered.
I rest my case.
Erica
on 26-02-2014 08:24 PM
on 26-02-2014 08:40 PM
years ago when i lived in balaklava the deli had kosher and ordinary milk, but the coffee seemed the same.
on 26-02-2014 09:17 PM