Rational suicide:

Beverley Broadbent was not dying of a terminal illness, nor was she depressed or unhappy. But at 83, she wanted to die.


After living a rich and satisfying life, the Brighton East woman said the ageing process had come to feel like a disease that was robbing her of her physical and mental fitness. In February, she said she had had enough.


 


''I look well and I walk well so people think I'm fine. But I have so many things wrong with me,'' she said. ''The balance is gone. It's taking so much time for me to keep fit to enjoy myself that there's not enough time to enjoy myself.''


 


In several interviews with Fairfax Media, Ms Broadbent said she planned to take her own life so she could have a peaceful, dignified death. She said she did not want her health to deteriorate to the point where she had dementia or found herself in a nursing home with no way out.


 


The environmental activist chose to tell her story because she believed many elderly people wanted to die when they felt their life was complete, but lacked the means to go gently.




Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/rational-suicide-why-beverley-broadbent-chose-to-die-20130401-2h34...


 


 


 




Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/rational-suicide-why-beverley-broadbent-chose-to-die-20130401-2h34...

Message 1 of 175
Latest reply
174 REPLIES 174

Re: Rational suicide:


 


Moorna, I hope that you are in a better place now. You must be amazingly strong. I have been married for almost 50 years and don,t .know how I would handle it if he wasn't,  here anymore.



 


It definately isn`t easy & like Twinkle my life wouldn`t have much purpose if I didn`t have my daughters & grandkids either..

Message 131 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:


Gosh Moorna, I'm so sorry to hear that. If you ever need to talk :-x 



 


Thanks Meep, I may just take you up on the offer sometime :-x


 


That accident was years ago but I still sometimes try to run the whole thing through my mind again to try and work out if there's was any way I could have avoided hitting that car, thereby avoiding the needless deaths of two young people, but I know it just wasn't humanly possible in the cold light of day.


The inquest decided somehow that the car driver fell to sleep at the wheel or some such, but I don't know how they work those sorts of things out.


I can tell you that my confidence as a previously clean record lifetime truck driver was totally shattered for a long time afterward.


 


I spoke to a train driver a couple or so years back who'd been the driver of a goods train when a lady was killed in her car on a level crossing as his train appraoched it.


He did commit suicide shortly after I met him because he just couldn't get past the fact that he was invovled in her death and felt so much guilt over it all, even though he was proved to be totally free of blame.


 


I came to the conclusion then that the mind is a strange bit of gear where what may seem right aand proper for one person just doesn't corrulate for another one, especially when feelings of guilt get mixed in.


 


Although I served in the military as a far younger man I never went into a war zone, but I can well understand why so many poor sods who have done go through such horror times afterward, even to the point of suiciding years afterward.


 


One of the strangest suicides I ever got to know about after the fact was that of a school headmaster who unbeknowingly to others suffered manic depression.


The thing that finally tipped him over the edge you'd have thought would have been a good reason to stop him, a simple apologetic approach from another bloke for having parked his car in the schoolyard gateway overnight.


The school teacher seemed pretty good about it at the time, but laid his neck on a traintrack two nights later after leaving a note telling of his own guilty feelings about him having gone so nuts at the car parking offender, then not being able to handle the friendly appology and handshake.


 


I doubt anyone could have talked any of them out of it though because trying to live with certain horrors playing around in the old brain matter can be the hardest thing to do for some of us.

Message 132 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:

**meep**
Community Member

😞  The only advice I can offer right now Moorna is that we have to accept we have no control over certain things and with help we need to find strength to carry on.  I know its easier said than done, I carry a lot of guilt as well...

Message 133 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:


😞  The only advice I can offer right now Moorna is that we have to accept we have no control over certain things and with help we need to find strength to carry on.  I know its easier said than done, I carry a lot of guilt as well...



 


I'm confident we all do Meep :-x


 


Talking it out is often the most difficult task though, and doing it with those closest to you often proves to be more difficult too.


I know that for a fact, and this is the first time ever I've really opened up on such things, so someone around here has a lot for me to thank them for I guess.

Message 134 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:

you wanted to neck yourself, mate, you weren't in a mental state to rationally suicide, is wot this thread is about.  


 


how's about not hi-jackin' somebody else's thread to talk about yourself (again).

Message 135 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:

As predicted, the first badmouther just turned up 😉


 


But wait, there'll be more right along soon :^O

Message 136 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:

met 'em all, mourner, per'aps you've been 'ere before, in a diffo. dress, though   :^O

Message 137 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:


How would posters feel if it was their Mother (that they loved) who decided to do this at 80+ years    I wouldn't want my mother to do this.


 


Am*3......It is not about YOU.  It is about a rational thinking elderly  person's personal choice.


Maybe if you are lucky enough to survive until your 80's you may feel differently and not have the selfish view you now have.


Would you feel more comfortable to watch someone you love live in pain or dementia so your precious feelings are not offended?.


Many older people know when their time is up and want to go out on a high note


.


Some people just don't get it !



 


My opinion is about ME. That is what it is, my opinion and I am entitled to express it. Just as anyone with opposing views is entitled to express theirs.


 


Would you feel more comfortable to watch someone you love live in pain or dementia so your precious feelings are not offended?.


 


I have already posted my mother is in her 90's, lives in a retirement home, has dementia and diabetes. She has expressed no desire to leave this earth by unnatural means (she still has her own mind, she is not ''away with the fairies'). She has slowed down physically in the last few months but still gets joy from family visiting, family living far away posting photo books etc to her of their children.


 


Anyone in chronic physical pain daily would be under close medical supervision and I would  be listen to their advice. I don't believe there are 100's or 1000's of  elderly people out there in extreme physical pain everyday. Most have aches and pains and take medicine everyday to keep it under control.


 


I don't think you need to be sarcastic and call my feelings 'precious'. It has no effect on you what my opinion of rational suicide is.


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 

Message 138 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:

No matter how old I do or don't get rational (or any) suicide will never be an option I would take.


 

Message 139 of 175
Latest reply

Re: Rational suicide:


No matter how old I do or don't get rational (or any) suicide will never be an option I would take.


 



 


Serious question.


 


Why?


Some people can go their whole lives and never really live for a single minute.
Message 140 of 175
Latest reply